Proof of Concept - Should managers be technical?
I launched a zine! Get Proof of Concept: The 000 Series today. “Should managers be technically excellent in their craft? What a skill level should they maintain? This is a question I get a lot during office hours, mentorship sessions, and via email. In May, Elon Musk tweeted his perspective on this. The tweet stated:
Brian Chesky, Airbnb CEO reposted the tweet in agreement about design leaders being technical. Posts on Twitter usually prompt reactions over rational thinking. What often happens with tweets like this is a strong reaction in agreement by the fans or a very reactive dispute to it. I’ll extract the two tweets into the following discussion points:
This is essentially three elements: knowledge of your domain expertise, your responsibilities, and how much time you do it. Though my primary discipline, this concept applies to other functions such as engineering, product, or any other technical role. The key roles of managers are to set expectations, ensure the team is operating efficiently, and maximize the output of the people on your team. In order to develop people, you must have a certain level of understanding of what skills are needed for people to be successful. However, as you progress in your career, there are going to be different org structures in place where it's relevant. If you're a Chief Product Officer, they likely have a more broad level of understanding of other functions outside of their domain and will put leaders in place who have the depth of knowledge in those areas. Foundational skillsOne of the missed opportunities in evaluating the skills of individual contributors and people managers is striking a strong divide between the skills. I cannot stand the term “soft skills” because they are foundational skills for both roles. As a design leader, there was likely a point you were the best designer on a team—with “best” and “a team” not “the team” are this statement’s keywords. You've risen to the ranks because of your impact and excellence as a contributor. Now, you encounter an inflection point if you want to focus more as a very senior individual contributor or move into management. Regardless of the path you chose, this is where influencing through coaching and developing people is crucial. There is a certain level of comprehension needed in your domain. A piano instructor needs enough experience to teach various levels the same way an NBA coach should have played the sport at a high level. Do you really need Hans Zimmer to teach you how to play the piano or Michael Jordan with basketball? As cool as it would be, it’s not necessary. You also don’t want someone as your manager who just finished a boot camp or online course. Certainly, they have the potential to grow into this role, but you need more experience. It’s about how you apply your skill to a roleCareer development looks more like unlocking attributes for a different subclass in a role-playing game than picking a distinct class that can never change. It’s not a path. It’s a collection of skills and attributes focused on certain outcomes. Applying foundational skills is heavily contingent on your role and responsibility. This sketch depicts how a manager might apply core skills to her day-to-day. In the end, it’s the same competencies applied in a different way. If a design systems team needed to get staffed, the individual contributor might apply skills by directly doing the work whereas the manager might use it to define a rubric on who to hire. Time spent and scale of the teamI strongly do not agree with Chesky that design leaders should be spending most of their time designing and doing the actual work. It honestly sounds like he misses being a designer. That said, I think it’s important for leaders to invest time in exploring new innovations to learn/grow. Reviewing work is crucial to scale excellence, but allow your team to own the decisions. There are many different types of management roles out there, and depending on what the company is, its scale, and other distinct attributes, the role and responsibility are going to look different. However, having deep technical skills allow you to scale teams longer term. Let's say you're an experienced Product leader. You're taking on a new challenge at a startup as the first product manager with the intent to grow the team. When you're the 0-to-1 leader you start by doing the work, establishing the foundation, and growing the practice as the company grows. RecapI want to end to articulate my point of view:
The cavalry captain should be able to ride a horse but get them off the front lines as they should have more important stuff to work on! Management is something you take on when the value of your team is more important to develop others and help them drive towards shared outcomes that are more impactful than your own. Having more depth in the technical acumen of your field will only give you more range to help others grow. If I had to sum it up, you'd want your manager to be like that army general that still carries the World War II pistol around. He's never going to use it, but you have the confidence if something came up that they have lived experiences to be able to roll their sleeves up and take action. Weekly recapI'm thankful to have the next two weeks of work off! I only have anti-plans. Looking forward to not being on Zoom, having meetings, and having big blocks of time to do whatever I desire to rest, recover, and explore. I'm going to kick it off by watching my favorite Christmas movie...Prometheus! Hope you all have some time to unwind for the rest of the year! Tweet of the weekDreamweaver 25 years old—eligible to rent a car! I am forever grateful to Macromedia software for getting me into design and coding. Happy 25th Birthday Dreamweaver 1.0!
