Speckyboy RSS: Are Google’s Core Web Vitals Metrics Unreasonable?

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!.

Speckyboy Design Magazine

Design News, Resources & Inspiration

Are Google’s Core Web Vitals Metrics Unreasonable?


By Eric Karkovack on Mar 23, 2021 08:15 am


Google’s influence over web designers, website owners, and everyday users is undeniable. The company is hyper-aggressive in detailing what it wants to see from the first two groups in order to serve up relevant results to the third.

One of their more recent efforts in this area revolves around something called “Core Web Vitals”. These metrics are in place to measure user experience. Items such as how quickly a page can be interacted with, it’s responsiveness, and how much visual shift during loading are measured.

Keeping tabs on these factors sure seems like a worthy endeavor. However, it’s not just for convenience. Google is planning to integrate visual indicators of page experience into search results in May 2021. The move has the potential to affect both SEO and how a website is listed on the search engine results page (SERP).

This means websites that don’t meet Google’s benchmarks could see a negative impact on their ranking. There’s also a possible hit with regards to how it displays within results. With that, site performance is going to be more important than ever.

It’s not only a call for web designers to bleed every last millisecond of speed out of their sites. This is also an open question about what Core Web Vitals means to sites on a tight budget or even those running a content management system (CMS): Is Google asking too much?

Tougher Testing

There are a lot of tools out there to measure website performance. Each has their own methodology for generating a report. There will likely be some variance in how the included categories grade out. Thus, they should all be taken with a grain of salt.

That being said, Google’s PageSpeed Insights tool seems to grade on the lower end of the scale. For example, a test website that gets a glowing result on GTmetrix is much less flattering on Google’s offering. The site doesn’t pass the Core Web Vitals standards for mobile.

The point here is not necessarily to complain (although this is quite a bummer). It’s more of a friendly heads-up to web designers: Just because your website looks great in a non-Google testing suite doesn’t mean it will do well in these particular metrics.

Not surprisingly, Google wants you to use their tools to determine how well your site does with Core Web Vitals. As such, all of that tweaking you did to get a great performance grade elsewhere may not impress this particular search giant.

Speed testing comparison between GTmetrix and PageSpeed Insights.

Top: A test site grades well in GTmetrix, while the same site struggles in PageSpeed Insights (bottom).

Who Might Core Web Vitals Potentially Hurt the Most?

If your website doesn’t pass muster when it comes to Google’s Core Web Vitals, some work will be required. First, there’s analyzing the PageSpeed Insights report and determining what needs done. Then it’s time for implementation.

But both budgetary and technological concerns could get in the way for some website owners. Let’s look at a few situations where Core Web Vitals may become extra burdensome:

Low-Budget Websites

Improving website performance costs time and money. Of course, if it helps with SEO, then it might be considered an investment. But it still may be out of reach for those on a tight budget.

When you think about it, there are multiple facets to better performance that need to be explored. That could include refactoring code, optimizing images and eliminating features that are dragging the whole site downward.

The costs for this type of work could easily add up. For an older or particularly slow site, it might end up being more cost-effective to start from scratch with a redesign.

Web hosting is also a potentially huge factor. Those on a lower-end shared hosting account may simply not have enough server resources. Once again, more robust hosting requires more cash.

Websites Running a CMS

A traditional CMS (WordPress, Drupal, etc.) that utilizes a database makes for a more complex case. The overhead from executing queries and other key functionality is generally going to slow down a website.

This is where features such as caching can help. But cache alone may not be enough to satisfy the likes of Google. It may take the use of a content delivery network (CDN) and higher-level web hosting to get things to an acceptable level of performance.

Even then, a bloated theme or plugin could also provide a setback. The WordPress commercial theme market, for example, is chock full of heavy options. Themes that need to load large frameworks and lots of custom code can be beyond the reach of developers.

In these situations, the only way to add enough speed may be switching themes, deactivating plugins or (possibly the most expensive of all) utilizing a headless configuration. These may not be realistic options for every website. At best, these measures are also an inconvenience.

Websites That Use Proprietary Software

Likewise, using a proprietary CMS (Squarespace, Wix, etc.) may leave website owners without a viable path to fixing each and every performance deficiency. While they may allow you to tweak certain bits and pieces of your website, other areas may be completely off limits.

As for server infrastructure, there’s not much to be done there, either. Perhaps an account level upgrade could provide more resources – but that’s up to the vendor to decide.

In general, website owners and developers could be left hoping that their service provider addresses these issues. Anything less will require living with the shortcomings or moving to a different platform.

HTML and CSS code on a screen.

Big Players vs. Everyone Else?

It’s fair to wonder if Google Core Web Vitals inevitably favors those with the most resources. Could a small-budget website with tons of great content be overshadowed by one that simply has more money to throw at performance?

At this point, we simply don’t know how Google would weigh one website against another when these metrics are included. And they aren’t likely to provide all of the details.

In some ways this is all reminiscent of the arguments over net neutrality. The fear being that, if an internet provider gives preference to certain types of traffic over others, it’s going to favor the well-heeled. Small startups could be at a major disadvantage and unable to compete with the big players.

Google may have no intention of favoring speed over quality. But, at the very least, Core Web Vitals seems to be raising the possibility.

Cables connected to a server.

Another Hurdle for SEO Success

It seems like every time we think we know what search engines want, they go and change the game on us. Regardless, the bottom line is that Google Core Web Vitals is going to impact every website that aims to be found in search engines. Naturally, some are going to avoid any potential negative effects better than others.

