Good Morning It’s Basketball - To a more joyful MVP debate
Here’s a free preview of today’s subscriber-only post. Become a GMIB subscriber to see the whole thing and all of our other daily posts. Good morning. Let’s basketball.
Poppy Field, Claude Monet, 1886 The MVP race is heating up. The MVP race discourse is getting to the point that makes me want to log off. We have a rampant debate over whether it is appropriate for a player with limited postseason success to win three consecutive MVPs during a period in which there is a veritable cornucopia of elite talent in the NBA. We have a rampant debate over the ethics of denying said player a third MVP based on the results of prior postseasons, without knowing what will happen in this postseason. We have a debate on unequal treatment of the Triple-Double King of the prior decade vs. the current Triple-Double King. We have debates on how much “taking over a game” matters in someone’s candidacy. We have a debate on the value of assists. We have a debate on the value of playing almost every night. We have a debate on whether an MVP needs to have their team in the top three in their conference. We have a debate on the value of individual defense. Thanks to Kendrick Perkins, we now have a debate on whether race is a factor in the current debate. Here’s what gets me: all of these debates are worth having and worth engaging in! Well, almost all of these debates. To me, the problem isn’t the debate. It’s the vitriol that results from the debate. It’s the unsettling defensiveness and accusatory nature of the rebuttals. The loudest voices in these debates are the most dismissive and counterproductive. And they come from every angle — there isn’t a certain camp that is universally cool about it, or universally aggravating about it. There are a ton of good points and great arguments being made. They are just often drowned out by divisiveness for the sake of divisiveness. And that poisons the debate that the people who actually want to have a debate about this are trying to have. The energy changes when you start name-calling and making accusations. So consider this is a plea for the firestarters (who are very likely not reading this newsletter) to stop it, and for the debaters to breathe a little deeper, avoid getting so defensive and simply disengage from troll discourse in hopes of actually having the debate the NBA MVP award deserves. As for the core debate — who should win MVP with six weeks left? — I don’t have a vote, but I do care about this stuff. And I’m legitimately torn right now. ... Keep reading with a 7-day free trialSubscribe to Good Morning It's Basketball to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives. A subscription gets you:
Read Good Morning It's Basketball in the app Listen to posts, join subscriber chats, and never miss an update from Tom Ziller.
|
Key phrases
Older messages
176 reasons to believe in the Beam
Monday, February 27, 2023
Maybe you'll beat the Kings. But you're going to have to BEAT them.
Tuesday, February 21, 2023
With about two dozen games remaining and the trade deadline gone, how many contenders are there?
Your Honest NBA All-Star Weekend Viewing Guide
Friday, February 17, 2023
Starring Ben Affleck, a Peloton guy, multiple Antetokounmpii and a multiversal Mac McClung.
Good morning! Yep, the Suns traded a bunch for Kevin Durant
Thursday, February 9, 2023
The re-armament of the Western Conference continues apace.
... but it might work for the Mavericks
Monday, February 6, 2023
The Mavericks take the plunge into Kyrieland. Hope they packed oxygen.
Why the Next USMNT Manager Won't Be Who You Want It to Be
Friday, March 24, 2023
And, among other things: why it doesn't matter!
🔴🔴 Only 14 Liverpool players 'guaranteed' Anfield future
Friday, March 24, 2023
Liverpool Echo Latest LFC stories from the Liverpool Echo Read in browser News In Your Area Liverpool FC What's On | Sign In Today's Headlines See more stories... Only 14 Liverp Latest LFC
Friday, March 24, 2023
WTF is in the water these days
Friday, March 24, 2023
K-State, UConn, FAU & Gonzaga Punch Tickets to the Elite 8 as NCAA Tourney Rolls On... BY JEFF YODER MAR. 24, 2023 | SUBSCRIBE | REFER | WEB VIEW Happy Friday 🙌 How's your pulse? The Big Dance
🔴🔴 Liverpool watching 'really insane' situation with transfers in mind
Friday, March 24, 2023
Liverpool Echo Latest LFC stories from the Liverpool Echo Read in browser News In Your Area Liverpool FC What's On | Sign In Today's Headlines See more stories... Liverpool watc Latest LFC
The New Faces in the German National Team
Friday, March 24, 2023
6 players have been called up to the German National team for the first time in their career. Which of these 6 deserved the call up, & for whom may it have come too soon?
🔴 Gakpo suffers 'chicken curry' nightmare
Thursday, March 23, 2023
Liverpool Echo Latest LFC stories from the Liverpool Echo Read in browser News In Your Area Liverpool FC What's On | Sign In Today's Headlines See more stories... Cody Gakpo's t Latest LFC
🔴 FSG await 'marker' after Man Utd update
Thursday, March 23, 2023
Liverpool Echo Latest LFC stories from the Liverpool Echo Read in browser News In Your Area Liverpool FC What's On | Sign In Today's Headlines See more stories... FSG still wait Latest LFC
🔴 LIVE: Join our special Liverpool Q&A
Thursday, March 23, 2023
🙋♂️ Pose your LFC questions to Ian Doyle... Read in browser LFC News LFC Transfers Podcasts | Sign In Jude Bellingham transfer chances, FSG's rebuild budget plus Jurgen Klopp's mood revealed
Thursday, March 23, 2023
The Sweet 16 Tip-Off. McDavid Scores 60th Goal. Golf's Match Play Brackets & NBA West Race... BY JEFF YODER MAR. 23, 2023 | SUBSCRIBE | REFER | WEB VIEW It's Back... The madness returns