In December 1997, Macromedia released the first version of the popular Dreamweaver 1.0 website editor. The editor allowed users to switch between text and WYSIWYG (What You See Is What You Get) mode
webdesignmuseum.org/old-software/h…
#WebDesignHistory Hype links
Enjoy this newsletter? Please consider sharing it with friends, or subscribing if you haven’t already. I appreciate it! Sincerely, DH |
Key phrases
Older messages
Inattentive and hyper-focused management tips for managers
Sunday, December 11, 2022
Issue 121: Managing yourself to manager others
The ability to build
Sunday, December 4, 2022
Issue 120: Manifesting through construction and assembly
Creative consumption
Sunday, November 27, 2022
Issue 120: Binge watching and reading your way to creative breakthroughs
Approaching hard work
Sunday, November 20, 2022
Issue 119: On hustle culture, being hardcore, and where hard work pays off
The importance of community
Sunday, November 13, 2022
Issue 118: Seeking like-mindedness and new perspectives when gathering
You Might Also Like
9 Trends From Milan We Can’t Stop Thinking About
Thursday, April 25, 2024
View in your browser | Update your preferences ADPro Even More From Milan Design Week Each year, the design world convenes in Milan—and that applies to us at AD, too. For the third year running, our
Subframe, Attributes vs Properties, Front End Handbook, aspect-ratio, GenAI
Thursday, April 25, 2024
The 5 best design links, every day. Curated by a selection of great editors. Email not displaying properly? View browser version. Sidebar April 25 2024 Subframe subframe.com Subframe is a design-to-
Ritmo, Climate Change, Icons & Typefaces, Click Wheel JS, CarPlay
Wednesday, April 24, 2024
The 5 best design links, every day. Curated by a selection of great editors. Email not displaying properly? View browser version. Sidebar April 24 2024 Meet Ritmo, Musixmatch's cross-platform
Why Jake Arnold Doesn’t Text Clients
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
View in your browser | Update your preferences We've had a remodel! From now on, you'll be hearing from AD PRO in your inbox twice a week—once with a deep dive into trends to watch and subjects
The secret ingredient to media success
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
PR tips from our founder Nora Wolf In this month's edition is all about *the most important* element of successful media outreach—photography. You may have some photos, but if the backgrounds are
#453: Design Systems
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Design system generator, types of design systems and how to consolidate design systems. Issue #453 • Apr 23, 2024 • View in the browser Smashing Newsletter Buổi tối vui vẻ Smashing Friends, Ah, design
👨🏫 Striking Educational Website Designs + 🏆 Challenge Updates
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Your UpLabs Design Updates Await! Let's Get Going! 🎨 Firstly, let's congratulate Mariana Gameiro, the winner of our latest 👩💻 SheCodes Website Redesign Challenge! Congratulations!! Secondly,
Code Connect, JS Naked Day, Shape of AI, Product Design, CSS Grid Level 3
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
The 5 best design links, every day. Curated by a selection of great editors. Email not displaying properly? View browser version. Sidebar April 23 2024 The Right Code for Your Design System figma.com
Accessibility Weekly #393: When Security and Accessibility Clash
Monday, April 22, 2024
April 22, 2024 • Issue #393 View this issue online or browse the full issue archive. Featured: When security and accessibility clash: Why are banking applications so inaccessible? "While using
Bézier Curves, CSS Motion Extraction, CSS Testing, CSS Theming, Women Who Code
Monday, April 22, 2024
The 5 best design links, every day. Curated by a selection of great editors. Email not displaying properly? View browser version. Sidebar April 22 2024 Flattening Bézier Curves and Arcs minus-ze.ro