Marty's Ƀent - September 15th, 2021 - Issue #1077

Wednesday, September 15th 2021 - Issue #1077

More unsolicited thoughts on ESG

I know, I know, I know. Some of you may think Crazy Uncle Marty's anti-ESG schtick is getting a bit nauseating. However, as you should have realized by now, I cannot control myself. When I think there is a good point to be made about the subject, I will make it. And that is what I am here to do today.

The above snippet comes from a blog posted yesterday by Aswath Damodaran, a professor of finance at the NYU Stern School of Business, which builds on a post he published last September that began to dissect the ESG movement in the capital allocation space and beyond to determine whether or not it is a productive framing to conduct business and life. I highly recommend you take the time to read both pieces because Aswath does an incredible job of breaking down the thesis behind the investment strategy, how it gets implemented in the real world, its failure to accomplish its stated goals, why it can never accomplish its stated goals, and a better framework from which to approach "doing good".

To summarize the core argument that Aswath makes; ESG does not work because it ignores the existence of free will and reduces individuals and individual processes into uniform inputs in a rigid mathematical function that spits out an ESG rating. At its core, this type of grading/rating system cannot work because, again, it ignores the existence of free will and the subjectivity of "goodness" in the eyes of two different individuals. It is literally impossible to settle on a ratings system that people are able to agree on. And since that is the case, any ratings system that is brought to market will inherently carry the biases of those who construct it; governments looking to acquire more power over their subjects and corporations looking to leverage advantages provided by regulatory moats. 

Not only that, when these investment strategies are applied, they do not produce a return profile that is desirable. So this movement is crowding smaller players out by increasing the cost to comply and producing bad returns for investors. A lose-lose for most economic actors.

Now, if this is the case why are so many people pushing for it? Well, as Professor Damodaran so eloquently describes in his latest post on the subject; because most individuals don't want to take personal responsibility and extreme ownership over their impact on the world. Many are so lazy that they would rather have the government, capital allocators, and corporations make these decisions on their behalf and provide them with an "ESG-certified" label they can point at and say, "See, I'm doing my part!" Completely glossing over the fact that when these personal responsibilities are handed over to bureaucrats, bureaucrats are going to do what bureaucrats do - whether they're political or corporate bureaucrats - manipulate the system in their favor while making everyone else worse off. 

Politicians will attempt to gain more control and some corporations will attempt to leverage it to create an artificial moat around their businesses to artificially reduce competition. Which leads to another interesting line of discussion under the overarching ESG topic; is it a form of Fascism? I think you could make a very good case that yes, yes it is. And nothing made this clearer to me than a clip that was floating around Twitter earlier this week of Dave Smith educating a fellow panelist about how Mussolini defined Fascism.   
Dave Smith defining Fascism.
"He defined it as a merger between Corporation and state."

While Dave may have been articulating this to make a point about how vaccine mandates can be considered Fascist, I think we can also apply this to what is happening throughout the ESG movement. Via the direction of the UN (a group of coordinated countries - the state) and the "climate change goals" they have arbitrarily set for the global population, corporations and capital allocators are beginning to direct the means of production and pick winners and losers via an ESG ratings system built around those arbitrary and subjective world views. Favoring some forms of energy and boardroom structures over others while failing to be open about the tradeoffs that are being disregarded. A good example of this is wind and solar being favored as energy sources for being "green" when they leverage an immense amount of hydrocarbons and slave labor on the front and back end of their lifecycles.

By creating arbitrary and rigid guidelines which entrepreneurs must operate within, the state and the corporations who are best positioned to benefit from these arbitrary guidelines dictate the means of production in a subversive fashion. There is no overt physical seizing of the means of production. Instead, the means of production is slowly but surely nudged in a certain direction until the desired amount of control is in the hands of the state and its corporate cronies.

As a bitcoin miner, this issue has become very clear to me. In a sane world bitcoin mining would be viewed as a massive boon for conservationism. For the first time in human history we have a mechanism by which we can profitably monetize previously wasted and stranded energy assets. The natural incentives of the network force miners to drive their electricity costs down as low as possible and the best way to do that is to seek out wasted and stranded energy sources that no one else is willing to utilize. Bitcoin miners will show up in the middle of nowhere to utilize energy that was LITERALLY BEING SET ON FIRE without producing any positive economic value. Definitionally making the world more energy efficient.

Not only this, but the miners utilizing that previously wasted energy are doing so to profitably facilitate and secure the best monetary system humanity has ever come into contact with. A monetary system which will end the mis-pricing of opportunity costs that is induced by the ability to print money out of thin air. As Steve Barbour said
during a conversation on the topic we were a part of earlier this afternoon, it punishes the misallocation of capital, which leads to less unnecessary consumption. When governments and central banks print money out of thin air to save companies that have misallocated capital and resources to an extent that they are in danger of going out of business, they perpetuate that misallocation of capital and resources, which one can argue is a net negative on the environment and society overall.

