Simon Owens's Tech and Media - The valley of churn
Welcome! I'm Simon Owens and this is my media industry newsletter. If you've received it, then you either subscribed or someone forwarded it to you. If you fit into the latter camp and want to subscribe, then you can click on this handy little button: Let’s jump into it… Your story is special. Your writing and publishing partner should be too[Sponsored]
Gotham Ghostwriters is the partner you have been looking for. With 3000+ accomplished editorial specialists in our network, we have the unparalleled ability to find the right writing partner for your priorities. Our ghostwriters have collaborated on hundreds of noteworthy books with globally known public figures and celebrities. Schedule a complimentary consultation today! Gotham also can help you get the most impact from your work. We have extensive industry relationships with literary agents, publishers, media outlets, and PR and marketing consultants to find the right publishing path for your stories and ideas. Not ready to start your storytelling journey? Subscribe to Gotham’s monthly newsletter for industry insights, tips, opportunities, and more. The valley of churnSpend any amount of time reading coverage of the media industry and you’ll be constantly exposed to success stories. Everywhere you turn there’s a media executive touting their X% YOY audience growth or a newsletter writer being interviewed about how they hit 10,000 paying subscribers or a TikTok star casually mentioning they charge $20,000 per sponsored video. And because nobody wants to be regarded as a failure, everyone else projects strength — to the extent that probably each person reading this has found themselves, at some point, cherry picking stats that indicate upward growth. This then triggers a self-perpetuating state of anxiety among media operators who aren’t aware that they’re not the only ones struggling to grow their businesses. Of course, with traditional media outlets, there often comes a breaking point — typically indicated with a massive round of layoffs — where the emperor is revealed to have no clothes. How many years did we buy BuzzFeed’s narrative that it had unlocked the strategy for unlimited growth before everything came crashing down? And more recently, Business Insider rode wave after wave of positive press about its subscription growth and expansion into new verticals, only to then suffer a series of setbacks that painted a much bleaker picture. Last week, its editor-in-chief finally admitted in a staff-wide memo that “traffic is down. Subs are down. Video views are down. That was true two weeks ago and has been for months.” But for those content creators who are operating their own solo media businesses, that public breaking point often never comes. They've reached some level of "success," in that they're making more than pizza money, but clearing that next hurdle to where they're pulling down something resembling a living wage is seeming increasingly unreachable. Many are left wondering if they’re progressing, treading water, or just slowly drowning. It can be an intensely lonely experience, especially when everyone around you seems to be doing just swell. That’s why I found it so refreshing to read this piece in the Hoarse Whisperings newsletter titled “I am presently failing.” I’m not super familiar with HW — as I’ll refer to him from here forward — but I do know that he’s built a sizable following on Twitter, and at some point he launched a paid newsletter on Substack. Though he experienced encouraging subscription growth early on, that growth eventually plateaued and even reversed itself. And while HW points to a number of causes — including Elon Musk’s decision to punish Substack links on Twitter — the underlying problem is the one that every subscription business faces eventually:
For better or worse, paid subscription models are the easiest to implement for the vast majority of content creators, and I think many would identify with HW’s struggles. After a certain point, building a subscription business starts feeling more and more like wading through molasses, to the point where you may stop growing all together. It can be a quite maddening experience, especially since there’s no readily apparent remedy. It feels even worse when you keep coming across creators who humble brag about their eye-popping subscription numbers. The entire situation can leave you feeling wholly inadequate as a content creator. I’ve been operating as a full-time creator for over three years, and there certainly have been times when I felt this inadequacy myself. But I’ve always managed to push through and find a path forward. Here are the strategies I’ve used to adapt: Talk to other media operators As I mentioned above, most media entrepreneurs aren’t keen on publicly broadcasting their failures, but I’ve found they’re much more willing to open up in a private conversation. Over the last few years, I’ve assembled a growing network of media operators that I correspond with regularly through DMs, email, and even phone calls. Many of them have shared their own struggles across a range of issues, and it’s helped contextualize the problems I’m facing. What’s more, these discussions have led to key insights into how to troubleshoot those problems. The network essentially served as a high-value focus group wherein a member’s own experience informed the feedback they gave. I’ve definitely had a few lightbulb ideas that were triggered through my conversations with others. Reassess your subscription strategy Too many media businesses set their subscription strategies on autopilot; they start with assumptions about what drives audience conversions from free to paid, and then stay wedded to those strategies moving forward. They assume that what worked to convert the initial cohort of paid subscribers will also work on the next cohort. Let’s consider Netflix and Spotify for a moment. By some measures, they’re among the most successful subscription businesses of all time, with each company serving hundreds of millions of recurring customers. In the past decade, has there been a single year when either of these companies didn’t push forward a major shift in their strategy — whether it was through their content offerings, optimization, or marketing? Of course not! That’s because subscriptions aren’t a single puzzle to be solved, but rather they’re an ever-shifting landscape of consumer trends and motivations. Over time, marketing channels get saturated and successful conversion levers become less effective. I’m constantly testing out new subscriber offerings and ways to market them. Several weeks ago, for instance, I got the idea to introduce a formal process so new subscribers could book a half-hour introductory phone call with me. This unlocked a sizable burst of conversions from readers who had been on the fence about subscribing. Recently, I began working on another subscriber feature that I plan to debut in the coming weeks. Recognize that subscriptions alone probably will never be enough Many media businesses are built on the foundation of Kevin Kelly's “1,000 true fans” theory — which posits that content creators only need to find 1,000 people to pay $100 a year in order to generate a decent middle class income. To be clear, I think Kevin Kelly’s essay deserves all the recognition it’s received for pinpointing a fundamental truth about internet economics, but at the same time I’ve come to believe that the vast majority of creators won’t be able to achieve the escape velocity needed to generate 1,000 “true fans.” Subscription economics are brutal and require frequent output of both free and paid content to pull consumers into a sales funnel and convert them. Unfortunately, most creators simply don’t have the capacity to maintain the level of production needed to reach 1,000 concurrent customers. Eventually, the gravitational force of churn becomes too great to overcome. That’s why I’m such a huge advocate of revenue diversification. Whether you’re selling high-priced courses, low-priced ebooks, or sponsorships, each approach allows you to monetize sections of your audience who may otherwise resist paying for a subscription. According to most surveys, only about 20% of adults pay for even a single news subscription, which means a huge portion of your audience is likely unmonetizable through subscriptions alone. Don’t get me wrong; I still think paid subscriptions can form a great foundation for any media business, especially since they incentivize creators to remain hyper focused on serving their audiences. But there’s a reason that even the most successful subscription companies — including Netflix, Spotify, and The New York Times — have embraced diversification: there aren’t quite enough subscribers to go around. The valley of churn is harsh and inhospitable. Often, the only means of escape is to explore other business models. What do you think?
