Horrific-Terrific - 🤷♀️ Digital Exclusion
If someone forwarded this email to you, consider subscribing! Also if you’re already subscribed… consider paying? I write this newsletter every week in my spare time and require compensation, dammit. Thanks :) 🤷♀️ Digital ExclusionA call to pause AI development | ChatGPT plugins are here | More TikTok banning | More Twitter rotHello! Lots of stories this week, aren’t you lucky? This week was kind of like a $5 Amazon gift card (what the hell am I supposed to do with that and why is it in dollars?) 🤷♀️. Scroll down mindlessly for these things:
⏸️ Can we all just PAUSE for a sec?The Future of Life Institute has called on all AI labs to pause experimentation for six months — and there’s even an open letter with over a thousand names on it. I am ALMOST convinced that, in the world of over hyped technology, six months is just about long enough for everyone to forget that generative AI even exists. But, in reality, all that will happen (I mean, if we do get the six month pause), is a brief respite from all the tech commentators going on and on about the risks and benefits of this new technology — yes I am very aware that I am basically describing myself, leave me alone. I am also confused about what this group of people expect anyone to achieve in just six months. Regulators take six months alone just to open an email that might be warning them of the dangers of AI. Then they take another six to ponder over the email carefully. Then another six to maybe draft a white paper about it (but probably not). The open letter itself uses alarming language and makes ridiculous claims, including that the developers of AI should essentially lobby policymakers to regulate it. This is such an unrealistic expectation; usually technologists engage in aggressive lobbying to make it easier and faster for them to deploy their rancid products — so good luck with that! Tbh the Future of Life Institute look like bullshit artists; they say that they “believe that the way powerful technology is developed and used will be the most important factor in determining the prospects for the future of life.” — and so therefore we should do everything we can to ‘improve’ those prospects. Not only is this a horrendously woolly thing to say, but also it seems to take humans (and anything that isn’t technology) completely out of the equation. If you want a more comprehensive breakdown of how misleading this open letter is, read this post from AI Snake Oil. 🔌 ChatGPT has plugins nowWhat does this mean? Basically, if/when these are deployed beyond the alpha and beta stages, you won’t have to interact directly with certain apps or websites — you can get ChatGPT to interact on your behalf. But more broadly it means that ChatGPT is finally going to be able to connect with the wider internet, instead of regurgitating answers from a corpus that only goes up to 2021. Once again I would like to point out that this is a weekly newsletter and as such I ingest tech news basically every day — and yet I am still struggling to keep up with generative AI’s developments, possibilities, and unsolicited productivity advice from tech bros on Twitter. But don’t worry, I’ve managed to wring out my brain to get some thought-juices out 🧃. First of all, without sounding like an irrational evangelist/alarmist, ChatGPT plugins have the potential to change the way we interact with apps and websites f o r e v e r:
I often think that the New and Convenient way of doing every-day tasks eventually becomes The Only Way — and when you only have one way of doing something, you often leave behind those who exist on the fringes of the key demographics that most technology is designed for; the people who maybe have accessibility needs that technologists only think about as an after-thought (or never think about at all!) This is exactly what drives digital exclusion and it needs to fucking stop. When you look at the list of companies currently developing plugins for ChatGPT (e.g. Expedia, Slack, Instacart, OpenTable) it is abundantly clear who this technology is made for, and who it will inadvertently exclude. Employing the use of an effective virtual assistant to book flights sounds perfectly useful and convenient to me, but I don’t have any specific accessibility needs and I also already know how to do that myself. There are 10 million people in the UK who don’t have the digital skills needed to do even the most basic things online — do we really expect everyone to become a prompt engineer just so they can check their bank balance? 🚫 The banning of apps on government devices continues, and nothing materially changesLast week I wrote about the ridiculous intellectual somersaults the US government were doing to position TikTok as a major threat to national security — and this week the fear-mongering continues: just like many jurisdictions before them, France have proudly announced that they will ban TikTok from government devices, as a way of maintaining national security. Oh except France will also ban streaming services and gaming apps. This might sound completely unhinged but to me it makes more sense than only banning TikTok if the logic is that these apps collect way too much data (they do), are not very secure (probs not), and use opaquely governed algorithms (yep). Of course, the overall problem with banning these apps from government devices is that it will materially change nothing; apps like Candy Crush have obscene data practices because governments — who now want them banned — have failed/refused to put in place any meaningful laws/regulations around this. Instead, they wilfully created the conditions for large scale data processing, behavioural ad targeting, and algorithmic amplification — and now they don’t have the power to do anything except complain, apparently. 🐣 Twitter Blue For YouIn a classic case of Being Accidentally Funny, Elon announced on Monday that by the 15th of April, the legacy verification system for Twitter will be gone, and the only people with a blue tick will be the ones who were dumb enough to pay the $8 a month. Furthermore, the ‘For You’ page will only contains posts from Twitter Blue subscribers, and only Twitter Blue subscribers will be able to vote in polls. Excuse me, but let’s zoom out:
