What George Michael's greatest song teaches us about art
This is the Rubesletter from Matt Ruby. I’m a comedian, writer, and the creator of Vooza. Every Tuesday, I send essays, jokes, and videos to your inbox. You’re on the free plan, for the full experience, sign up for a paid subscription. What George Michael's greatest song teaches us about artHe took the most unrelatable topic you can imagine (i.e. being a massive – and closeted – pop star) and turned it into a universal anthem that speaks to all of us.There’s a neat chronology to how the Beatles defined the sixties, bursting onto the scene in ’63 and riding their bigger-than-Jesus wave until Let it Be came out in 1970. From shaggy mop-tops to long-haired hippies, they wind up serving as the perfect prism for viewing that decade. In a way, George Michael did that for the 80’s. Wham hit in ’83 and became massive (as seen in a new doc on Netflix). Then, he went solo and achieved even greater success with Faith in ’87. And he closed out the decade with a song that burnt it all down and set him on a different path. His trajectory is like a time capsule of that era: He started as a pop cheerleader during the trickle-down, coked out Thatcher/Reagan years and garnered massive success as Wall Street told us “greed is good.” Eventually, he looked in the mirror, realized he hated what he had become, and vowed to start anew in a more authentic way. George Michael in the 80’s was all of us. And the song he wrote that put it all to bed was “Freedom ‘90.”
Like a prisoner who has his own key The reason there’s a ‘90 in the title is Michael wrote another (different) song called “Freedom” back when he was in Wham. (Note: Technically, it’s “Wham!” but I refuse to use the “!” at the end because I’m allergic to faux enthusiasm.) The lyrics to that “Freedom”… Like a prisoner who has his own key … set the table for the ‘90 version. The earlier song’s narrator has imprisoned himself yet sings about someone else’s freedom – and how much he doesn’t want it. And then we hear a closeted gay man sing, “Girl, all I want right now is you.” Girl? Look, sometimes you gotta give the teenyboppers (and the Chinese) what they want: Sometimes you “go go” along to get along. The two “Freedom” songs feed into each other via their titles and a shared theme: Your identity can be a trap. Wesley Morris’ review of the Wham doc:
Around 1984, Michael went on kids’ TV and said his favorite record was Joy Division’s Closer. Imagine dressing up like this… …while feeling like this: Turns out George Michael (born Georgios Kyriacos Panayiotou) was not the man he seemed to be. Wham, ‘Whisper, and Wallace The doc is a fun, breezy watch and makes you realize how many Wham tracks were just refried Motown ditties. You can easily imagine Diana Ross or the Temptations singing half their hits. And oof, those outfits. Somehow, the group constantly looked like they were ready to play an arena and/or teach aerobics. “All That She Wants” is a banger, no doubt. And you can’t deny the pep rally catchiness of “‘Go Go” and “I’m Your Man.” But Wham’s clear masterpiece was “Careless Whisper” (which was the start of Michael veering off into solo territory). That sax riff is one of the most iconic in history. (I’ve still gotta give the all-timer 🎷 intro trophy to Gerry Rafferty's “Baker Street.”) “‘Whisper” is a gorgeous track and we’ve all heard it tons of times. Sometimes, the best way to get at the the nuance of a song is to listen to an instrumental version. Check out the Delvon Lamarr Organ Trio doing a cover of it that absolutely cooks… Love when a cover illuminates the original this way. Minus the big production and vocal shine, you can really tune in to the song’s intricate arrangement and lush melodies. Sidebar: Want another example of an instrumental version that makes you rethink what you know about the original? Check out the Wrecking Crew bringing it on “I Get Around.” The vocals dominate in the regular Beach Boys version because, well, it’s the Beach Boys. But underneath the vocal heavy mix is a handclappin’ surf orchestra letting it rip like they just stole all the amphetamines from a pharmacy. Back to George Michael: He eventually dumped Andrew Ridgely, who seems to have taken it all in stride – and pretty much saw it coming because how long can you expect a guy who looks like a Greek god and writes platinum-selling singles to stay musically monogamous? Speaking of, professional jealousy is a meaty topic that rarely gets addressed in an honest way. Often, people pretend to be happy for their more successful peers in public while talking 💩 about them behind their backs. Confused notions of respect, envy, and status bubble underneath but rarely surface. The best exploration of it I’ve seen is in End of the Tour, a movie about author David Foster Wallace and David Lipsky, a journalist profiling him. They talk all about life, career, and art with both knowing one of them is the greatest writer alive and the other wishing it was him. At the end of the flick, the David Foster Wallace character admits the image and the reality are misaligned.