I'm sorry for rambling, freaks. I just had to get these thoughts off of my chest after reading Aswath's blog last night and partaking in a conversation on the subject this afternoon. I will leave you with the actionable advice from Aswath's blog post, which I think is a much better framework for individuals, business, and investment professionals to approach the concept of "doing good in the world". It should be based on your personal values and not a top-down diktat defined by a very narrow set of values.      
Final thought...

The beard is getting grizzly. 
Share
Tweet
Forward
Hope you enjoyed today's issue. If you have any friends that are looking to find out more about Bitcoin have them sign up for this newsletter here:
 
Get Ƀent

Ƀent noun 1. direction taken, as by one's interests; inclination.

Thanks for reading Marty's Ƀent, a daily newsletter containing all the information I found interesting in the Bitcoin world in the last 24 hours.

Copyright © 2020  TFTC.io, LLC  All rights reserved. 

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or Ƀent Over!
 

Older messages

Marty's Ƀent - September 14th, 2021 - Issue #1076

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

Tuesday, September 14th 2021 - Issue #1076 Yet another reminder that many bitcoin critics are subpar The above snippet comes from the Opinions section of the New York Times, and it is a stark reminder

Marty's Ƀent - September 13th, 2021 - Issue #1075

Monday, September 13, 2021

Monday, September 13th 2021 - Issue #1075 Consumer are expecting more inflation The New York Federal Reserve released the results of their August 2021 Survey of Consumer Expectations and it appears

The Sat Standard - Bitcoin Weekly - Sep 11 2021

Saturday, September 11, 2021

This week in bitcoin. Straight to the point. No bullshit. Every Saturday. View this email in your browser The Sat Standard This week in bitcoin. Straight to the point. No bullshit. Every Saturday.

Marty's Ƀent - September 10th, 2021 - Issue #1074

Friday, September 10, 2021

Friday, September 10th 2021 - Issue #1074 More (safe) NFC UX please Here's something cool that Rodolfo Novak from Coinkite teased earlier today; a prototype for a new ColdCard model that would

Marty's Ƀent - September 9th, 2021 - Issue #1073

Friday, September 10, 2021

Thursday, September 9th 2021 - Issue #1073 Mining scuttlebutt from the Bitmain conference Bitmain is throwing a conference down in Miami at the moment. Your Uncle Marty is bummed he couldn't make

Protocols don’t capture value, DAOs manage risk

Thursday, September 16, 2021

This essay is a spiritual successor to On Value Capture at Layers 1 and 2. It also builds on some ideas from On Forking DeFi Protocols. WRITING Protocols don't capture value, DAOs manage risk By

Ethereum Rivals, SEC vs. Coinbase Part II, & This Week's Pump and Dump

Thursday, September 16, 2021

Issue #186 September 15, 2021 | Issue #186 Editor's Note: Another Teeka webinar goes live tonight at 8PM EST. For the first time ever, he's giving listeners the name of his #1 “Catch Up Coin”

Marty's Ƀent - September 15th, 2021 - Issue #1077

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

Wednesday, September 15th 2021 - Issue #1077 More unsolicited thoughts on ESG I know, I know, I know. Some of you may think Crazy Uncle Marty's anti-ESG schtick is getting a bit nauseating. However

👉 Bitcoin Drops 20% On First Day As Legal Tender in El Salvador... Manipulation?

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

We bring you the top stories in crypto every week! Stories like... Monday, September 13th, 2021 Sign Up Your Weekly Update On All Things Crypto In Partnership With: TL;DR Bitcoin Day: El Salvador

Marty's Ƀent - September 14th, 2021 - Issue #1076

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

Tuesday, September 14th 2021 - Issue #1076 Yet another reminder that many bitcoin critics are subpar The above snippet comes from the Opinions section of the New York Times, and it is a stark reminder

Marty's Ƀent - September 13th, 2021 - Issue #1075

Monday, September 13, 2021

Monday, September 13th 2021 - Issue #1075 Consumer are expecting more inflation The New York Federal Reserve released the results of their August 2021 Survey of Consumer Expectations and it appears

👉 SEC Threatens Coinbase With Lawsuit Over Lending Feature

Monday, September 13, 2021

We bring you the top stories in crypto every week! Stories like... Monday, September 13th, 2021 Sign Up Your Weekly Update On All Things Crypto In Partnership With: TL;DR Bitcoin Day: El Salvador

The Sat Standard - Bitcoin Weekly - Sep 11 2021

Saturday, September 11, 2021

This week in bitcoin. Straight to the point. No bullshit. Every Saturday. View this email in your browser The Sat Standard This week in bitcoin. Straight to the point. No bullshit. Every Saturday.

Marty's Ƀent - September 10th, 2021 - Issue #1074

Friday, September 10, 2021

Friday, September 10th 2021 - Issue #1074 More (safe) NFC UX please Here's something cool that Rodolfo Novak from Coinkite teased earlier today; a prototype for a new ColdCard model that would

Bounty Brief #22

Friday, September 10, 2021

Get ready for a curveball ⚾ ↪️ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