Enough thorns can become an impenetrable bramble
Thanks for reading Story Cauldron, where I investigate stories and storytelling. If you enjoy what you’re reading, please consider sharing this newsletter with a friend. Welcome once again to Story Cauldron, where I publish my original fiction as well as occasional articles about storytelling in the real world and related topics. Today, I want to address something very topical but also rather uncomfortable. I hope you don’t click away. A couple of weeks ago, I shared an open letter to the Substack founders on the subject of Nazis on Substack that followed an article in The Atlantic. I published it both here and on Fictionistas, the community for fiction writers that I co-organize with Geoffrey Goldenof the awesome Substack Adventure Snack. The goal of the letter was to push Substack’s leadership into explaining why they allow Nazis, white supremacists, and other far-right figures to not only publish on this platform but make money on it (and Substack also gets a cut). It wasn’t an ultimatum, just a pressure campaign to get an answer. Racism and hate speech are stochastic terrorism (incitement to violence) even if they don’t overtly mention violence, and most people agree it’s in violation of Substack’s terms of service:
On both Fictionistas and Story Cauldron, after publishing the letter, a handful of people unsubscribed (a situation that has already resolved itself as new subscribers have already replaced those who left), and there was a flurry of conversations over on Substack’s chat platform Notes, as well as in the comments on Fictionistas. Some of the main issues people had with the letter—and my sharing it—can be summed up as follows:
Why did I share the letter?I had several reasons why I jumped at the opportunity to sign on to the Substackers Against Nazis letter. As I commented on Fictionistas,
But it goes beyond all of this. Why fiction writers shouldn’t hide from the issueIt’s easy for some people to put their heads in the sand and say, “I’m apolitical,” or that they don’t want their work to be associated with controversy. I mean, wouldn’t it be nice if we could just pretend for a moment that Nazis died out in 1940s Germany? Wouldn’t it be nice? But they didn’t, and pretending otherwise is disingenuous at best. Arguing that Nazis should have a right to spread their hate speech (under the guise of “free speech”) is absurd because Nazis don’t believe in free speech. They have no problem invading and infecting every form of media to spread their propaganda, lies, and hatred—and silencing their opposition. That’s what Nazis do. And lots of fiction authors much bigger than me are standing up against Nazis on Substack. Case in point: Margaret Atwood, who knows a little about fascism. As she wrote on her Substack,
And if that’s not enough, it’s also a question of what Substack could become if the Nazi problem continues unabated. As S Peter Davis points out in his article about moderation on social media platforms, if fascist rhetoric is allowed to continue on Substack unabated, there may be a point when that’s all that’s left. Fighting Nazis is personalIn addition to the millions of people who opposed the Nazis in WWII or died under their regime, my grandfathers both fought the Nazis (and carried the weight of their efforts for the rest of their lives), and members of my extended family in Croatia were some of the Nazis’ victims. We beat them once. I don’t want my generation to have to fight these battles—or fall victim to this ideology—again. As an outspoken leftist who identifies with the LGBTQ+ community and who has many friends who are people of color, immigrants, and/or non-binary/trans—and as a student of history who has studied how the Nazis came to power the first time around—I will stand up against today’s fascists and Nazis at every opportunity. But even if I weren’t directly impacted and had no family history of fighting Nazis, this would still be personal. Nazis believe that some people, simply due to their location and position of birth, skin color, religion, or sexual or gender identity, do not deserve equal rights. Some say those people don’t deserve to live. And those sentiments are alive and well and being shared on Substack every day. The outcome of the letterThis is a Substack about storytelling, after all, and it wouldn’t be a good story without the ending. The good news is that, after years of being asked their position on this topic, the Substack leadership finally responded to the open letter shared by more than 200 Substacks (including Atwood) and