Tedium - Pixel-Perfect? 🎨

The Apple-Pixelmator deal makes sense. Just look at its feature set.

Hunting for the end of the long tail • November 02, 2024

Pixel-Perfect?

Apple makes a move to acquire an app so Apple-like that you might be surprised to learn it’s not first-party: Pixelmator. During an age when Adobe is laser-focused on the enterprise to its peril, this might be a good thing.

It’s not often I can say I’m good at predicting the future, but here’s what I wrote in January:

There are some interesting image editors out there that don’t get the attention of the primary three: Pixelmator, for MacOS, recently gained video-editing capabilities, for example, making it an excellent partner to Final Cut Pro (and a probable acquisition target for Apple, if it was so interested).

It took nearly ten months, but Apple pulled this exact trigger, acquiring the company behind Pixelmator, which also develops a photo-editing app along the lines of the dearly departed Aperture, earlier this week. (It still faces regulatory approval, but odds are it will go through.)

As I have noted throughout 2024, the creative software economy is at something of a crossroads. Adobe has a lot of power in the sector, in large part because of its ownership of Photoshop, Premiere, InDesign, and Acrobat, four tools that absolutely dominate their respective sectors. Other companies have some, but not all, of the parts needed to compete with this lineup: Canva has its Web-based editor as well as the Affinity Suite, and older players like Corel and Quark, can cover some of these use cases. But Adobe is in a unique spot, because it’s so dominant in so many workflows, often at an enterprise scale, and it charges with that in mind.

Apple always struck me as a company that could directly compete with Adobe, if it wanted to and felt that its market dominance elsewhere would not create a fly-crushing dynamic. The logic is there, and not just in the form of Logic. For one thing, Adobe has not always been particularly respectful of Apple’s software conventions, meaning that running Photoshop or InDesign isn’t a particularly native experience on MacOS. And, despite controversies about some of its more dramatic software changes, Final Cut Pro is one of the few best-in-class apps that can truly compete with Premiere. Plus, if you squint hard enough at Freeform, Preview, and Pages, you can see that many of the elements of having a full design-software ecosystem are there, if they add just a few more pro features and add more precise tweaking. (Plus, the fact that the Mac windowing system is built around PDF technology gives it a unique advantage it could exploit if it so chose.)

The one thing Apple was really missing was a good image editor. Honestly, until now, it didn’t even have a bad one. Unlike Windows, the modern MacOS has never had an app like Microsoft Paint baked in. (Given the large number of creative apps, it didn’t need to.)

Pixelmator seemed like it was trying extremely hard to be Mac’s missing image editor, to the point where it became difficult to differentiate it from an Apple developed app. Pixelmator doesn’t have my one must-have feature, animated GIF support, but it does have a lot of other things going for it—and if you ask me, those things are why Apple decided it had to get in on the action.

We are seeing a lot of people speculate that Apple bought the app to kill it, pointing at the deconstruction of the weather app Dark Sky, but it really doesn’t highlight what the app has done. About two years ago, Pixelmator introduced video-editing functionality which made it a surprisingly lightweight alternative to Final Cut Pro that could be used for color grading and even live image editing. It not only used Apple’s UI styling to do so, but also its API frameworks. It made Apple’s own internal tools better by using them in ways that Apple themselves perhaps hadn’t considered.

By combining a Photoshop-like experience with a traditional video editing workflow, it felt like Pixelmator, long seen as a second-fiddle to Photoshop and Affinity Photo, had started to find a unique lane that nobody else was touching in quite the same way. Photoshop could already edit video, but not quite like this.

If Apple killed this app which made its best professional app work even better, they’d be absolutely stupid. Apple most assuredly bought this app because it looked like something Apple made themselves. Acquisitions in this spirit often stick around in real ways, even if not exactly in the same form as before the big purchase. A good example of this is the automation app Workflow, which also benefited from looking like something Apple built themselves. The company bought it, and turned it into Shortcuts, which is essentially Workflow, except with a more direct integration into iOS. That, to me, seems like the direction Apple would want to go with this.

But one wonders what the Pixelmator team could bring to the rest of the Apple lineup. Could they make Pages a little more pro-friendly? Could they give Freeform a use case beyond “ambitious tech demo”?

If Apple could figure this out, Adobe may be giving them an opening. The chatter around artificial intelligence has been coming from the Adobe camp in ways that seem sort of dismissive to the role of the creator.

On this front, Pixelmator actually looks quite good. The reason: They have actually used technologies like machine learning, but have done so in ways that empower the creator, rather than augment them. Beyond the recent work in video, the company has also developed features like ML Super Resolution. That tech, as suggested by the name, uses machine learning to size up small images at high quality—a major pain point for people who work in print settings in particular. It has also done some impressive work in the realm of image masking as well.

In this light, Pixelmator looks like a company that has been quietly innovating by adding features their users actually want, while still cleverly implementing the latest technologies. Meanwhile, Adobe has been adding features that sound better to their bosses.

