🔍 The 3-Piece Framework For A High-Converting Email Pop-Up

All Case Studies 🔍 Learn About Sponsorships

Nothing angers me like the typical 10% off generic email pop-up everyone uses on their site. Think about it. It’s one of those things marketers tend to overlook, ignore, and don’t put too much thought into. Which is a problem and an opportunity at the same time. On the other end, David Protein made a 10/10 email opt-in which checked off the three aspects of a good email pop-up. Lemme show yah…

And a big thank you to heatmap for partnering with us and letting us create media for a livin’.

Get your brand in front of 200,000+ marketers & founders.

Email opt-ins are that thing that every brand ignores, never optimizes, and puts no intention into. Big problem. Mistake. And huge missed opportunity. We’ve all seen the generic “get 10% off” email pop-ups 20 sec after landing on a site you’ve never visited before.

Again, mistake.

So, I’m going to help you fix it.

There’s a three piece framework I put together that’ll help you build the perfect email opt-in + a brand that executes this to perfection.

The framework:

1. Product Specific

People buy products to get a specific job done. You buy a hydration stick to stay hydrated throughout the day. You buy a sleep supplement to help you stay asleep during the night. You buy software to have an efficient CMS.

So, asking someone to give you their email or phone number for 10% off isn’t going to move the needle because it’s not specific to the job the individual needs to get done.

Takeaway: Find the underlying job to be done someone hires your product/service for and create an email opt-in around that.

2. Value Driven

There’s underlying value beneath every “job to be done.”

This value also is a positioning tool.

Back to the hydration stick - if you offer a hydration guide to potential customers then not only do you open another door to your product but you create a valuable piece of content that positions your brand as the resource.

The more you position yourself or brand as the resource, the more you cement yourself as the guide in the space.

3. Personalized

The last layer for a good email opt-in is personalizing the content of the email-opt in. Seems obvious. But again, it’s such a missed opportunity.

David’s Protein Bar’s Email Opt-In

So, why is this so good when it’s so simple?

People are hiring “David’s protein bar” to help them get more protein into their diet/nutrition.

Knowing that, they make a product-specific email-opt in for potential customers.

Next, the email opt-in isn’t trying to collect your email so they can promote the product uncontrollably.

Instead, they’re exchanging your information for valuable information which continues to position themselves as the leader within the category and works potential customers down the funnel.

Lastly, David’s team put a lot of intention into the content on the backside of this email-opt in. Not some simple PDF.

But what feels like a full-fledged course/guide around protein.

So, the three steps to follow:

In partnership with heatmap

35% Higher Revenue Per Session:

Cowhides Direct was drowning in data.

Their storefront had over 1,000 product variants, and customer drop-off was off the charts.

And Microsoft Clarity wasn’t helping.

So they installed heatmap to understand exactly what to fix.

heatmap’s revenue-attribution instantly identified the highest-impact fixes and prioritized changes by revenue potential.

The result? 

Cowhides Direct increased its revenue per session by 35%. 

Delivering over 100x ROI from using heatmap in just 30 days.

E-comm brands, this is a no-brainer.

heatmap literally pays for itself within weeks.