The Deleted Scenes - Benches for Whom?
I’ve been mulling over this piece for awhile, and honestly was hesitant to write it, because, like talking about urban crime, it can open up a lot of cans of worms. But it’s something you have to think about if you write or think about urban design, public space, and the public realm. Not far from our home is the Hunter’s Woods Village Center, one of Reston, Virginia’s original village centers (though very little of its original design is still intact.) Reston is near the western edge of Fairfax County, and it’s very suburban, but the village centers were supposed to be sort of town squares; they included churches, libraries, and public art, as well as neighborhood retail. Reston was part of a movement called “New Towns,” kind of a proto-New Urbanism. Read its history here. Anyway, there’s a Safeway here, a (recently closed) drug store, a bunch of smaller stores and restaurants, a church, and a community center. There’s a high-rise building for seniors behind the community center, and some townhomes right up against the sidewalk leading to the Safeway. There’s a public plaza space where there used to be a few benches. Used to be. Here’s a view of part of the public plaza; the benches were where the concrete juts into the grass. And a closeup: The benches were most frequently used by young Hispanic men. Mostly they’d sit there and shoot the breeze, sometimes into the night, 10 or 11pm. Occasionally they’d get loud. Sometimes they would drink beer. I saw comments on Nextdoor (I know, not necessarily a reliable source) that occasionally women walking by the benches were catcalled. None of this bothered me, but it must have bothered some people, because one day, the benches were gone. (Around the same time, a tall wooden fence was also put up to separate the front of the townhome properties from the sidewalk.) Misanthropic NIMBYs had taken away a public amenity to stick it to non-white people they didn’t like! However that’s probably too simple, isn’t it? I was chatting on Twitter with a young Asian-American woman, about crime in the subway. Both of us are urbanists, both comfortable riding the D.C. Metro. But I had said something to the effect of old Boomers being afraid of subway crime, and she countered that she also had that fear in the back of her head—given, for example, that New York’s rare but horrifying subway pushing incidents have often involved Asian female victims. Sometimes you’ll see comments like, “Americans would rather get rid of all public services than allow a homeless person to access them.” You see this, for example, with train stations that have no seating, or places where bathrooms in stores are almost always closed. Others will counter that you can’t just absorb the infinite expense of maintaining these things when people consistently misuse/damage/vandalize them. I think there’s probably some truth in both of these takes. And I think you can recognize that and still be compassionate. Taking away things that desperate people need doesn’t make desperate people go away. Making something invisible isn’t the same as fixing a problem. Now I mentioned crime, but of course, the guys sitting on the benches and occasionally being a little rowdy were not committing any crimes, nor were they really even creating public disorder. They were doing, I suspect, something perfectly normal and deeply human. The same exact behavior in a bar or at a backyard gathering, for example, is perfectly acceptable (minus hopefully the catcalling.) Or really, anywhere that American suburbanites think of as a social space. But we don’t generally think of strip malls as social spaces, even if there’s a suggestion of a public plaza and a few benches. But what, then, are the benches for, exactly, if you’re not actually supposed to sit there and chat with friends? Are they just there to look at as you pack your groceries into the car, and think to yourself how nice it would be to sit there one day and chat with friends? What kind of sense does it make to take away a public amenity precisely because someone is actually using it? Look, I’m not being blasé about crime and public order, and frankly some urbanists are. But again, that wasn’t the problem here. The problem was, maybe, racism. I think it was probably also a culture clash, and a clash of unstated norms about how space is to be used. Something I wrote in Strong Towns last year is relevant here, I think:
That link, which makes the claim about how Latin Americans use pubic space, was in the Washington Post. I’ve heard that supposition elsewhere too. Also:
Here, I was writing about run-down strip malls that have received a second life as bustling quasi-public spaces largely patronized by immigrants. This is pretty common in more working-class pockets of the D.C. region and, I gather, in other metro areas with large populations of immigrants. But a similar point holds in regard to public behavior. One of the things that has begun to click for me about suburban land use, with its stark separation of uses, is that it artificially renders perfectly natural human behavior kind of suspicious. What we call “loitering” is often what we would call in another context “hanging out,” but again, strip malls are not for hanging out. Why? Why ever would you strictly separate socializing from commerce? Isn’t that kind of bizarre? In a previous post here, I wrote:
I think that explains a lot of this sort of conflict. I do think racism and classism also play a part in these things. And I also think there’s such a thing as a proper way to behave in public. But how we draw those lines is subjective and contingent. What do you think of this? It’s tough subjects like this where I really value your comments, thoughts, and experiences! Related Reading: Thanks for reading! Please consider upgrading to a paid subscription to help support this newsletter. You’ll get a weekend subscribers-only post, plus full access to the archive of over 300 posts and growing—more than one full year! And you’ll help ensure more material like this! You’re a free subscriber to The Deleted Scenes. For the full experience, become a paid subscriber. |
Older messages
NIMBY All Along?
Monday, July 4, 2022
Thoughts on balancing stagnation and total change
Sanctuary
Saturday, July 2, 2022
A little island of nature in Greenbelt, Maryland
New and Old #64
Friday, July 1, 2022
Friday roundup and commentary
Kids and Cars
Thursday, June 30, 2022
What urbanism can do for families, and living on Main Street
The Yugo in Yugoslavia
Wednesday, June 29, 2022
What Do You Think You're Looking At? #64
You Might Also Like
Starting a fire
Thursday, May 2, 2024
John August reminds you that as a writer it's your job to burn the house down. Splash metaphorical or real gasoline all over the place, strike a match and let it fly. You need to burn down houses.
The Anti-Cutoff Shorts Everyone Will Be Wearing In 30 Days
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Summer is coming.
Charge Big Oil with conspiracy, former tobacco prosecutor says
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Following the release of new internal documents, Sharon Eubanks told the Senate Budget Committee that there is evidence for a DOJ climate case against Big Oil. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Clicking This Fake Chrome Update Could Drain Your Bank Account 🚨
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
When to Use a Credit Repair Service. A new Android-based malware is posing as a Google Chrome update and can steal your bank information and more. Here's what you need to know to avoid it Not
‘Help! Our DEI Trainer Won’t Stop Talking About Kink’
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
What's new today on the Cut — covering style, self, culture, and power, plus interviews, profiles, columns, and commentary from our editors. Brand Logo WEDNESDAY, MAY 1 ADVICE 'Help! Our DEI
Build Lean Muscle All Over! Find Out How!👀
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Transform your muscles in six weeks Men's Health shop logo Build Lean Muscle All Over! View in Browser Man doing bent over row with dumbbell Build Bigger Muscles in Just Six Weeks! Build Bigger
Bella Hadid's Seashell Bra Is Peak Mermaidcore Vibes For Summer
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Plus, your May horoscope is here, Paris Hilton takes on the troubled teen industry, & more.
Starbucks is extremely late to the boba party
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Restaurant owners share their funding tips
WIN $25,000 for a dream kitchen makeover!
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Kitchen Makeover $25000 Sweepstakes
New from Tim — "Live 10th Anniversary Random Show with Kevin Rose!"
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
The latest from author and investor Tim Ferriss