Judge defends right to teach Beyoncé, strikes down law restricting lessons on race and gender
About 320,000 people will receive this email, but only a small fraction are paying subscribers. If another 2% of Popular Information readers decided this newsletter was worth 96 cents per week, we could significantly expand our capacity to do this work. If the cost of this newsletter ($6/month or $50/year) would cause any financial strain, please stay on this free list. That's why we've eliminated the paywall for the last four years. But if you can afford it, please consider becoming a paid subscriber. In September 2020, in the midst of a panic about Critical Race Theory (CRT) infiltrating the government and schools, former President Donald Trump issued an executive order. The executive order, however, does not take on CRT directly — or even related concepts like structural racism, implicit bias, and affirmative action. Instead, the order prohibited federal funding for programs that promote general concepts such as "an individual should be discriminated against… solely or partly because of his or her race" or "an individual, by virtue of his or her race or sex, is inherently racist, sexist, or oppressive." Would discussions of implicit bias violate this provision? Federal employees and contractors were left to guess. President Joe Biden, shortly after his inauguration, repealed Trump's executive order. That's when the New Hampshire legislature got to work. In 2021, Governor Chris Sununu (R) signed a new law, modeled after Trump's executive order, that prohibited government employees, including public school teachers, from promoting "divisive concepts." It prohibited students from being "taught, instructed, inculcated or compelled to express belief in, or support for" a series of general concepts pulled from Trump's executive order, including:
Teachers found to have violated the law could lose their teaching licenses and, as a result, their careers. Under the law, anyone who feels the "divisive concepts" prohibition has been violated can file a civil lawsuit or a complaint with state officials. The law, however, does not define key terms. Does a classroom discussion of various views count as "instruction"? Does a lesson on affirmative action violate the ban on instruction suggesting a person "should be discriminated against… solely or partly… because of his or her… race"? Teachers were left to guess. In April 2022, a New Hampshire parent complained that Alison O’Brien, a high school social studies teacher, violated the divisive concepts law by showing two videos — “Formation” by Beyoncé and “This is America” by Childish Gambino — as part of a unit on the Harlem Renaissance. O'Brien said she showed the videos as part of a lesson where students "listen to Strange Fruit by Billie Holiday, read poetry, and study paintings by Harlem Renaissance artists." Then, O'Brien asked the students if they saw "any connections between these two modern music videos and the art and culture of the Harlem Renaissance." O'Brien explained in a declaration filed as part of a lawsuit that using "modern examples of artists that students are aware of helps them to make connections to historical events such as the Harlem Renaissance in a manner that is relevant to them so they can better understand, analyze, and critique the information." The parent who complained claimed the music videos were "offensive," too focused "on the oppression of just one group," and "not a balanced view of history.” In response, O'Brien was pulled out of class by the Assistant Principal and asked to confirm if she had shown "This Is America" to students. Later, O'Brien was summoned to the Principal's office and told that the Department of Education was "investigating" her conduct. The investigator advised the officials at the high school to read a recently published op-ed by New Hampshire Education Commissioner Frank Edelblut about the law to understand the "context" of the investigation into O'Brien. In the op-ed, Edelblut does not actually discuss the divisive concepts law. But Edelbut asserts that certain "activist educators" are "knowingly dismantling the foundations of a value system" built by parents. Edelblut's op-ed linked to a 68-page document of emails, classroom materials, and text messages that he says are examples of inappropriate classroom instruction. There is no explanation of how any of this relates to New Hampshire law. O'Brien was given a copy of the op-ed. The investigation into O'Brien became known to her colleague. One "decided not to show a clip from a popular TV show because she did not want to face the same kind of scrutiny." O'Brien never heard anything further from the Department of Education or received an explanation as to why the videos might have violated the law. Various educational groups sued, alleging that the divisive concepts law was unconstitutional. On Tuesday, United States District Judge Paul J. Barbadoro struck down the law, finding that it violated the 14th Amendment. Barbadoro, citing the experience of O'Brien and other teachers, ruled that the law was unconstitutionally vague. The law represents "viewpoint-based restrictions on speech" but does not "provide either fair warning to educators of what they prohibit or sufficient standards for law enforcement to prevent arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement." As such, it violates the due process protections of the 14th Amendment. Barbadoro's reasoning, if it is accepted by other courts, could have large implications because similar laws have been passed in several other states. OklahomaIn Oklahoma, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is leading a lawsuit against HB 1775, which prohibits teachers and administrators from including certain race-related topics in their classes. The prohibited topics mirror those in Trump's executive order. The lawsuit, filed in October 2021, asks that the court “declare the bill unconstitutional under the First and 14th Amendments.” Emerson Sykes, the lead attorney for the ACLU, argues that the law is “unconstitutionally vague, overbroad and viewpoint discriminatory.” District Judge Charles Goodwin, who was appointed in 2018 by former President Trump and was deemed “unqualified” by the American Bar Association in 2017, is presiding over the case. Oral arguments in the case were presented on December 4, 2023. Earlier this month, the plaintiffs for the case “asked a federal judge to move along the proceedings.” Goodwin then scheduled a “status conference” for June 7, the Oklahoman reported. TennesseeIn July 2023, the Tennessee Education Association filed a federal lawsuit against the state's “Prohibited Concepts Ban.” The ban, which was signed into law in May 2021, “prohibits the inclusion of 14 prohibited concepts in educational curriculum, including those dealing with race, gender and other subjects.” The language in