Horrific-Terrific - 💔 Love Doesn't Scale
Yep, I’m a data scientist. Okay now on with the main thing. You know, I thought I was too young to get a stomach ulcer until I read the Techno-Optimist Manifesto which was released earlier this week by Andreessen Horowitz, the biggest VC firm in Silicon Valley. Tbh I was really trying to avoid looking at it but everyone kept talking about it so I gave in. If you didn’t know by now, I hate capitalism and critique it at every opportunity. But even if that wasn’t true: I’ve never read anything that demonstrates a fundamental hatred of humankind more than this does. The whole thing is an Ayn Rand wet dream of infinite growth and abundance. It says, pretty much in the same breath, that humans are not exploited by the free market, yet their entire purpose is to be useful and productive. I’m not going to pick apart the whole thing (because frankly it’s completely unhinged), but it has everything you might expect from a16z: an expert conflation of technological progress and human progress; the continual malignment of things such as collective action and sustainability as ‘enemies’; the aggressively narrow vision that stagnation will lead to death; and of course the general idea that capitalism isn’t just an ideological choice, but a moral one, and we must all submit to it like a new religion or face being left in a societal ditch like a putrid commie who refuses to upgrade to the latest iPhone. The thing that really gets me with hyper-capitalist rhetoric is the stuff about never-ending innovation and abundance. Never mind for a minute that ‘infinite everything’ is impossible, it’s also completely at odds with what capitalists do, which is to restrict, enclose, and make scarce. In fact, when an attempt is made to build something that even just feels infinite — like the internet — capitalists are the first ones to chop it up and sell it back to us. This silly manifesto has come while we are nipple-deep in a multi-verse of subscription models monetisation projects. Elon Musk has just decided to start charging $1 a year for people to post on Twitter. Microsoft’s Copilot is no longer free. Reddit’s third-party apps now have to start charging or shut down because the API has become so expensive. And the CEO of Unity has had to step down because of his new, grossly unpopular monetisation scheme. It’s kind of hard to agree that capitalism + tech = abundance when every time I want to do something of any use with a piece of software, I have to pick a payment plan first. The world of SaaS seems to force us to approach our personal suite of tools and gadgets like a small business would, where you have to weigh up the costs and benefits of glorified word processors and kanban boards. To me, abundance in these contexts would be getting to use software and experience online spaces without restriction. It’s especially patronising to be told that we live in a limitless world by the very people that are imposing limits. Nothing is limitless, which means you cannot — no matter how many times Marc Andreessen insists you can — grow infinitely. Even our new all-powerful AI systems have limits, and therefore a cost. You have to mine the precious metals which hold together the circuit boards that make up the GPUs that power things like large language models, and then you have to run these GPUs indefinitely, until they completely burn out, and continually keep them cool with water which, again, has to come from somewhere. All that extraction costs the Earth a great deal, and costs the consumer a monthly subscription fee. The extraction of finite resources works us towards scarcity… not abundance. The ‘infinite growth’ mindset comes from people who’ve mangled their cognition by watching numbers on a screen go up all day. We’ve seen this play out in a bunch of ways now: aiming to scale infinitely doesn’t work, it just makes your service worse. That’s why social media platforms are rapidly decaying and why Google just kind of sucks now. Because Google doesn’t have to be good, it just has to be big. This week Google’s ongoing antitrust case revealed that they pay Apple annually to be the default search engine on Safari, and this makes up 14-16% of Apple’s profits. Brb just trying to figure out who this benefits, other than Google and Apple. Okay, now I’m imagining how much iPhones will increase in price after the courts order Google to stop paying all that money to Apple every year. Abundance, amirite? Not to labour the point, but the Microsoft-Activision deal is also going through, which means Microsoft will own, and therefore probably restrict access to, loads of popular computer games. In tech at least, this honestly feels a renaissance of enclosure, not of endless wonders and innovation. But I will say that this Techno-Optimist Manifesto did concede that there’s one thing out there impervious to growth. Apparently (and this is verbatim) “love doesn’t scale” — hard to scale something you’ve never experienced, I guess — thus the natural conclusion here is “let’s stick with money”. Can’t argue with that. 💌 Thank you for subscribing to Horrific/Terrific. If you need more reasons to distract yourself try looking at my website or maybe this ridiculous zine that I write or how about these silly games that I’ve made. Enjoy! |
Older messages
🌍 New spheres of reality
Friday, October 6, 2023
Somewhere to escape to while the world comes crashing down around us
💦 “Tits are for breastfeeding” | A conversation about porn and child safety
Friday, September 29, 2023
The online safety bill is becoming real; I interviewed a sex worker about how it will effect their work
🌌 Olivia Colman Cinematic Universe
Monday, September 11, 2023
Making content about content to train AI models to make further content (about content)
🔍 Where are all my precious answers?