In a way, that sums up Michael’s crisis too. Ya gotta have Faith Faith, Michael’s first solo album, made him a massive star but left him feeling hollow. It was a vehicle for him to deliver Top Gun meets Elvis shtick on “Faith,” Prince schmoozing with Marvin on “I Want Your Sex,” and Phil Collins going full Freudian on “Father Figure.” And yet, behind the scenes, Michael couldn’t function. The album dominated the culture so much it led to Dana Carvey doing a bit on SNL, as Michael, commanding Dennis Miller to look at his butt: “It’s a total circle…Accept it before it destroys you.” SNL note: If you ask me when SNL was the best, it was probably this era. You know why? Because I was in middle/high school back then. And that’s the era when everyone thinks SNL was at its best – whenever they were a teenager. And that’s a noteworthy takeaway: SNL is made for teenagers. Lorne has spent decades trying to appeal to middle American youth. So when grown adults prattle on about SNL (see: media elites on social media) as if it’s an ongoing “state of the union” for comedy, I always want to shake them, tell them they’re judging a restaurant based on the kiddie menu, and bring them to an actual comedy club. Michael couldn’t handle the combo of massive success and mockery. He did everything he could to make us love him, yet we still didn’t respect him. He wanted us to admire his mind, but we just wanted to stare at his butt. And that set the table for his cri de coeur: “Freedom ’90.” Burn the past It starts with the groove, a marvelous, percussive amalgam of “Sympathy for the Devil,” mixed with the Manchester sound of Primal Scream and Happy Mondays, funky James Jamerson-ish bass, Shaft wah wah rhythm guitar, a beat from the oft-sampled James Brown song "Funky Drummer," and an Aretha-esque church choir. It’s an irresistible combo that makes it a bulletproof go-to for any DJ who wants to get the dance floor moving. Where it gets really interesting is with the lyrics. Tracks like that are typcally paired with throwaway June-moon-spoon rhymes. But here, we get Michael going introspective and creating an ode to changing your mind. It’s a love song about loving yourself, regardless of the consequences. And it redefines freedom as evolution. And then there’s the video, directed by David Fincher, starring all those supermodels. Michael’s subtext: “You want pretty? Fine, here’s pretty. It just won’t be coming from me anymore.” In 1990, Michael explained:
In the video, Michael’s Faith accessories (a leather jacket, a Wurlitzer jukebox, and a guitar) explode in a ball of flame as the word "freedom" hits during the chorus. In the track, Michael manages to accomplish something incredible: He takes a song about perhaps the most unrelatable topic you can imagine (being one of the world’s biggest pop stars while also being closeted) and turns it into a universal anthem that speaks to anyone who yearns to break free from their past. It’s a lesson in making art: The path to the universal is through the specific and personal. That narrative may be completely foreign to 99.99999% of the world, yet we can all relate to its emotional core. Plus, it makes you wanna get up and move. Mind and body, unite. The path to the universal is through the specific and personal. Today the way I play the game is not the same Let’s break it down… Heaven knows I was just a young boy When you’re young, you don’t really know what you want. You take the attention however it comes. You pretend and create an image. You wear what they tell you to wear and you sing what they want you to sing. At first, it’s enough. But then…well, here’s Michael in that ‘90 interview:
To win the race, a prettier face TV was everything back then. So you do what the execs want, they put you on the air, and you reap the rewards. But what happens when getting everything fails to make you happy? The only way you can be truly depressed is after you have it all. Because then, it’s up to you. More stuff/power/fame didn’t solve it, so you have to solve it. In the end, you realize you must manufacture your own happiness. I think there's something you should know Eventually, you need to come clean. You need to tell them the truth. If the person they know is not who you are, it’s unsustainable. You must deny your past to embrace your future. The only way out (of the closet) is through. All we have to do now The chorus arrives with a shift from first person to third. It’s not just you or me, it’s all of us. We must take our lies and make them true. We must be like the trees, breathing in the carbon dioxide and turning