Silicon Valley Outsider - Should I have shut down my startup?
Should I have shut down my startup?Someone else is executing on my idea... so I might have been very wrong
I often wonder if I messed up by shutting down my startup. I had a pretty good thing going! I had won some pitch competitions that gave me seed money, I had signed up a paying customer, I had talked my way onto the stage of the biggest industry conference, and I had secured multiple offers to finance my business. The latter fact alone may have been enough for many entrepreneurs to stay in the fight, but here’s the kicker: two weeks ago, the GSMA, the world’s most important consortium in telecommunications, announced that they are following through with my idea. A blockchain protocol to “….automate and streamline inter-operator business processes starting with roaming and settlement” is exactly what I was pitching to telcos in 2017/2018. And now it’s happening. Did I seriously mess up deciding not to pursue what might ultimately have been a winning startup idea? Two weeks ago, I talked about the internal motivation that you need to succeed as an entrepreneur and one of my loyal subscribers reached out with a great counterpoint: “sometimes [grit] actually is about quitting.” She recommended that I check out some research related to the “escalation of commitment to a losing course of action,” and the most recent and approachable source I found came from Adam Grant (author of Originals, one of my favorite Silicon Valley books ever) in a new book called Think Again. He writes:
Grant’s book explains that, after long enough, you become your project. Before I shut it down, that startup was my identity! I was “the blockchain guy” to my business school classmates and to the telco industry. I had stood on stage in front of hundreds of people and answered the question “Will you be back next year?” in the affirmative. I had sold clients, investors, co-founders, and service providers on a bold idea of what the future could be. And I had made promises to so many people in order to will a new idea into existence. It is really, really hard not to blindly plow more of your money, time, and identity into a project like that. Admitting that I was wrong about the startup idea felt like admitting that my life was wrong in some way. But to not admit defeat may have been, in psychology words, “escalating commitment to a losing course of action.” In the end, I think that made the right decision for me.The following list is admittedly a little bit self-serving and -affirmational, but I think it’s important for anyone considering going into the startup business. It’s okay to stop pursuing a losing idea; the trouble is figuring out when you need to stick it out and when you need to quit. Here’s what hindsight taught me: 📈 Not all good ideas are venture-backable businesses.Just because my vision for the future came to pass does not mean that my company would have become a success — far from it! Most profitable businesses in the world could not be successful venture-backed startups. As I’ve written about before, the venture capital game is built around a very specific return profile: a company that has a low-to-moderate probability of generating a superlative return. My startup probably had a high probability of generating a reasonable return — and that’s a huge no-no for the venture capitalists I wanted to fund my business, which might have led to me having no follow-on funding and a company on life support. Looking back, even the bull case for my startup likely capped out at single- or double-digit millions of dollars of revenue each year; it just didn’t have enough room to grow, so it likely wasn’t venture-backable. 🌊 The timing wasn’t right.It is true that many startups will spend years in obscurity building the foundation for an “overnight success.” But there are far more startups who spend years in obscurity hoping for an overnight success that will never come to pass. In my particular case, I had tied my wagon to the blockchain caravan — and I probably don’t have to tell you about the rollercoaster ride that industry has been through over the past five years. In 2017/2018, blockchain technology wasn’t ready for prime time — it was still too slow, there were too many privacy concerns, and while the “crazy ones” in telcos knew who I was and why my idea worked, the real decisionmakers wouldn’t go anywhere near blockchain. I still believe that the architecture I presented — and that the GSMA is now championing — is the best one for this particular problem. But startups life and die by timing: catch a wave and you can ride to glory, but start too early or too late and you’ll fizzle out. 