What makes a social studies textbook "woke" in Ron DeSantis' Florida
You are currently a free subscriber to Popular Information, a newsletter dedicated to accountability journalism. According to Florida Governor Ron DeSantis (R), textbook publishers are attempting to indoctrinate Florida students by incorporating "woke" concepts into social studies textbooks — in violation of state laws prohibiting certain kinds of instruction on race and gender. The DeSantis administration says it is scrutinizing these textbooks for "inaccurate material, errors and other information that was not aligned with Florida Law." Then it is demanding that changes are made before the textbooks get into the hands of Florida students. The Florida Department of Education says the problems in social studies textbooks are pervasive. In a press release, the state said that only 19 of the 101 social studies textbooks initially submitted were approved for statewide use. The rejections were based on reviews of the textbooks conducted on behalf of the Florida Department of Education. Many of these reviews are performed by right-wing activists from the Florida Citizens Alliance, a group closely aligned with the DeSantis administration. "Our public education system is failing America’s students academically, civically and morally," the Florida Citizens Alliance says on its website. "Florida children are being indoctrinated in a public school system that undermines their individual rights and destroys our nation’s founding principles and family values." As of June 12, 87 of the 101 textbooks were approved after unspecified changes were made to dozens of textbooks. But there has been very little information provided about what caused the textbooks to be rejected in the first place or what content was edited. The Florida Department of Education has not responded to public records requests filed by the Florida Freedom to Read Project seeking that information. Popular Information discovered, however, that the Florida Department of Education has quietly posted the initial reviews of all currently approved social studies textbooks — including those that were initially rejected. These reviews, which have not been previously reported, reveal why these social studies textbooks were deemed unacceptable. In several instances, the reviewers of rejected texts mischaracterized basic factual information as biased, inappropriate, or ideological. First Grade textbook denounced for including image of same-sex familyOne of the initially rejected textbooks for 1st Grade was Social Studies Alive! My School and Family, published by the Teachers' Curriculum Institute (TCI). One reviewer of Social Studies Alive! My School and Family determined that the textbook was in "very poor/no alignment" with the provision of Florida law that prohibits "any instruction regarding sexual orientation or gender identity." The reviewer does not claim there is any instruction in the text about sexual orientation or gender identity. But the reviewer notes that the textbook's "photographs and graphics include homosexual and heterosexual couples." The reviewer also claimed that the photos of "non-traditional families" violates the Florida requirement that the material be presented "objectively" and is "free of bias." Here is an example of an offending image: Middle school textbook deemed inappropriate for referencing "LGBTQ court cases," "lesbianism," and "abortion rights"Another initially rejected textbook for 6th-8th grade was Civics Alive! Foundations and Functions, also published by TCI. One reviewer who did not recommend the text claims that "the discussion of lesbianism… [is] inappropriate for the middle school classroom." This is the entire "discussion of lesbianism" within the textbook:
The same review concludes that the "reference of LGBTQ court cases" is an example of "liberal bias" that is inconsistent with state standards. This is the only LGBTQ-related court case referenced in the textbook: The review of Civics Alive! Foundations and Functions also claims the discussion of "abortion rights" is "inappropriate." This is how the textbook addresses abortion rights:
While the reviewer claims the textbook is biased toward "the left," its description of the conservative approach to judicial restraint — especially in light of recent decisions by conservative federal judges — is rejected by most liberals. Middle school social studies textbook cited for including "slavery image"One middle school social studies textbook, Florida United States History Advanced: myWorld Interactive, was not rejected by the state but did have several issues flagged by a reviewer. For example, the reviewer writes that "Slavery image on pg. 444 may violate the statute relating to guilt of future generations." This is a reference to the Stop WOKE Act, which prohibits instruction that makes an individual "feel guilt, anguish, or other forms of psychological distress for actions, in which he or she played no part, committed in the past by other members of the same race." This is the image on page 444: The same reviewer also cites another image that depicts "the life of White plantation owners," which the reviewer believes is "outside the scope of the standard and potentially the law." This is the image at issue. The same reviewer also objects to aspects of a section called "Characteristics of White Society," claiming it is "irrelevant and may violate the intention of the law regarding generational guilt." An opaque processIn many other cases, the reviews of social studies textbooks do not provide any detail about the alleged violation of Florida standards or law. Nor has the state provided any information about what, if anything, has been changed for specific textbooks that were initially rejected but later approved. This allows Florida officials, including DeSantis and Commission of Education Manny Diaz Jr., to make broad assertions about "woke indoctrination" embedded in textbooks. The materials necessary to fact-check these claims are not released until much later. This strategy enables DeSantis and his allies to manipulate the media narrative. In April 2022, for example, DeSantis explicitly claimed that publishers of math textbooks were targeting elementary school students with Critical Race Theory, which DeSantis sometimes calls "race essentialism":
DeSantis did not provide any proof for his claim that elementary school students were being targeted with CRT, but it nevertheless generated a slew of credulous headlines. Weeks later, Popular Information reported that the reviews of the math textbooks revealed unequivocally that DeSantis was lying. No reviewer of Florida math textbooks for elementary school students found any instances of CRT. You are currently a free subscriber to Popular Information. To support this work and get the full experience, upgrade your subscription. |
Key phrases
Older messages
Popular Information's future
Friday, June 23, 2023
In March 2020, I took down Popular Information's paywall. Since then, each edition of Popular Information (655 newsletters!) has been freely available to everyone. And over the last three years, we
Did Hunter Biden get a "sweetheart deal"?
Thursday, June 22, 2023
In a May interview, President Joe Biden said that his son, Hunter, "has done nothing wrong." That turned out not to be true. On Tuesday, Hunter Biden was charged with two misdemeanor counts
Weigh in
Wednesday, June 21, 2023
It's been a busy few weeks for Popular Information. Here are a few highlights from our reporting: Popular Information revealed that the investig…
US murder rate declines dramatically in 2023 — but you probably haven't heard about it
Tuesday, June 20, 2023
In 2020, along with the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a dramatic spike in murders in the United States. This increase in lethal violence, understandably, was covered extensively in national
What the PGA Tour's corporate sponsors have to say about joining forces with the Saudis
Tuesday, June 20, 2023
On October 2, 2018, Jamal Khashoggi, a US-based journalist critical of the Saudi regime, was murdered and dismembered. According to the US government, Crown Prince Muhammad bin Salman (MBS), Saudi
You Might Also Like
Beautiful Online
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Want a little more beauty online? Beautiful Online By Kaamya Sharma • 30 Apr 2024 View in browser View in browser The Beautiful Dissociation Of The Japanese Language Marco Giancotti | Aether Mug | 20th
Today’s the final day. Don’t let us fall short.
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
We're counting on reaching our goal of 3000 new monthly donors to meet our reporting budget for the rest of this year. At midnight tonight, we close the books on our April fundraising campaign, and
Gaza is not the only famine risk
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
+ solutions to America's long-term care crisis
🌀 JWST Zooms Into the Horsehead Nebula
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Plus: Caitlin Cronenberg reflects on following her famous father into genre filmmaking.
Plant Vogtle, Scottish Shake-Up, and a Summer Movie Guide
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Facts, without motives.
Congress May Cancel Your Automatic Flight Refunds
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Airline-bankrolled lawmakers just added language to a bill that could undermine Biden's promise of automatic refunds on canceled or delayed flights. Read below to learn how lawmakers are trying to
Will bird flu make things more ... eggspensive?
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Plus: India's overseas assassination plots, America's oversize cars, and more April 30, 2024 View in browser Good morning! We've already talked about the rise of bird flu in mammals,
The biggest political deception of 2024
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
In the 2024 presidential election, one of the central attacks that Trump and his political allies are levying against Biden is that Biden is responsible for a "migrant crime" wave. The
An urgent message from The Intercept’s interim editor-in-chief
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
Amid a desolate landscape for journalism, it can be hard to see signs of hope. The Intercept is a rare example. Yesterday was my first day on the job as The Intercept's interim editor-in-chief. I
Numlock News: April 30, 2024 • Kansai, Domino's, Dodecahedrons
Tuesday, April 30, 2024
By Walt Hickey Domino's Domino's sells about 1.5 million pizzas every day, and it's become more and more profitable owing to a number of deals struck with third-party delivery companies and