Friday, September 1, 2023
They've been eaten by a corporation, deal with it like the rest of us and buy twenty different media subscriptions
🐍 Automation is a snake eating its own tail
Friday, July 28, 2023
The division of labour and the fallacy that automation provides freedom from work
You Might Also Like
Charted | Global Economic Confidence in 2025, by Country 🌎
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
While emerging markets in Asia have the strongest confidence in the global economy looking ahead, European countries are most pessimistic. View Online | Subscribe | Download Our App FEATURED STORY
Top Tech Deals 🎅 Sony Headphones, iPhone Cases, 4K Projector, and More!
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
The season of giving is upon us. How-To Geek Logo December 25, 2024 Top Tech Deals: Sony Headphones, iPhone Cases, 4K Projector, and More! The season of giving is upon us. Happy Holidays! If you're
Why the Race to AGI is Humanitys Defining Moment
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
Top Tech Content sent at Noon! Boost Your Article on HackerNoon for $159.99! Read this email in your browser How are you, @newsletterest1? 🪐 What's happening in tech today, December 25, 2024? The
Iran's Charming Kitten Deploys BellaCPP: A New C++ Variant of BellaCiao Malware
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
THN Daily Updates Newsletter cover The Data Science Handbook, 2nd Edition ($60.00 Value) FREE for a Limited Time Practical, accessible guide to becoming a data scientist, updated to include the latest
Software Testing Weekly - Issue 251
Wednesday, December 25, 2024
GitHub Copilot is free! 🤖 View on the Web Archives ISSUE 251 December 25th 2024 COMMENT Welcome to the 251st issue! In case you missed it — GitHub Copilot is free! The free version works with Visual
Daily Coding Problem: Problem #1647 [Medium]
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
Daily Coding Problem Good morning! Here's your coding interview problem for today. This problem was asked by Square. In front of you is a row of N coins, with values v 1 , v 1 , ..., v n . You are
Sentiment Analysis, Topological Sort, Web Security, and More
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
Exploring Modern Sentiment Analysis Approaches in Python #661 – DECEMBER 24, 2024 VIEW IN BROWSER The PyCoder's Weekly Logo Exploring Modern Sentiment Analysis Approaches in Python What are the
🤫 Do Not Disturb Mode Is My Secret to Sanity — 8 Gadgets I Want To See Nintendo Make
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
Also: The Best Christmas Movies to Watch on Netflix, and More! How-To Geek Logo December 24, 2024 Did You Know Their association with the Christmas season might make you think poinsettias hail from a
😱 AzureEdge.net DNS Retiring Jan. 2025, 🚀 Microsoft Phi-4 AI Outperforms, 🔒 Microsoft Secure Future Initiative
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
Blog | Advertise | View Online Your trusted source for Cloud, AI and DevOps guidance with industry expert Chris Pietschmann! Phi-4: Microsoft's New Small Language Model Outperforms Giants in AI
Mapped | The Top Health Insurance Companies by State 🏥
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
In 13 US states, a single company dominates the health insurance market, holding at least half of the total market share. View Online | Subscribe | Download Our App Presented by: Global X ETFs Power