Quick hits"A new study from Pew Research Center, released on Thursday, found that just over half (51%) of the top-ranked podcasts in the US have a video component." [Business Insider] I'm pretty much ready to declare that 99% of the hype around journalism use cases of AI is bullshit. It's not that the longterm potential isn't there, but every article I read on the subject involves media executives issuing vague bromides like "we're exploring all potential applications." It's getting tiresome. Wordpress is launching a paid newsletter product. [TechCrunch] This is actually a really interesting move from Wordpress because it's offering options for both its free and paid accounts. For free accounts, the user simply pays 10% of their subscription revenue, whereas if they upgrade to a paid Wordpress account they pay 0%. Probably the biggest weakness of Substack is that, once a newsletter reaches a certain size, it's incentivized to move off the platform to avoid the 10% fee. With Wordpress, users will simply be able to upgrade and then eliminate the fee — thus Wordpress doesn't lose them as a customer. People are often more willing to pay for in-person connections than they are for content. That's why conferences and other in-person events are such a huge business. [Meagan’s Newsletter] I'm surprised it's taken this long for WashPo to build out its games vertical, given the success of its chief competitor in this niche. [WashPo] Are you sick of me yet?If not, then you might want to follow me on one of these channels where I round up media industry news on a daily basis: You're currently a free subscriber to Simon Owens's Media Newsletter. For the full experience, upgrade your subscription. |
Key phrases
Older messages
Let's talk about growing your sponsorship revenue
Tuesday, June 20, 2023
We've lined up top ad sales experts to answer your questions
Paywalls aren’t blocking access to high-quality news
Tuesday, June 20, 2023
PLUS: CNN is in denial
5 case studies of successful media entrepreneurs
Monday, June 12, 2023
Let's go deep on what made their ventures so successful
You're not optimizing your newsletter enough
Thursday, June 1, 2023
PLUS: I answer your questions
Vice's biggest mistake
Friday, May 26, 2023
PLUS: How to sell your content business
You Might Also Like
☕ Q&AI
Friday, May 3, 2024
Amazon debuts new AI chatbot features. May 03, 2024 Tech Brew PRESENTED BY Splunk It's Friday. TGIF, friends! We're eager to start our weekends and sure you feel the same. Let's get right
Is the Supreme Court quiet quitting?
Friday, May 3, 2024
Plus: World Press Freedom Day, age-gap relationships, and more. May 3, 2024 View in browser Happy Friday! Do you feel like you've heard way more news out of the Supreme Court in recent years than
Peloton's Shake-Up, Kentucky Derby, and April's Best Stories
Friday, May 3, 2024
Facts, without motives.
Numlock News: May 3, 2024 • Orangutans, Cocoa, Retinol
Friday, May 3, 2024
By Walt Hickey Have a great weekend! Orangutans An ape in Indonesia has made headlines as it purportedly produced a poultice. In 2022, an orangutan named Rakus in his early 30s had picked up a gnarly
☕️ A meaty ban
Friday, May 3, 2024
Lab-grown meat bans are gaining traction... May 03, 2024 View Online | Sign Up | Shop Morning Brew PRESENTED BY MassMutual Good morning and Happy Friday. Here's an interesting stat: A new academic
Every State's Richest Person, a Hot Dog Record, and the Golden Retriever Ring Bearer
Friday, May 3, 2024
All but three US states have at least one billionaire resident, and the combined wealth of these 54 billionaires adds up to $1.6 trillion, according to a new Forbes list. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Federal frenzy to patch gaping GitLab account takeover hole [Fri May 3 2024]
Friday, May 3, 2024
Hi The Register Subscriber | Log in The Register {* Daily Headlines *} 3 May 2024 GitLab Federal frenzy to patch gaping GitLab account takeover hole Warning comes exactly a year after the vulnerability
✅ Cheat codes for life
Friday, May 3, 2024
Fun stuff to click on, watch, and read from CreativeMornings HQ. May 2, 2024 Open in new tab Did a friend forward this? Subscribe today. Speech bubble logo with the words, CreativeMornings "Never
The hateful bait
Thursday, May 2, 2024
President Biden urged protestors to stay peaceful, as demonstrations and arrests continued to roil campuses around the country. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
The House Antisemitism Bill Is Bad for the Jews and Free Speech
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Columns and commentary on news, politics, business, and technology from the Intelligencer team. Intelligencer the national interest The House Antisemitism Bill Is Bad for the Jews And free speech. UCLA