it into oxygen. I am not your property, nor are you mine. Freedom. Cue the choir. Let’s sing it all together: Freedom! We had every big-shot good-time band on the run, boy That’s the thing about success: You’ve got to define it for yourself. Because otherwise you just winding up programming your life according to someone else’s functional spec. You can spend decades grinding nonstop just to get to a place they wanted to go. The only way to win is to stop playing another person’s game. Instead, go inside yourself and keep asking, “What makes me satisfied?” Well it looks like the road to heaven Now the bridge. We go from major to minor and the vocals go spoken word. What looks like heaven can feel like hell. Every time you pose for a photo, you “take the knife.” In modern terms: Ask all those influencers what life is like when the camera goes away. You shake your ass to get over but it sticks to you. How will all these OnlyFans twerkers react in the future when they go to meet their boyfriend’s parents and feel the wrath? Some mistakes are built to last. That's what you get The world punishes you for evolving. Becoming someone new is viewed as faking it. Changing your mind is a betrayal. Flip flopper! You’ve broken a promise you never made. That’s what you get. Yet you must anyway. May not be what you want from me During the slow fade out, we learn there is no choice here. Like that t-shirt Michael once famously wore, you must choose life. It’s not what they want, but it’s “the way it’s got to be.” Mic drop, meet mask drop. The flip side of freedom: It can be terrifying. It’s like another brilliant songwriter, Kris Kristofferson, once wrote: Freedom’s just another word for nothin’ left to lose. In Infinite Jest, Wallace writes:
“It is tragic and sad and chaotic and lovely.” That’s also how freedom feels. It is nothing left to lose, yet somehow it’s also everything. Welcome to what you wanted…also, sorry it’s terrifying…plus, you’re welcome. Sound contradictory? Well, all that’s left to do is take these lies and make them true. Quickies🎯 That this generation’s Jerry Garcia is John Mayer kinda says it all. It’s like trading in a wildfire for one of those battery powered candles. 🎯 Ron Desantis is just like that Clubhouse app: Got good traction during pandemic but now everyone just ignores it. 🎯 The richest man in the world tryna crowdsource a free logo within 24 hours is everything you need to know about the current state of graphic design. 🎯 So many Barbie bashes last weekend. Need someone to throw an Oppenheimer party. Just angry men in fedoras wondering what they’ve done. 🎯 Gerwig missed it: The Barbie movie shoulda been called Little Women 2. 🎯 Barbenheimer just proves how much we go with the flow if it’s a golden portmanteau. (I call that a gomanteau.) 🎯 Re: religious freaks in USA vs. the ones in Israel, at least the ones in America have the decency to serve in the military. These Israeli ones wanna have their rugelach and eat it too. 🎯 Odd how the more a woman hates men, the more likely she is to dress like one. It’s as if BLM protesters decided to dress up in police uniforms. 🎯 I have had many discussions with my therapist about gender stuff and would like to share what she taught me: When you make wide-ranging assumptions ("men/women are like this...") about the other gender, you're usually really revealing more about you and how you see the world than anything about them. 🎯 I will never understand watching a DJ. They barely move. It’s like crowding around to watch a cashier ring someone up. 🎯 Ladies, good line for when a creep hits on you: "Actually, I have a nut allergy. I don't want you to nut anywhere near me." 🎯 We've lost sight of the phrase "on average." Too many convos like this: "Women tend to prefer men who are taller than them." "Not all women! My friend dates a man shorter than her!" "Sure, I'm just saying that on average–" "No, I proved you wrong." Sigh. 🎯 The big issue with dating now is we think people should behave like apps. But people don't come with a Preferences screen. You can't just tick off the checkboxes you like and customize your perfect mate. The truth: Human beings arrive with their default settings intact and rarely, if ever, "upgrade." 🎯 Ugh. This is how it begins... Comedy🃏 I post clips of my standup (and more) at Instagram, TikTok, Threads, and YouTube. Podcast🃏 Last three eps of my KOAL podcast have featured deep dives on some classic Rubyisms…the most recent one:
Here’s a clip from ep22: 5-spottedI dig the Italian term passeggiata:
The secret to social media fame: The dumber, the better.