🤠 I wasn’t the right person for the job.This is the hardest pill to swallow, but it’s the real reason that I made the right decision by leaving my startup: it is possible that someone could have built a great business in that space, but it’s unlikely that I could have been that person. (If that sounds sad or defeatist, don’t worry. Those who know me can attest that I rarely lack in self-confidence; just being honest with myself here!) In order to succeed in a venture, you need to find founder-market fit.In enterprise markets like the one I was trying to enter, a great CEO will not only know the industry like the back of their hand, but will have deep relationships with the key executives and/or decisionmakers at the companies they want to work with. In contrast, I was building my network effectively from the ground up, and while I had some early successes, getting to decisionmakers proved basically impossible — the final straw that led me to shut my startup down. One of the biggest bummers of startup — and, I suppose, human — life is that you never get a chance to run counterfactuals. What would have happened if I had stuck with this startup? We’ll never know. I might have landed the GSMA contract, gone public, and made a billion dollars by age 30. But I also might have wasted four years of my life on a losing idea. All said, it’s hard to imagine grass that is much greener than what I’ve got at Astranis, and the only certainty is that if I hadn’t shut down my startup, I wouldn’t be where I am today. I’ll be just fine — and if you’re wondering whether it’s time for you to “reconsider your past commitments,” use my story as an example. Sometimes, it is better to quit. Better that, than escalate your commitment to a losing course of action. Thanks for reading Silicon Valley Outsider! Here are a few past editions that you might like if you enjoyed this one: If you want to join 450 folks in getting an email from me each Monday, I’ll help you understand Silicon Valley using normal-human words. If you liked this post from Silicon Valley Outsider, why not share it? |
Older messages
Startup resources, and how to work hard
Tuesday, July 6, 2021
Two retweets this week: Lea Boreland and Paul Graham
The most important skill in Startup Land: Drive
Monday, June 28, 2021
Operator Skill Tree: Edition #1
Are Midwestern values incompatible with startup success?
Saturday, June 26, 2021
For most people, but obviously not for all — let me explain.
Re-introducing Silicon Valley Outsider
Saturday, June 26, 2021
A newsletter for startup-interested folks who live outside the SF Bay Area
You Might Also Like
10words: Top picks from this week
Friday, April 19, 2024
Today's projects: Spheria • Narration Box • OnTheFly • AnyCheese • Dumbbe • HASTY • lockrScan • IdeaAize • Mailmo • ProSolvio • GigHunterBot • WeekToDo 10words Discover new apps and startups in 10
[Replay] Building a million dollar beauty brand
Friday, April 19, 2024
Free summit replay extended Hey - great news! We've extended the summit replay for 24 more hours. Watch it here free >> And, I want to highlight one of the inspiring founders, Alicia Scott.
Put it on paper
Friday, April 19, 2024
In case you missed it, here is the full recording of the 668 person workshop I co-hosted yesterday "how to build products of the future". It's completely free to watch here. Put it on
7 prompts for your B2B company’s next LinkedIn post
Friday, April 19, 2024
Plus, tips, news & Buffer updates for your social media journey Image Hey folks 👋🏾 It's been an interesting week in social, with the launch of TikTok Notes (their take on a photo + text
Challenges of Offering an API — The Bootstrapped Founder 313
Friday, April 19, 2024
When you sell access to an API, what should you keep in mind? How would you protect your data but still make it easy to use?
12 hours to go! 🐣
Friday, April 19, 2024
Catch the super early bird rates before they expire! View this email in your browser. 1200 x 380 (Desktop & Tablet) (8) Hey there, There are just 12 hours to go before Summit Summit ticket prices
Why I Switched My Blog to Ghost (and Why You Might Love It Too)
Friday, April 19, 2024
Tired of slow, clunky blogging platforms? I was too! Find out how Ghost changed my blogging life (and my company!), and why it might be the upgrade you need. Salehin Khan Salehin Khan Why I Switched My
Latvia's startup financing gets creative
Friday, April 19, 2024
We visit Riga to explore Latvia's tech scene, layoffs at Stability AI and why climate tech's latest phase will be built on debt. View in browser Notion flagship logo final Good morning there,
How Meta is paving the way for synthetic social networks
Friday, April 19, 2024
Five ways of thinking about Llama 3, its latest large language model Platformer Platformer How Meta is paving the way for synthetic social networks By Casey Newton • 18 Apr 2024 View in browser View in
SaaSHub Weekly - Apr 18
Thursday, April 18, 2024
SaaSHub Weekly - Apr 18 Featured and useful products Ant Design logo Ant Design An enterprise-class UI design language and React implementation with a set of high-quality React components, one of best