covered by major news media. So despite the people asking, “What are you hoping to achieve?” the public pressure campaign worked. The bad news is that while the leadership responded, it was a wishy-washy statement (on Notes, rather than an actual post on Substack, so it will be harder to find in the future). They claim they don’t like Nazis, but Substack won’t ban their content based on free speech principles (although, interestingly, other content, including porn, is banned, so they do censor some things). The tone-deaf response doesn’t address the root of the problem or why hundreds of people are upset, leading some Substack writers to announce they’re leaving Substack. As the New York Times wrote,
So what’s my plan?I’m not happy about Substack’s response at all. However, I’ve enjoyed being on the platform over the past couple of years and have made a number of friends here. I have also greatly expanded the audience and reach of my writing. Story Cauldron is an effective place to share my writing; Fictionistas has grown into a delightful and vibrant community; and Unseen St. Louis has opened so many doors and allowed me to share local history with a sizable audience. So, for now, I plan to join others, such asAnne Helen Petersen, who intend to remain on Substack and be thorns in the leadership’s side. If enough of us become thorns, perhaps together, we can grow into an impenetrable bramble, and change will become inevitable. Think of it a little like the French Resistance but on Substack. Let’s fight like hell to keep the Nazis from destroying this little patch of the Internet. Thanks for reading. I hope to return very soon with more fiction and updates on my novels, so stay tuned! You’re on the free list for Story Cauldron. For the full experience and to be the first in the world to read my next novel, consider becoming a paying subscriber. |
Older messages
Substackers against Nazis
Friday, December 15, 2023
A collective letter to Substack leadership
FOUND
Saturday, October 21, 2023
A flash fiction story set in my Favor Faeries world
Rising from the rubble
Friday, September 29, 2023
An update on my Labor Day writing experiment and new ideas
Fighting back against the writing slog
Thursday, August 31, 2023
A plan to combat burnout by writing something entirely new
Busy busy busy!
Friday, July 7, 2023
What I've been up to lately, and a sneak peek at my latest project
You Might Also Like
Food for Agile Thought #441: The Hexi Approach to Scaling, Good and Bad Product Coaches, Product Roadmap Failure
Sunday, May 5, 2024
Also: Kaizen, OKR Fragility, Decision Frameworks, Guide to Product Surveys
FTI #411: In retrospect...
Sunday, May 5, 2024
You don't know what you're doing. You think you do, but you don't. Neither do I. Now, on to this week's ideas... *** The Starting Five 1. How To Create A Business Process Map
Now Open <> End of May Holiday Newsletter Promo for Authors + Social media
Sunday, May 5, 2024
For Authors ~ Join Our Book Newsletter for Summer Reading Enable Images to See This Join ContentMo's MAY 2024 Summer Reading Promotion & Get Your Book Emailed ~ Tweeted & posted to Facebook
Peaky Blinders saved my life
Saturday, May 4, 2024
My morning date with Thomas Shelby
What would your life be like with LESS stuff?
Saturday, May 4, 2024
Five years ago I made a choice that changed my life. I was at home with my kids, drowning in stuff, and not the present, happy mom I wanted to be. (It wasn't even our home. We had too much consumer
🎙️ Find That Pod #260
Friday, May 3, 2024
Check out these 5 great podcasts...and bring some awesomeness to your ears. Let's take a look at this week's recommendations. ADVERTISEMENT 5 great podcasts to discover… Welcome to the 260th
Around the Newsletter Universe (May Edition)
Friday, May 3, 2024
feed your inbox.
Where do you start?
Friday, May 3, 2024
We have 4 updates for you this week: 1. Where do you start improving your website? Congrats you want to improve your website performance. Everyone has their ideas on where to start. Your competitors
📌 Double Days Sale 📌 Promo Pins for Authors for a Limited Time
Friday, May 3, 2024
Advertise on Pinterest boards that get thousands of views/month Enable Images to See This PINTEREST PROMOS FOR AUTHORS & PUBLISHERS Enable Images to See This $30 for 30 Days of Pins! & ORDER BY
🎤 SWIPES Email (Friday May 3rd, 2024)
Friday, May 3, 2024
The SWIPES Email Edition: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 An educational (and fun) email by Copywriting Course. Enjoy! 🎤 Listen to this email here: Swipe: You know your Uncle Neville, he loves a good