How a viral NFT project survived the crypto crash
Here’s this week’s free edition of Platformer: a conversation with Vine co-founder Dom Hofmann about Loot, his viral crypto project from last year. Crypto has crashed, and Loot’s hype cycle has long passed. But there are still some fascinating ideas in there — if anyone can manage to figure out the right way to put them together. Can I brag a little? Between my recent scoop on Instagram walking back unpopular changes, my members-only interview with a former TikTok policy manager, and my investigation with Popular Information on Twitter’s secret donation to the Republican Attorneys General Association, I feel like this summer has been Platformer at its best: news and analysis at the intersection of tech and democracy, on a range of issues important to the industry and the wider world. Do you value this sort of ad-free, independent journalism? If so, it’s a great day to upgrade your membership. You’ll get access to our vibrant Discord server, where this week we’ve been talking about those Mark Zuckerberg metaverse memes. Want to see what we’re up to — while also supporting a solo reporter who loves to wake up each day and do this work on your behalf? How a viral NFT project survived the crypto crashLoot's Dom Hofmann on outlasting the hype cycle, public-domain video games, and why Creative Commons is the futureProgramming note: Platformer will be off Monday as I’m in a full day of meetings about the forthcoming launch of … the podcast! Excited to share more soon. I. A year ago I told you about Loot, a collection of non-fungible tokens that had inspired an energetic community to form around it. A series of brief, text-based descriptions of fantasy genre items like swords and amulets, Loot captured the imaginations of builders and speculators who wondered if the underlying NFTs might someday serve as the basis for graphic novels, movies, video games and more — an open-source art project that could eventually become the foundation of a crypto-flavored Marvel Cinematic Universe. Loot was also the first NFT project that I found personally compelling, at least as a subject for journalism. Its creator, Dom Hofmann, was well known to me as a co-founder of the short-form video pioneer Vine and the idiosyncratic social network Peach. It was an art project more than a startup — Hofmann made 7,777 randomized “bags” of loot available for free to anyone who would pay the transaction fees necessary to mint them on Ethereum. And the project blew up overnight: five days after launch, Coindesk reported, Loot bags had generated sales of $46 million, and had a market capitalization of $180 million. Of course, in those days lots of NFTs were selling for eye-popping sums. What made Loot stand out was the way a community of builders stepped forward almost immediately to begin building out an ecosystem: creating art for the items contained in the bags; forming guilds for people who owned the same “rare” items; and writing smart contracts to let people trade the items held within their NFTs. The dream was that all this would coalesce into something more than the sum of its parts. But 2022 has been catastrophic for the larger NFT market, wiping out the majority of the notional value for even the most richly valued collections. And so as we near the anniversary of Loot’s launch on Aug. 27, I got curious: what had happened to Loot in the year since it went viral? “I think it’s doing well, in the sense that the things that are being built on top of it right now are really interesting, or really ambitious, and in some cases both,” Hofmann told me over the phone Thursday. “A lot of them are closer to the types of things that I thought we might see in the early days of the project.” Hofmann had spent the previous hour and a half on the phone with a developer planning to launch a Loot-related project, something he said he does fairly frequently. His full-time job is running Sup, a 12-person game studio working on various projects that he mostly declined to discuss on the record. But Hofmann continues to lurk in Loot forums, piping up when he feels like he has something to offer, and messages frequently with Loot developers. That development continues despite the fact that the speculative mania around Loot has cooled. The project’s market cap has fallen to just under $6 million, and the price of the cheapest Loot bag available for sale has fallen from about $20,000 when I wrote about it to about $1,438 today. So what are developers building? One project all the people I spoke with pointed me to is HyperLoot, which its creators call a “visual building block on top of Loot.” Essentially, Loot owners log in to its website with their crypto wallets and HyperLoot generates a picture of whatever is in their bag on the body of a digital adventurer. That image might could then serve as your profile picture, the basis for a novel, a character in a game, and so on. Like the original Loot, HyperLoot creations are released under the CC0 “no rights reserved” license, effectively placing them in the public domain. HyperLoot is building a software development kit that will allow people to build using these creations more easily, co-founder Thanakron Tandavas told me over direct messages. The company is also building its own video game, CCO Wars — essentially a Super Smash Bros.