Horrific-Terrific - 👎 Violent = Viral
👎 Violent = ViralTexas content moderation law broken by Twitch’s removal of Buffalo live stream | Activision-Blizzard release a backward ‘diversity tool’Hello best online friends — you may have noticed I’ve moved to Substack. I outlined the reasons in this tweet thread but the TLDR is that Ghost is expensive and featureless, and Substack is free and actually has an audience. If you unsubscribed since last week’s newsletter and you are seeing this, sorry — you got caught in the migration of my subscriber list (Ghost doesn’t notify me when I lose subscribers…). If you unsubscribe now you’ll never hear from me again! This week was seriously something I could have done without 👎 which is really annoying because it was also my birthday. Fuck you, tech news. The reasons for this rating:
🤪 10/10 for ‘culture’Right, it’s time to talk about Activision Blizzard because this newsletter has ignored them for way too long. Some background info for you:
Anyway, now that you have that every important and totally relevant context, you might be interested to learn about AB’s new diversity tool. Further no-background: AB have had huge diversity problems which have resulted in scandals and lawsuits (this gamer website even called their CEO ‘a piece of shit’). So, their 80% white male workforce decided to do something about it: they shouted about their internal diversity tool. From a PR perspective, that was their first mistake. But from a normal, non-dumbass perspective, their first mistake was failing to replace the idiot white men in their staff with real people. But anyway, let’s move on. 👩🏫 What this tool is for: AB perhaps want to use this tool (still in beta) to design ‘diverse’ characters for their games. E.g. Overwatch 2, is a game where people of all different ethnic backgrounds and gender identities work together to kill each other — it’s inspired. The tool measures the ‘diversity’ of characters with the following completely inane metrics (out of 10):
Right so let me guess: a cishet white man of average height with no cultural interests beyond watching football would get a 0 on all of these. That means, if you had a team of six characters who were all brown, queer, and fat they would all get very high scores... even though they are all the same? Is that what diversity is? Protip: any ‘diversity tool’ that assumes the neutral ‘starting point’ of all humans is a cishet white man, is not a diversity tool... it’s a piece of digital garbage. Let’s all try and remember that. 🪞 Some reflections on the Buffalo live stream...Last weekend, a white supremacist entered a supermarket in Buffalo and shot and killed ten people. This is bad enough on it’s own, but do you know what else they did? They streamed it live on Twitch, and now nearly a week later content platforms are still having trouble containing the video. Funny how the loudest content moderation expert out there — Elon Musk — hasn’t said a single word about this yet? I suppose we’ll just have to do without his insight for now. 👉 First of all, let’s just think about how you might even moderate a live stream. When someone goes live, it’s entirely possible that the audience (if any), will have no idea what the stream will contain. Certain events have to play out before it becomes clear whether or not the stream should be stopped. Then, it’s up to the audience themselves to do the reporting if they feel it necessary, leaving the rest up to the platform and their response times. 👉 Second of all, let’s look at what history has shown us: response time is absolutely key. In 2019 the New Zealand Christchurch shooting live stream was allowed to run on Facebook for it’s entire 17 minutes. This means, the whole video was available to be shared (which we all know that it was, a lot). Less than 200 people watched it live, and none of those people reported it while it was happening. Twitch say that they took down the Buffalo live stream in less than two minutes (if this is true this is an unprecedented response time) and the live audience only contained 22 people. Even with a response time that fast, and an initial audience as small as that, the video still went massively viral. Conclusion: the challenges of content moderation are too complex for my tiny brain. All I can say is that we’re clearly doing it wrong. You cannot stop a live stream of a mass shooting before any violence occurs, because no one — no matter how many advanced predictive models they have — can actually predict the future, or even how information will flow across the web. The internet’s hugest draw and drawback is that it promises you everything. How many websites have you been to that