Great website performance should be on the top of everyone’s wish list – no argument there. But to earn a passing grade on these new metrics, it’s going to take resources. And that will sadly leave some people behind.

In this way, Core Web Vitals could indeed be asking too much. That leads one to wonder if a search engine should be able set such arbitrary requirements in the first place.

The post Are Google’s Core Web Vitals Metrics Unreasonable? appeared first on Speckyboy Design Magazine.



Read in browser »

Recent Articles:

8 Common Website Layouts Built with CSS Grid
Weekly News for Designers № 584
The 10 Best Photoshop Action Sets for Creating the Bokeh Effect
Why Thinking Ahead Is Crucial in Web Design
Do We Really Need to Follow Design Trends?
Share
Tweet
+1
Share
Forward
Copyright © 2021 Speckyboy Design Magazine, All rights reserved.
You signed up for daily Speckyboy Design Magazine email alerts either via Feedburner or directly through our site.

Our mailing address is:
Speckyboy Design Magazine
27 Braeside Park
Inverness, Scotland IV2 7HL
United Kingdom

Add us to your address book


Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

Older messages

Speckyboy RSS: 8 Common Website Layouts Built with CSS Grid

Monday, March 22, 2021

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!. Speckyboy Design Magazine Design News, Resources & Inspiration 8 Common Website Layouts Built with CSS Grid By Eric Karkovack on Mar 21, 2021 05:42 pm Among

Speckyboy RSS: Weekly News for Designers № 584

Saturday, March 20, 2021

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!. Speckyboy Design Magazine Design News, Resources & Inspiration Weekly News for Designers № 584 By Speckyboy on Mar 19, 2021 07:43 pm Envato Elements The 20

Speckyboy RSS: Why Thinking Ahead Is Crucial in Web Design

Wednesday, March 17, 2021

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!. Speckyboy Design Magazine Design News, Resources & Inspiration Why Thinking Ahead Is Crucial in Web Design By Eric Karkovack on Mar 17, 2021 10:23 am The

Speckyboy RSS: Do We Really Need to Follow Design Trends?

Tuesday, March 16, 2021

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!. Speckyboy Design Magazine Design News, Resources & Inspiration Do We Really Need to Follow Design Trends? By Addison Duvall on Mar 16, 2021 06:40 am

Speckyboy RSS: 5 Common WordPress Myths Debunked

Monday, March 15, 2021

Your latest Speckyboy content is here!. Speckyboy Design Magazine Design News, Resources & Inspiration 5 Common WordPress Myths Debunked By Eric Karkovack on Mar 15, 2021 09:06 am Don't be

Inside Claude Monet's Home at Giverny

Wednesday, June 16, 2021

(image) Architectural Digest AD PRO Logo Image may contain: Garden, Outdoors, Arbour, and Porch Forget the Gardens: The Best Part of Giverny Is Monet's Kitchen Read More → (image) Condé Nast

Typography Trends, Tutorials UX, Safari 15, Brave Onboarding, Loaf

Wednesday, June 16, 2021

The 5 best design links, every day. Curated by a selection of great editors. Email not displaying properly? View browser version. Sidebar June 16 2021 Typography Trends in 2021: What Should You Know?

Issue 307

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Fixing up all the table things, equal columns with flexbox, avoiding layout shift when loading web fonts. CSS Layout News Issue 307 By Rachel Andrew – 15 Jun 2021 – View online → It's still sunny

✏ Samsung Redesigns the Save Icon, 22 Exciting New Tools, Typography Trends, and more…

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Samsung Gives the “obsolete” Floppy Disc Save Icon a Facelift for the 2020s ITSNICETHAT.COM COMMENTS 22 Exciting New Tools for Designers, June 2021 WEBDESIGNERDEPOT.COM COMMENTS Typography Trends in

96 / Not boring avatars for your apps, design resources, iOS 15 UI kit and epic fails

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Product Disrupt Logo Product Disrupt Half-Monthly Jun 2021 • Part 1 View in browser Image Boring Avatars Tiny JavaScript React library that generates custom, SVG-based, round avatars from any username

Smashing Newsletter #305: Color Palettes Generators and Tools

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

With CSS variables, HSLA, color generators, color combinations and color scales for data visualizations. Issue #305 • June 15, 2021 • View in the browser 💨 Smashing Newsletter Ciao Amici, Color may

👨‍⚕️ Curative Medical UI Kits + 🏆 Challenge Updates

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

Don't Miss This Week's UpLabs Designer Digest 👇 Firstly, we'd like to wish a warm congratulations to Yolan Puspa, the winner of our latest 🎙Clubhouse App Redesign Challenge! Secondly, we

✏ Is A Graphic Design Career For You? Create React Custom Hooks, Health Icons, and more...

Monday, June 14, 2021

Is a Graphic Design Career for You? (7 Questions to Ask Yourself) DRIBBBLE.COM COMMENTS When CSS Isn't Enough: JavaScript Requirements for Accessible Components SMASHINGMAGAZINE.COM COMMENTS Health

A Filmmaker's Kubrickian Loft

Monday, June 14, 2021

Design editor Wendy Goodman takes you inside the city's most exciting homes and design studios. Design Hunting A visual diary by Design Editor Wendy Goodman The living room (that's not really a

This New Tabletop Collection Has Us Falling Back in Love With Formality

Monday, June 14, 2021

Plus, 10 kitchen trends taking TikTok by storm (image) Architectural Digest AD PRO Logo The Expert Taps Former Domino EIC Jessica Romm Perez to Lead Partnerships Read More → CeCe Barfield's New