And Apple, which (for all its faults) has never forgotten that it’s building for consumers first, enterprise second, just scooped up the upstart. This is what happens when you take your eye off the ball.

Unacquired Links

I like what John O’Nolan of Ghost recently wrote about open source governance. We can debate the exact details of their platform, but operationally, their model is the one to follow.

Look, right now, we’re in a nerve-wracking moment, and I’m not exactly finding it easy to navigate on my end. (I’m in redesign mode, and I’d rather think about that than election day.) But in that spirit, I want to share the most blissful piece of art I’m aware of: Pavement’s “Spit On A Stranger.”

As a follow-up to my piece earlier this week, I just want to drop this here. No matter your thoughts on Bezos or the Post, this is what they should be doing right now. It’s a reminder that, when a newspaper has editorial independence from its ownership, they’re allowed to report on them, no matter how bad it makes them look.

--

Find this one an interesting read? Share it with a pal! I am going to figure out something blissed-out to share ahead of Election Day. Will be back in a day or so.

Share this post:

follow on Twitter | privacy policy | advertise with us

Copyright © 2015-2024 Tedium, all rights reserved.

Disclosure: From time to time, we may use affiliate links in our content—but only when it makes sense. Promise.

unsubscribe from this list | view email in browser | sent with Email Octopus

Older messages

Caught In The Middle 💸

Thursday, October 31, 2024

On rich guys, collateral damage, and The Washington Post. Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • October 30, 2024 Caught In The Middle The mess with Bezos and The

Why Butterfingers Break 🍫

Monday, October 28, 2024

Pondering why Butterfingers are often broken in half. Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • October 27, 2024 Today in Tedium: Ok, so we're near Halloween,

Stressing The Protocol 🧮

Wednesday, October 23, 2024

What it's like to back up your tweets on Bluesky. Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • October 23, 2024 Stressing The Protocol I'm trying to import as

So, Your CMS Blew Up 💣

Sunday, October 20, 2024

So, thinking about moving from WordPress for the first time … ever? Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • October 20, 2024 Today in Tedium: Deciding on a content

Gateway Country 🐄

Sunday, October 20, 2024

What Gateway 2000's demise says about outsourcing and globalization. Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • October 13, 2024 Hey all, Ernie here with a

You Might Also Like

Weekend Reading — More time to write

Sunday, November 24, 2024

More Time to Write A fully functional clock that ticks backwards, giving you more time to write. Tech Stuff Martijn Faassen (FWIW I don't know how to use any debugger other than console.log) People

🕹️ Retro Consoles Worth Collecting While You Still Can — Is Last Year's Flagship Phone Worth Your Money?

Saturday, November 23, 2024

Also: Best Outdoor Smart Plugs, and More! How-To Geek Logo November 23, 2024 Did You Know After the "flair" that servers wore—buttons and other adornments—was made the butt of a joke in the

JSK Daily for Nov 23, 2024

Saturday, November 23, 2024

JSK Daily for Nov 23, 2024 View this email in your browser A community curated daily e-mail of JavaScript news React E-Commerce App for Digital Products: Part 4 (Creating the Home Page) This component

Not Ready For The Camera 📸

Saturday, November 23, 2024

What (and who) video-based social media leaves out. Here's a version for your browser. Hunting for the end of the long tail • November 23, 2024 Not Ready For The Camera Why hasn't video

Daily Coding Problem: Problem #1617 [Easy]

Saturday, November 23, 2024

Daily Coding Problem Good morning! Here's your coding interview problem for today. This problem was asked by Microsoft. You are given an string representing the initial conditions of some dominoes.

Ranked | The Tallest and Shortest Countries, by Average Height 📏

Saturday, November 23, 2024

These two maps compare the world's tallest countries, and the world's shortest countries, by average height. View Online | Subscribe | Download Our App TIME IS RUNNING OUT There's just 3

⚙️ Your own Personal AI Agent, for Everything

Saturday, November 23, 2024

November 23, 2024 | Read Online Subscribe | Advertise Good Morning. Welcome to this special edition of The Deep View, brought to you in collaboration with Convergence. Imagine if you had a digital

Educational Byte: Are Privacy Coins Like Monero and Zcash Legal?

Saturday, November 23, 2024

Top Tech Content sent at Noon! How the world collects web data Read this email in your browser How are you, @newsletterest1? 🪐 What's happening in tech today, November 23, 2024? The HackerNoon

🐍 New Python tutorials on Real Python

Saturday, November 23, 2024

Hey there, There's always something going on over at Real Python as far as Python tutorials go. Here's what you may have missed this past week: Black Friday Giveaway @ Real Python This Black

Re: Hackers may have stolen everyone's SSN!

Saturday, November 23, 2024

I wanted to make sure you saw Incogni's Black Friday deal, which is exclusively available for iPhone Life readers. Use coupon code IPHONELIFE to save 58%. Here's why we recommend Incogni for