the law is drawn from Trump's executive order. The lawsuit argues that the law is “unconstitutionally vague and that the state’s enforcement plan is subjective.” The case also argues that it “interferes with instruction on difficult but important topics included in the state’s academic standards,” saying that the law “encourages arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement and violates the 14th Amendment.” Earlier this month, a judge denied a motion by the state of Tennessee to dismiss the case and scheduled a June 17 meeting with the case attorneys, Chalkbeat Tennessee reported. FloridaIn August 2022, students and educators represented by the ACLU filed a lawsuit against Florida’s HB 7. The law, known as the Stop WOKE Act, limits the way teachers can discuss race in the classroom and prohibits classroom instruction “from being used to indoctrinate or persuade students in a manner inconsistent with certain principles or state academic standards.” The lawsuit argues that the law is “classroom censorship” and “severely restricts Florida educators and students from learning and talking about issues related to race and gender in higher education classrooms.” The lawsuit also argues that the law “violates the First and 14th Amendments by imposing viewpoint-based restrictions on educators… and students that are vague and discriminatory.” In November 2022, a federal judge blocked enforcement of the law in higher education settings. A hearing for the lawsuit is scheduled for June, Politico reported. ArkansasA law prohibiting “indoctrination” in Arkansas schools is being challenged by two students and two teachers. The LEARNS Act was signed into law by Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders (R) in March 2023. A section of the law prohibits topics like “indoctrination,” “critical race theory,” or curriculum “encourag[ing] discrimination” from being taught in schools. The attorneys for the plaintiffs argued that the law is “too vague, and creates a chilling effect on teaching.” Earlier this month, a federal judge “issued a narrow preliminary injunction” against the law and “ruled Arkansas cannot prevent two high school teachers from discussing critical race theory in the classroom,” but did not fully block the state from enforcing the law in schools, the AP reported. On May 14, the office of Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin (R) filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. Today’s newsletter is part of our ongoing coverage of the radical transformation of public schools in Florida. The DeSantis administration has attacked our reporting. Florida Commissioner of Education Manny Diaz called Popular Information "fake news" and claimed we were "too lazy" to understand Florida's education policy. We are not intimidated by this kind of bullying. We are being attacked because we are telling the truth. You can support this work by upgrading to a paid subscription. |
Older messages
The Minnesota GOP endorsed an anti-semite for U.S. Senate. Republicans are silent.
Thursday, May 23, 2024
Earlier this month, Congressman Tom Emmer (R-MN) blasted college students protesting Israel's military operations in Gaza. "By these students' own admission, they're not just standing
An extraordinarily important legal decision just dropped, and no one is talking about it
Wednesday, May 22, 2024
On February 13, 2020, Nicholas Robertson was shot in Jackson, Mississippi. Wounded, Robertson knocked on the door of a nearby home. But by the time the police arrived, Robertson was unresponsive and
Need your input
Tuesday, May 21, 2024
May has been a busy month for Popular Information. Here are a few highlights: Today, however, I want to hear from you. What's on your mind? What… ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
The truth about crime in DC
Monday, May 20, 2024
On May 15, Congressman Andy Biggs (R-AZ) went to the floor of the House of Representatives and said he supported a federal takeover of Washington, DC's criminal justice laws "to improve public
Is Trump orchestrating a new criminal conspiracy?
Friday, May 17, 2024
In recent days, several high-profile Republican political figures have traveled to the Manhattan Criminal Court, where Donald Trump is on trial. Outside the courthouse, they addressed the media and
You Might Also Like
Why is everyone so afraid to talk about AIPAC?
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Most major news outlets treat AIPAC as a taboo subject — the organization whose name cannot be spoken. Over the past week, hundreds of thousands of Israelis have poured into the streets night after
E Ink's 'Wizard of Oz' moment: Behind the digital notepad's colorful transition
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Boeing's Starliner makes it back to Earth | Upcoming tech events in the PNW ADVERTISEMENT GeekWire SPONSOR MESSAGE: Join RSM US LLP, in partnership with GeekWire in San Francisco for an exclusive
Telegram’s Durov Strikes Back | SEC May Derail FTX Repayment Plan
Saturday, September 7, 2024
The executive issued his first public statement since he was detained. ADVERTISEMENT Forbes START INVESTING • Newsletters • MyForbes Nina Bambysheva Staff Writer, Forbes Money & Markets Follow me
Why Ireland isn't toasting VP Harris' ties
Saturday, September 7, 2024
+ that new football helmet accessory
Middle Two-Shot
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Today, enjoy our recent video and audio picks Middle Two-Shot By Kaamya Sharma • 7 Sept 2024 View in browser View in browser The full Browser recommends five articles, a video and a podcast daily.
The Home Stretch
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Columns and commentary on news, politics, business, and technology from the Intelligencer team. Intelligencer Weekend Reader Required Reading for Political Compulsives 1. Are Republicans Stuck With
7 pajamas we love
Saturday, September 7, 2024
We won't judge if you wear them all day View in browser The Recommendation Oh, so comfy A person wearing a navy blue pajama set on their couch, petting a black dog. Photo: Kyle Fitzgerald A
Last Chance To Join Forbes For Just $49.99!
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Subscribe for less than $1/week with this special membership offer. Subscribe for less than $1/week with this special membership offer. Ends Soon: Less Than $1/Week This is your last chance to take
☕ A long way from Barney
Saturday, September 7, 2024
How Selena Gomez became a billionaire... September 07, 2024 View Online | Sign Up | Shop Morning Brew PRESENTED BY Pendulum Good morning. An American man hasn't played in a Grand Slam final in 15
YOU LOVE TO SEE IT: A Dam Good Idea
Saturday, September 7, 2024
Plus, AI gets reined in, Mississippi thinks of the children, and electric school buses power on. YOU LOVE TO SEE IT: A Dam Good Idea By Jean Yi • 7 Sept 2024 View in browser View in browser A fly