-style fighting game, populated by NFT characters in the public domain. Think Bored Apes vs. CryptoKitties, coming eventually to a console near you. “I feel that the same success could happen to Loot like other successful open-source projects that embrace permission-less innovations, [like] Linux or Android,” Tandavas told me. The artist Shahruz, who uses one name, told me about a similar public-domain project he’s working on called 32 Swords. It’s “an elimination reality series” in which players must have both Loot and another NFT known as a Manny. The game is human chess, with each team given 12 hours to discuss and vote on their next move. As players are eliminated, their Loot bags are given away to the other participants or spectators. Shahruz, too, was drawn to the idea of creating art from the public domain. “I think there’s a lot of unique kinds of fun to be had working with existing projects and communities this way, instead of only creating new properties all the time,” he told me. II. So what is there to learn from Loot a year out? One, Hofmann told me, the early wave of hype around the project wasn’t as helpful as you might have guessed. Because the project was public domain, the early days were essentially a free-for-all of people making cheap clones and other associated projects that distracted from the more serious developers. It took a while for the hype to subside and the better projects to rise to the top. Two, early enthusiasts likely under-estimated just how challenging it is for public-domain projects to coalesce. At the height of Loot’s hype cycle, plenty of folks wrote blog posts and tweetstorms about how Loot could form the basis of a video game. But it’s a really long way from writing a list of magical items to shipping Elden Ring, and the entropic forces that can cause multi-year delays for even the best-funded video games are magnified exponentially for games built by part-timers and volunteers. Even in 2021, it was obvious that turning Loot into a video game would be incredibly difficult. But some of the intermediate steps have proven difficult, too. One of the aspects of NFTs that Hofmann finds appealing is “composability”: the idea that blockchain applications are modular and can be joined together like Legos. In the weeks after Loot launched, other developers “composed” various secondary elements meant to work with it in this way: a compendium of beasts in the Loot universe, a list of dungeons, some visual elements, and so on. But the result was a kind of Frankenstein’s monster that was less than the sum of its parts. You can write a new smart contract that attempts to join the pieces together, but as soon as someone wants to add a new piece to the stack you might have to start over. “It's it's really, really, really difficult to make a bunch of pieces of something that are supposed to be related to one another, relate to one another — and also be open to future pieces that need to connect,” Hofmann said. “Being future-proof is sort of difficult.” Three, while much of the focus on NFTs over the past few months has been on crashing prices, Hofmann said that one of the biggest reasons web3 projects aren’t making much progress lately is how expensive Ethereum is to use. Transaction fees routinely run $10 or more to take a single action, making projects inaccessible to anyone other than rich nerds. “Because of that, I think there is a whole slew of use cases — I would even say the majority of use cases — that are not within the reach,” Hofmann said. “Under normal conditions, you're talking about closer to $10 and maybe even $100 to perform a transaction. … The price is prohibitive.” All that said, Hofmann remains deeply interested in the technology. Making films used to be expensive, too, he said — recalling the time when, as a young teenager, he bought a book about filmmaking and learned he was expected to scrape together $50,000 for an entry-level film camera. Today every smartphone comes with a fully capable camera; that barrier to entry has disappeared. And he still likes the basic properties of NFTs: the fact that they represent a piece of data that lies outside an application; the fact that the data has a verified owner; the fact that the data can be transferred to another verified owner. “Those are pretty big inversions of the way most of the internet works right now,” he said. “Removing the value part from it altogether, just thinking about what it means to be the owner of the data and being able to prove that you're the owner of the data. What that enables, just as a technology primitive, it's super interesting. That's not something that exists right now.” One project Hofmann is working on, Corruptions, attempts to build on those properties. It’s a role-playing game that takes place entirely on the blockchain — it doesn’t even have a website — with holders of the relevant NFTs playing by interacting with Discord bots. Among the game’s more outlandish features is the CPC, or “community-playable character,” whose actions are voted upon the community. I don’t know if Corruptions — or Loot — will ever reach an audience of more than a few thousand people. (Hofmann estimates Loot has about 200 developers currently involved in some capacity.) But I’m struck by the degree to which builders developers like him continue working to make something out of the NFT and its strange properties. No one I spoke with today suggested that developers have gotten particularly close to cracking the code — just that it all continues to feel interesting enough to keep working on. A year from now, Hofmann said, there would likely be Loot-related fiction in the world, and perhaps the first Loot-related video games. And as other CC0 projects join the public domain, they will likely continue to collide with Loot in surprising new ways. “It just moves so fast,” Hofmann said of the NFT landscape. “And it changes so much.” Governing