have a search bar which prompts you to ‘search for anything’? And when you get bored of searching for real things, you can just make stuff up! It’s just a lot. ☝️ One last thing: if you’re worried about the state of content moderation, just get a load of Texas’s new content moderation law — one that I hope no one else copies (that’s how laws work right?). It makes very little sense in almost all directions, but essentially it says that you cannot censor anyone based on their viewpoint, including shared viewpoints of those consuming the content. So... it was the white supremacist’s ‘viewpoint’ that those ten people should be shot, and therefore, Twitch are technically in violation of this law. Sorry to leave you on such a sour note but it’s the weekend and it’s time for me to stop typing and perhaps go outside or something, idk. Byeeeeeee 💌 You made it to the soggy bottom of the post — please share this with friends or colleagues so they can be as smart and well-informed as you are right now. |
Key phrases
Older messages
🤷 Be Quiet
Friday, June 17, 2022
Florida free speech law somehow violates free speech | Google asked to cease collection of location data in run up to expected Roe VS Wade reversal
🌋 It’s Not Fair
Friday, June 17, 2022
Something slightly different this week | Sorry if you were looking forward to the usual thing | Please still like me
👎 GPT-4chan
Friday, June 17, 2022
Content moderators fired for trying to unionise | Elon backing out of Twitter deal | Youtuber 'pranks' 4chan
👎 Inadvertent Leverage
Saturday, May 28, 2022
Whistleblowers reveal that Facebook blocked public services pages in Australia following 'link tax' law 👎 Inadvertent Leverage By Georgia Iacovou – 06 May 2022 – View online → Hello Best Online
👍 Gatekeepers
Saturday, May 28, 2022
Crypto crash (lmao) | Details on the upcoming Digital Services Act | I hope El Salvador are okay 👍 Gatekeepers By Georgia Iacovou – 13 May 2022 – View online → Hello — this week has been rated by me as
You Might Also Like
🖥️ Why I'm Never Going Back to a Windows PC — Tips Before You Buy a Smart Ring
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Also: How to Clear the Moisture Detected Warning on Samsung Phones, and More How-To Geek Logo May 1, 2024 Did You Know A single 1 oz shot of espresso only has approximately 40 mg of caffeine, whereas a
Daily Coding Problem: Problem #1428 [Hard]
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Daily Coding Problem Good morning! Here's your coding interview problem for today. This problem was asked by Microsoft. Given an array of positive integers, divide the array into two subsets such
Top Tech Deals 👀 Samsung Gaming Monitor, Pixel Watch 2, MacBook Air, and More
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Get a discounted M3 MacBook Air or expand your Xbox storage. How-To Geek Logo May 1, 2024 Top Tech Deals: Samsung Gaming Monitor, Pixel Watch 2, MacBook Air, and More Get a discounted M3 MacBook Air or
Infographic | Visualizing Global Gold Production in 2023 🏅
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Gold production in 2023 was led by China, Australia, and Russia, with each outputting over 300 tonnes. View Online | Subscribe Presented by: Access European benchmarks with a trusted 25-year history
⚙️ GPT-5 may be releasing sooner than expected
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Plus: Amazon rebrands AI branch
Noonification: How to Create a CI/CD Pipeline Using GitHub and AWS EC2
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Top Tech Content sent at Noon! Get Algolia: AI Search that understands How are you, @newsletterest1? 🪐 What's happening in tech today, May 1, 2024? The HackerNoon Newsletter brings the HackerNoon
Arc for Windows is better than Chrome
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Adobe bug bounty; Rabbit's first R1 software update; Dream podcaster mic -- ZDNET ZDNET Tech Today - US May 1, 2024 placeholder Arc browser is now available for Windows and it's so much better
Is TikTok trying to get banned from the App Store early?
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
TikTok is offering some users a way to buy its in-app tipping tokens outside of Apple's App Store. View this email online in your browser By Alex Wilhelm Wednesday, May 1, 2024 Good morning, and
Get Compliant in 2024 - Download Ultimate PAM Policy Template Today
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Privileged Access Management Policy Template What are your PAM policies for 2024? Get ready for the New Year Is your approach to Privileged Access Management as current and effective as it could be? In
What's new in Autodesk Inventor 2025?
Wednesday, May 1, 2024