This will either drive even more people away from the site, or begrudgingly force people to pay to even get slightly noticed on what is already the hardest platform to get attention on if you are a small account. I just find it SO FUNNY that these seething, middle-aged, Silicon Valley men are failing to understand that the main draw of social media is that it provides an endless stream of free content without having to do any piracy. Since 2020, it feels like all they’ve been doing is trying to take that away. In 2021/22, before AI was being injected into every empty feature, it was NFTs. They were trying to take money from users and make it seem cool — it was hilarious. Nearly all of those projects have shut down now. The new trend is to literally just charge you a monthly subscription to get any meaningful use out of the platform ✝️ The first AI image to trick even the most aggressively online peopleMidjourney has had an upgrade, and people have worked out that with the right prompts, it can spit out really good photo-realistic images. Here is the pope in a puffa jacket that (apparently) looks like it was made by a brand called Balenciaga. I’m not someone who cares about fashion so I’ve never heard of them before now, but from what I can gather, they sell really ugly trainers that are already covered in dirt? Good for them! Literally, the only dead giveaway is the weird coffee cup type looking thing in his left hand — everything else is basically perfect. Should we be afraid? No; you should have already been afraid. You have no idea what’s going to happen to you; one day an AI will memorise your likeness, and inject a much better looking version of yourself into unskippable package holiday adverts. You won’t be able to even go on holiday because your job would have been replaced with a very good NLP engine. Are you prepared? Of course you’re not! You’re just sitting there trying to recreate an image which is as good as the one above. Anyway, have a good weekend! 💌 Thank you for subscribing to Horrific/Terrific. If you need more reasons to distract yourself try looking at my website or maybe this ridiculous zine that I write or how about these silly games that I’ve made. Enjoy! |
Key phrases
Older messages
👎 Goodbye TikTok
Friday, March 24, 2023
TikTok is a very fun and popular app so naturally let's just force people to stop using it
🤷♀️ GPT-snore
Friday, March 17, 2023
GPT-4 is out | A good old fashioned bank-run! | Online Safety Bill VS WhatsApp
🤷♀️ Parting Clouds
Friday, March 3, 2023
Jack Dorsey's new social platform | Apple VS Spotify | Generative AI VS all of mankind
👎 Get Verified
Friday, February 24, 2023
A quick look at 'Meta Verified' how it compounds already tooth-grinding tensions between creators and corporates (it's fun!)
👎 Mother's Milk
Friday, February 17, 2023
Elon Musk 'fixes' Twitter algorithm | ChatGPT expresses emotions, not facts | Update on Microsoft's Activition-Blizzard acquisition
You Might Also Like
Stripe makes more changes
Thursday, April 25, 2024
TikTok is in trouble, and net neutrality is back View this email online in your browser By Christine Hall Thursday, April 25, 2024 Welcome back to TechCrunch PM, your home for all things startups,
💎 Issue 414 - From a Lorry Driver to Ruby on Rails Developer at 38
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome Ruby Newsletter Read this email on the Web The Awesome Ruby Newsletter Issue » 414 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular Ruby news, articles and
💻 Issue 414 - JavaScript Features That Most Developers Don’t Know
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome Node.js Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome Node.js Weekly Issue » 414 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular Node.js news, articles and
💻 Issue 407 - The Performance Impact of C++'s `final` Keyword
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome .NET Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome .NET Weekly Issue » 407 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular .NET news, articles and projects
💻 Issue 414 - Everyone Has JavaScript, Right?
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome JavaScript Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome JavaScript Weekly Issue » 414 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular JavaScript news, articles
📱 Issue 408 - All web browsers on iOS are just Safari with different design
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome iOS Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome iOS Weekly Issue » 408 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular iOS news, articles and projects Popular
💧 Don't Bother Liquid Cooling Your AMD CPU — Why You Should Keep Using Live Photos on iPhone
Thursday, April 25, 2024
Also: We review the Unistellar Odyssey iPhone Telescope, and More! How-To Geek Logo April 25, 2024 Did You Know Charles Darwin and Abraham Lincoln were both born on the same day: February 12, 1809. 💻
💻 Issue 332 - 🥇The first framework that lets you visualize your React/NodeJS app 🤯
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome React Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome React Weekly Issue » 332 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular React news, articles and projects
💻 Issue 409 - Sized, DynSized, and Unsized by Niko Matsakis
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome Rust Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome Rust Weekly Issue » 409 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular Rust news, articles and projects
📱 Issue 411 - AI Starts to Sift Through String Theory's Near-Endless Possibilities
Thursday, April 25, 2024
This week's Awesome Swift Weekly Read this email on the Web The Awesome Swift Weekly Issue » 411 Release Date Apr 25, 2024 Your weekly report of the most popular Swift news, articles and projects