Industry
Those good tweetsThree stages of career development are: I want to be in the meeting, I want to run the meeting, I want to avoid meetings. imagine a crab coming out of the sea pressuring you to kiss a girl you just met two days ago in a jamaican accent Talk to meSend me tips, comments, questions, and surprise Loot drops: casey@platformer.news. By design, the vast majority of Platformer readers never pay anything for the journalism it provides. But you made it all the way to the end of this week’s edition — maybe not for the first time. Want to support more journalism like what you read today? If so, click here: |
Key phrases
Older messages
Inside Facebook's encryption conundrum
Friday, August 12, 2022
The company is moving quickly to make Messenger more secure — but selling it to average users could prove to be a challenge
Twitter gets its hands dirty
Thursday, August 4, 2022
Two years after closing its PAC, the company has quietly begun giving away money again — starting with the Republican Attorneys General Association
What it's like to make policy at TikTok
Wednesday, August 3, 2022
Former policy manager Marika Tedroff talks nudity, China, and a "very toxic" work culture
🚨 Instagram walks back its changes
Thursday, July 28, 2022
Say goodbye to the full-screen feed, and at least some of those recommendations — for now. Adam Mosseri explains why
Facebook rethinks COVID misinformation
Wednesday, July 27, 2022
The company has banned anti-vaxx content for two years. Now it wants a second opinion
You Might Also Like
Why the F We’re Still Doing This, Xiaomi EV Launches, and 12 Startups Raised $320.8M Last Week
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Week of April 7, 2024 - 12 Silicon Valley Startups Raised $320.8M Last Week, Why The F We're Still Doing This, Why an Email Company Makes Sense for Intuit and Xiaomi EV Launch in Guangzhou ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Top 10 Most Funded AI Companies as of April 2024
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Week of April 15, 2024 - 13 Silicon Valley Startups Raised $298.1M Last Week, State of AAPI in Venture Capital and Generative AI Brings San Francisco Back from the Dead. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Race Capital Summit 2024 is a Wrap!
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Week of April 22, 2024 - 14 Silicon Valley Startups Raised $607.3M. How to Pitch Your Startup 101 in Boston. Midjourney + ChatGPT Functionality Launched in WhatsApp. Google Fires 28 Workers. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Top 10 PR Tips for Startup Founders
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Week of April 29, 2024 - 16 Silicon Valley Startups Raised $513.6M. 🔥 Who Could Buy TikTok? 🎨 Sora of China is Born. 👂🏼 The Complete History & Strategy of Microsoft ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Nato turns to spacetech
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Plus: Blockchain startups to watch and the man aiming to build the world's largest network of EVs. View in browser Logo - Zoom_flagship (1) Good morning there, While private investors remain unsure
The Capex Conquest in the Cloud
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Tomasz Tunguz Venture Capitalist If you were forwarded this newsletter, and you'd like to receive it in the future, subscribe here. The Capex Conquest in the Cloud Amazon announced their
62 new Shopify apps for you 🌟
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
New Shopify apps hand-picked for you 🙌 Week 17 Apr 22, 2024 - Apr 29, 2024 New Shopify apps hand-picked for you 🙌 What's New at Shopify? 🌱 Return rules in POS New ⸱ POS ⸱ 3 days ago Market
Linesaver
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
We keep your website up and running, even in times of heavy traffic BetaList BetaList Daily Linesaver We keep your website up and running, even in times of heavy traffic Too much email in your life?
"you been working out?"
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Read time: 1 min, 29 sec a picture of me lasting 1.3 seconds in a cold plunge: Let me get this out of the way: I am not a fitness guru 😆 If you've ever seen me in person, then you've probably
Founder Weekly - Issue 634
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
View this email in your browser Founder Weekly Welcome to issue 634 of Founder Weekly. Let's get straight to the links this week. General Take Two: Eight Hard-Earned Lessons from Repeat Founders on