Bob Lefsetz praising David Sedaris:
Washington Post’s Helaine Olen making the case against QR codes:
You are not that unique, according to Benjamin Godsill.
Not me, I’m a special snowflake! ❄️ OK, think I'm gonna get me some happy. Best, You’re on the free list for The Rubesletter by Matt Ruby. For the full experience, become a paying subscriber. Watch “Substance,” Matt’s 2023 comedy special where he performs sets high, drunk, sober, and on shrooms. Check out Matt’s other newsletter: Funny How: Letters to a Young Comedian. Follow Matt elsewhere: Instagram • Twitter • YouTube • TikTok • Facebook |
Older messages
Decades feel like centuries now
Wednesday, July 19, 2023
"Well, THAT did not age well." Of course it didn't. “Aging well” is an oxymoron and the future will frown upon all of us.
There are no heroes here 🦸♂️
Tuesday, July 11, 2023
Threads, Jonah Hill's texts, a great Steve Martin line, Dr. Bronner, and much more.
Hard closing for enemies and strangers
Tuesday, June 27, 2023
Thoughts on fashion, parenting, OceanGate, risk, The Bear, real estate, Madonna, forbidden love, spiritual hierarchy, concept creep, and more.
"This isn't just hurt feelings. I want to give up."
Tuesday, June 20, 2023
An aspiring comedian and I discuss ripple effects, being triggered, and how to deal with toxic comedy.
We don't know how to look 👀
Tuesday, June 13, 2023
On raw power, the jungle, Iggy Pop, and ancient wisdom.
You Might Also Like
Sweden's Oscar Entry 'The Last Journey': Making Dad Beam At All Costs - Clip
Friday, November 22, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 Sweden's Oscar Entry 'The Last Journey': Making Dad Beam At All Costs - Clip By Anthony D'Alessandro This email was sent to
Dwayne Johnson and Chris Evans Christmas Pic 'Red One' Stuffing $100M In Global Box Office Bag
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 Dwayne Johnson & Chris Evans Christmas Pic 'Red One' Stuffing $100M In Global Box Office Bag By Anthony D'Alessandro This email was
Shaboozey Deserves An Apology From the CMA Awards
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 Shaboozey Deserves More Than What the CMA Awards Gave Him - Including an Apology "A Bar Song (Tipsy)" artist boosted country music's
Spotify Newsletter #233
Thursday, November 21, 2024
Your Weekly Dose of Spotify News ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
'Dancing With The Stars' Season 33 Semifinals Hit Season-High Audience and Break Fan Voting Record Again
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 'Dancing With The Stars' Season 33 Semifinals Hit Season-High Audience & Break Fan Voting Record Again By Katie Campione This email was
too big to ban
Thursday, November 21, 2024
A new Trapital episode and memo on TikTok's 2024, its future in the US, and relationship with music ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Paramount Tweaks Theatrical Rollout Of 'Better Man' and 'September 5' During Awards Season
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 Paramount Tweaks Theatrical Rollout Of 'Better Man' & 'September 5' During Awards Season By Anthony D'Alessandro This email
'Landman' Expands Taylor Sheridan's Empire With Best Paramount+ Series Launch In 2 Years
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 'Landman' Expands Taylor Sheridan's Empire With Best Paramount+ Series Launch In 2 Years By Katie Campione This email was sent to
‘Drowning Dry’: Lithuanian Oscar Entry and Locarno Award-Winner Lands U.S. Distribution Deal
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 'Drowning Dry': Lithuanian Oscar Entry & Locarno Award-Winner Lands US Distribution Deal By Zac Ntim This email was sent to
Anti-Abortion Group Has a Conspiracy Theory for RFK Jr.
Thursday, November 21, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe November 21, 2024 Anti-Abortion Group Hopes to Convince RFK Jr. Abortion Pills Are Poisoning Our Water Students for Life has petitioned the FDA to investigate “