Story Cauldron - What is history?
Thanks for reading Story Cauldron, where I investigate stories and storytelling. If you enjoy what you’re reading, please consider sharing this newsletter with a friend. As a trained historian who’s been dabbling in history writing here and on my new Substack Unseen St. Louis, I’ve been pondering for a while how history and storytelling go hand in hand. In this week’s edition of Story Cauldron, let’s consider the question: what is history? As to the above image—there aren’t really any depictions of female historians in the Getty image library, so I settled for a 14th-century fresco by the Florentine artist Andrea di Cione di Arcangelo, better known as Orcagna. I’m imagining the woman who’s casually holding a parrot is recounting a scandalous story from the past. What is history?People think of history as someone putting together a string of past events, indisputable moments in time, into a pleasant narrative. Coming out of a 19th-century desire to understand and classify everything, history was understood as a scientific accounting of “what happened.” Historical accounts needed to be based on factual, indisputable data, and needed to be ‘objective.’ There could only be a single impartial and true historical narrative, and any deviation from that narrative could only be possible with new information that could better explain what we already knew to be true. But that’s not what history is, and it’s not really what it has ever been. Here’s part of what the Online Etymology Dictionary has to say:
As this definition of history suggests, the concept of ‘history’ is not a scientific thing at all, but instead is a story of the past. And what story hasn’t been colored and shaded by the storyteller? What this means is that, whenever you engage with history, you should ask, ‘why does this exist?’ Whether it’s a documentary, a history book, a website article, or a museum exhibit, it’s important to know who made it and why. Why I like historyLike many people, I grew up with the notion that “history is written by the victors,” a quote inaccurately attributed to Winston Churchill. The idea is that it is those who win the wars, conquer the territory, and win elections that get to decide which stories get told. Most people can name at least a handful of presidents of the US—but how many can name their opponents? In school, the history textbooks told the story of the growth of Europe, westward expansion, colonialism, and the wars that countries fought along the way, often against indigenous people. But I always found that boring. To me, history is not about memorizing a list of kings and wars, but understanding how people lived their daily lives and how societies have changed over time. As a graduate student twice, I gravitated instead to cultural history. I wanted to know what people thought, what they believed, and what they told each other. Along the way, what I discovered was that history ultimately is about patterns: human beings have this insane way of doing the same things over and over again, largely because they don’t remember how things worked out in the past. The role of story in historyI’m a storyteller fascinated in history. Every historical event is, at its heart, a story to be told. There will always be the ‘official’ story, the one told by leaders with power and influence, as reported in the media. But those storytellers rarely tell the story of the ordinary people, and never fairly report stories of people opposing that power. When I engage with historical materials, I like to tease out a different version of that story. It might have some of the same historical markers—dates, important people, major events. But there are other stories that can be told by focusing whenever possible on ordinary people and how they lived. When historians look back on the past couple of years, do you think they will get a fair idea of what it was like to live through the pandemic if they only look at what the presidents and governors and major organizations had to say about events? Or will they need to look at the stories coming out of hospitals and nursing homes, and how we all lived for years in fear of public spaces and at each other’s throats over masking and immunizations? My current historical workAs I’ve mentioned, I’ve started a second Substack called Unseen St. Louis in which I focus on lesser-known moments in St. Louis history. As I dig into the history—most of which was never taught to me in school—I see how modern St. Louis is the product of its former position as a leading industrial city. Thousands and thousands of people moved here in the 19th and early 20th century looking for jobs, creating unique challenges for the St. Louis area that it continues to struggle with to this day. To this end, recently I wrote about the Kerry Patch, a very large settlement of Irish people fleeing the Great Hunger. I also examined a notorious housing project in St. Louis that was long cast as so dangerous place that the city had to shut it down—only to find out that it actually failed because the city (and the federal government) never allocated sufficient funds and resources into its upkeep and security. I also dug into a boundary between cities in St. Louis county that was constructed to keep a Black community separate from a white one. So circling back—what’s my ‘why’ in this equation? Why do I choose to tell these stories? I guess it’s important to me that people have some sense of history. Like I said before, it’s helpful to know what happened in the past so we don’t keep repeating the same mistakes. And where St. Louis is concerned, I believe that if we don’t examine what happened in the past, we’ll never be able to move forward. Recent historyIf you’d like to check out my recent history articles, I’ve linked them below: Final notePart of the reason I created Story Cauldron in the first place was to highlight my fiction. While I don’t have a new story to share, I did want to note that I was interviewed for the Serial Fiction Show! In a two-part podcast (one for readers, and a second for writers), I talk about my Favor Faeries series, available here and on Kindle Vella and what it’s like to be a writer, why I write about faeries, and more. Be sure to check it out! And as always, thanks for reading Story Cauldron. If you haven’t yet, please subscribe. You’re on the free list for Story Cauldron. For the full experience and to be the first in the world to read my next novel, consider becoming a paying subscriber. |
Older messages
Winning a war through storytelling?
Thursday, March 10, 2022
The role of stories and propaganda in the Russian invasion of Ukraine
That was then, this is now
Friday, February 25, 2022
Reflections on where I grew up—and what's there today
Winter in St. Louis
Thursday, February 10, 2022
An update on our snowfall—and photos from around town
Let it snow, let it snow, let it snow
Wednesday, February 2, 2022
My lifelong passion for snowy winter days
Untangling a knotty mess
Tuesday, January 25, 2022
The future of one newsletter and the creation of another
You Might Also Like
Best CMS for SEO: 10 Platforms Compared
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Discover the top 10 CMS of 2024 reviewed and tested for flawless SEO experience Hi Reader, Want to run your site on a CMS like WordPress or Shopify? I've got some hints to help you make a choice.
Celebrate World Book Day 🎉 Free • KU • Paperback Book Deals • Fiction & Non-fiction
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Today is World Book Day, traditionally a great time to find new books. Fiction and Non-fiction
The Invisible Wall Around Most of Manhattan
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
It's an "eruv"
🧙♂️ New mic I travel with
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
gunna take over the world now
Death of Followers Leads to Good Business
Tuesday, April 23, 2024
Who cares about followers? Entrepreneurs don't need to.
🍀 time to forage for inspiration?
Monday, April 22, 2024
How + why to find inspiration when it's been lacking. View in browser The first single from my new album, Patas de Problemas (Troublepaws) is out now! 😻 🎧 Check it out! Hi Reader, When inspiration
Under $10M to $80M per year
Monday, April 22, 2024
AppSumo's story How did Dropbox get to 100million users? How Dollar Shave Club went from $4million to $250million ARR in 4 years? How did Medium turn around Brand their brand reputation? How
When Show Business Met Monkey Business
Monday, April 22, 2024
Or, when morning TV went bananas
🧙♂️ "You're a sellout"
Monday, April 22, 2024
Don't let your audience turn on you
Optimistic ought to be a verb
Monday, April 22, 2024
Good morning ladies & gents, It's gonna be a good week. Optimism: now, always, and forever. Trevor I just bet $100 the CFPB will be ruled unconstitutional (website) Kalshi is my site of choice