OUT OF THE BOX - The Limits of Artistic Expression
If you want to support the work I do and help to expand this art community, please upgrade to a paid subscription. Every subscription makes a huge difference. Small, one-time donations are also welcome here. I recently read an article about Pete Eckert, a blind photographer who creates light-suffused images that sometimes appear gritty and atmospheric and other times hit like a lightning strike. Eckert, who began to lose his sight in his twenties, explains in the article, “There is a section of the brain that's not being used when you're blind.” He adds, “(But) your brain is ready to (redirect) that capacity. So, for the past 20 years, I've been actively rewiring my visual cortex through sound, touch and memory inputs.” He explains his process of creating images this way:
Reading about Eckert made me think of Grant Achatz—the owner and head chef of Alinea, widely considered one of the best restaurants in the world—whom I’ve always regarded as a conceptual artist whose medium happens to be food. In 2007, Achatz was diagnosed with stage 4 mouth cancer, given a choice between having the lower part of his jaw (including most of his tongue) removed, and certain death. He decided to go home to die, because it was preferable to living a life that didn’t include eating and tasting and doing what he loved. Soon after, he was contacted by two doctors working on an experimental treatment that would spare him major surgery but involved a grueling schedule of chemo and radiation. During the course of that treatment—while Achatz was still running the restaurant full-time—he discovered that he had lost his sense of taste, unsure if it would ever return. “How can you be a chef, how can you be a cook, and not be able to taste?” he remembers asking himself, as he recounts in the Netflix documentary Chef’s Table. He started working from home, drawing his ideas for new dishes on paper and sending them to his kitchen. Dave Beran, Alinea's sous chef at the time, says they developed a system to desribe and discuss different elements of taste: "If a pickle's a five and bread's a one, how acidic do you want it?" Achatz recalls a lightbulb going off then, "For the first time ever, I think I can be a chef without being able to taste. Because it's up here," he says pointing to his head, "not here," he adds, pointing to his tongue. Beran saw the shift in him. “This is gonna sound weird,” he says of his boss, “but I honestly think [that] him being sick taught him how to be a chef.” When we, as a society, imagine artistic expression as having a one-to-one correlation with certain senses or abilities, we develop a false set of rules around creativity:
These self-limiting beliefs not only underestimate what the human animal is capable of when guided by a desire to create, but they reveal a fundamental misunderstanding about where and how art is generated. That which originates in the soul or the heart of a person contains countless paths into the hearts and souls of other people. We know from Eckert—as well as many other blind and visually impaired photograhers—that you don’t, in fact, need sight to make photgraphic images. You can construct them out of sound and touch and memory. We know from Achatz that you can create symphonies of flavor in your imagination without ever being able to taste them. Just like you can create actual symphonies, as Beethoven did, without being able to hear them. We know from dancer/choreographer Alice Sheppard, as well as members of the growing movement of disabled dancers, that you don’t need the use of your legs (or other parts of your body) to be a dancer. What is dance, afterall, if not the expression of emotion through a human vessel? Whoever decided that the vessel had to look or function a certain way in order to be able to do that? Perhaps we place these artificial limitations on art because its expansiveness and limitlessness frighten us. Or maybe it’s because we just can’t comprehend all the possibilities of artistic expression. To my mind, art is simply a desire made manifest, a soul’s cry made audible, a hope possible, a longing visible, a feeling tasteable, a beautiful madness tangible. If I know only one thing to be true, it’s that the creative force is more powerful than any other force in the world, and it will always find a way. If this post was meaningful to you, please let me know with a like or a comment. |
Key phrases
Older messages
Join my new subscriber chat
Wednesday, November 16, 2022
A private space for us to converse and connect
F*cked By The Attention Economy
Tuesday, November 15, 2022
How can artists navigate the realities of visual culture?
Unfiltered and Unedited
Thursday, November 3, 2022
A response to the pushback from last week's piece
Museums as Places of Protest
Tuesday, October 25, 2022
When are art spaces the right venue for political action?
The Case for Beauty
Tuesday, October 18, 2022
Listen now | A story and a thank you.
You Might Also Like
All the Country Easter Eggs in Beyonce's New Album
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Beyoncé's 'Cowboy Carter' Rollout Pays Homage to Country Music's History: All the Easter Eggs From the tracklist to the album art, every
Get instant access to Rolling Stone magazine.
Thursday, March 28, 2024
Print + E-edition only $29.95 Rolling Stone has been a culture carrier for more than 50 years, providing definitive coverage across music, politics, culture and entertainment. Subscribe now and you
'Love Is Blind' Takes Over Nielsen Streaming Charts; 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' Soars To No. 5 After Landing On Netflix
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 'Love Is Blind' Takes Over Nielsen Streaming Charts; 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' Soars To No. 5 After Landing On Netflix By Katie Campione This
Regal Theatres VP and Head Of Film Andrew Turner Departs
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Regal Theatres VP & Head Of Film Andrew Turner Departs By Anthony D'Alessandro This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by Deadline.
Bruce Springsteen Joins Zach Bryan Onstage in Brooklyn
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Bruce Springsteen Joins Zach Bryan Onstage at Triumphant Brooklyn Show Springsteen was a surprise guest at Bryan's triumphant Barclays Center show,
Viaplay Boss Vows Company "Will Be Different" After Horrors Of 2023
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Viaplay Boss Vows Company "Will Be Different" After Horrors Of 2023 By Jesse Whittock This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by
Tom Holland's Romeo Finds His Juliet In Brit Newcomer Francesca Amewudah-Rivers
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Tom Holland's Romeo Finds His Juliet In Brit Newcomer Francesca Amewudah-Rivers By Andreas Wiseman This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com
AMC Entertainment Shares Plunge On Proposed Stock Sale As Chain Cites Soft Box Office, Cash Burn
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 AMC Entertainment Shares Plunge On Proposed Stock Sale As Chain Cites Soft Box Office, Cash Burn By Jill Goldsmith This email was sent to newsletterest1
BBC Deficit Projected To Skyrocket To $620M Next Year
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 BBC Deficit Projected To Skyrocket To $620M Next Year By Max Goldbart This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by Deadline. Please add email@
Richard Sharp Says Actions That Led To His Resignation As BBC Chair Were "Misrepresented Wilfully By Other Forms Of The Media"
Thursday, March 28, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 28, 2024 Richard Sharp Says Actions That Led To His Resignation As BBC Chair Were "Misrepresented Wilfully By Other Forms Of The Media" By Max Goldbart