The Deleted Scenes - Engineers, Traffic and Social
A fellow on Twitter who enjoys disagreeing with urbanists wrote this last month: ![]() “Induced demand” refers to the insight and widely observed phenomenon that widening highways/increasing highway capacity often leads to more traffic, such that travel times and congestion do not improve. In his latest book, Charles Marohn writes that the only way to “fix” or “solve” congestion is to get people out of their cars. In the same vein, it’s often argued that you can’t build your way out of congestion. (I suppose you could, but where would 40 or 50 lanes of highway actually go?) In just one of the iconic examples of induced demand, Houston famously widened its traffic-choked Katy Freeway in the mid-2000s, to more than 20 lanes. Travel times improved in the short term. But by the time several years had gone by, peak traffic was worse than before the widening. This kind of thing can sound unbelievable. For certain conservatives who think of urbanists as car-hating ideologically driven busybodies, it sounds too perfect. But it’s basically true. Now there’s a lot going on here, and much of it has to do with land use rather than any magic property of road capacity to generate traffic. Obviously, if induced demand were some kind of universal phenomenon, no road anywhere would ever have any free capacity. What people are mostly talking about is commuting routes and freeways, where the widening project often encourages peripheral development, which in turn generates more commuting trips. Daniel Herriges at Strong Towns wrote an excellent piece about all of this last August, distilling it very clearly in layman’s terms. He starts like this, which is helpful when you’re addressing people who aren’t already convinced or have simply never heard of this stuff before:
As far as the land-use angle, he writes:
And you can imagine what happens to traffic as these changes in the development pattern play out. Here’s another good piece about this in Governing, by Jake Blumgart. If this interests you, read both pieces in full as well as the one I linked above about Houston’s big freeway. But in this post, I’m less interested in proving induced demand to you than in thinking about the kind of insight that it is. The fellow on Twitter who I showed you at the beginning here is a libertarian or conservative. But in fact, contra his opinion, I think induced demand is a profoundly conservative insight about how human behavior works. At heart, it’s an argument that human behavior is dynamic, not static. People are always evaluating and responding to incentives and making calculations. You can’t fix congestion by building more lanes, because people respond to the reduced time-cost of driving by doing more of it. You can’t hold driving habits or development constant in the real world, because these things interact with each other in ways that we can’t always predict or plan for. What we call “traffic” is much more complex than inputs and outputs—it’s a human, social phenomenon. In other words, induced demand is a sort of argument against social engineering and a warning about unintended consequences. Conservatives are quite familiar with this kind of argument. They often make it in regard to social programs, arguing that welfare weakens families or work ethic or what have you. They warn that it’s not as simple as providing social assistance to people in need, because (they argue) there’s something about those programs being available that can change human behavior in a way that makes those programs more necessary. Or, as the British conservative writer Theodore Dalrymple puts it, in more rarefied language, “misery increases to meet the means available for its alleviation.” I’m not saying this true; just that it’s familiar logic for conservatives. It’s even a more complex question than the observable relationship between freeway widening and congestion. (It also matters, a lot, how exactly social programs work; you can’t simply talk about “welfare” if you’re trying to actually understand how to do social programs well. My understanding is the simpler, the better.) But other than welfare—in fact, almost everywhere—genuine conservatives are cautious, aware of how fragile our current order can be, and humble, even skeptical, in terms of the ability of policy to fix human problems without unintended consequences. Everything we’ve done to cities in the last century, and the way in which we’ve totally oriented our land use around the car, is the sort of massive experiment that conservatives should look askance at. And here, the notion that you could ram 20-lane freeways through cities and out into the countryside without altering many other variables is the kind of technocratic, top-down hubris conservatives warn about. They should be as skeptical of traffic engineers as social engineers. Induced demand—which can sound like some sort of lefty anti-car theory—fundamentally embodies a very conservative way of thinking about the dynamic and unpredictable nature of human behavior. The fact that urbanists do tend to lean left is mostly an accident of American politics and culture war, and it has very little to do with most of what’s being advocated at heart. I’m not sure how many people who write about induced demand think about it the way I just outlined—but the phenomenon speaks for itself. These are not left or right concerns. They’re just human concerns—having a good place to live, having lots of ways to get around, and not wasting hours in traffic. Related Reading: The Housing Crisis is a Policy Problem Please consider upgrading to a paid subscription to help support this newsletter. You’ll get a weekend subscribers-only post, plus full access to the archive of over 300 posts and growing. And you’ll help ensure more material like this! You’re a free subscriber to The Deleted Scenes. For the full experience, become a paid subscriber. |
Older messages
The Car and Car Dependence
Monday, March 28, 2022
They're not the same, and in some ways opposites
A Good Run
Saturday, March 26, 2022
It's okay for a publication or a business not to live forever
Crossing Into the Supermarket
Wednesday, March 23, 2022
What Do You Think You're Looking At? #50
Where Do They Shop?
Tuesday, March 22, 2022
A look at rural retail
Forty Pages, No Words
Monday, March 21, 2022
Zoning absurdity at its finest in suburban Silver Spring, Maryland
You Might Also Like
*This* Is How To Wear Skinny Jeans Like A Fashion Girl In 2025
Wednesday, March 12, 2025
The revival is here. The Zoe Report Daily The Zoe Report 3.11.2025 This Is How To Wear Skinny Jeans Like A Fashion Girl In 2025 (Style) This Is How To Wear Skinny Jeans Like A Fashion Girl In 2025 The
The Best Thing: March 11, 2025
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
The Best Thing is our weekly discussion thread where we share the one thing that we read, listened to, watched, did, or otherwise enjoyed recent… ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
The Most Groundbreaking Beauty Products Of 2025 Are...
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
Brands are prioritizing innovation more than ever. The Zoe Report Beauty The Zoe Report 3.11.2025 (Beauty) The 2025 TZR Beauty Groundbreakers Awards (Your New Holy Grail Or Two) The 2025 TZR Beauty
Change Up #Legday With One of These Squat Variations
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
View in Browser Men's Health SHOP MVP EXCLUSIVES SUBSCRIBE Change Up #Legday With One of These Squat Variations Change Up #Legday With One of These Squat Variations The lower body staple is one of
Kylie Jenner Wore The Spiciest Plunging Crop Top While Kissing Timothée Chalamet
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
Plus, Amanda Seyfried opens up about her busy year, your daily horoscope, and more. Mar. 11, 2025 Bustle Daily Amanda Seyfried at the Tory Burch Fall RTW 2025 fashion show as part of New York Fashion
Paris Fashion Week Is Getting Interesting Again
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
Today in style, self, culture, and power. The Cut March 11, 2025 PARIS FASHION WEEK Fashion Is Getting Interesting Again Designs at Paris Fashion Week once again reflect the times with new aesthetics,
Your dinner table deserves to be lazier
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
NY delis are serving 'Bird Flu Bailout' sandwiches.
Sophie Thatcher Lets In The Light
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
Plus: Chet Hanks reaches new heights on Netflix's 'Running Point.' • Mar. 11, 2025 Up Next Your complete guide to industry-shaping entertainment news, exclusive interviews with A-list
Mastering Circumstance
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
“If a man does not master his circumstances then he is bound to be mastered by them.” ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Don't Fall for This Parking Fee Scam Text 🚨
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
How I Use the 'One in, One Out' Method for My Finances. You're not facing any fines. Not displaying correctly? View this newsletter online. TODAY'S FEATURED STORY Don't Fall for the