Trapital - breaking through the noise
breaking through the noise Hey! Did you see the video of Rick Ross giving someone a haircut at back-to-school event? I can’t stop laughing about this. Why is he cutting so fast? Why is he holding the kid’s head like that? Ross cuts hair like he’s chops down trees in his backyard. The man has many talents—hit-making, promoting, landscaping, investing, philanthropy. But haircutting ain’t it. I hope that boy got a gift card to WingStop as an apology. Today’s memo is about new music’s struggle to keep up with older music. This topic isn’t new, but this is a breakdown on what it means for artists both old and new. Hope you enjoy the breakdown.
Was this forwarded to you? want your company featured in Trapital? We are looking for a few more sponsors in Q3 who want to reach the artists, creators, and execs who read and listen to Trapital on a regular basis. Want your company to reach Trapital's audience? Reach out to us here.
how older music’s growth will impact newer artists Every few months, there’s a new thinkpiece, report, or article about the growth of older music and the decline in newer music. Catalog songs—anything older than 18 months—now account for 72.4% of U.S. on-demand audio consumption according to a new report for Luminate. It’s a number that grows a few percentage points each year. The record labels and publishers own both catalog music and new releases, so they bring in the revenue regardless. But still, no one entered this business to be a glorified estate manager. Labels can’t rest on the laurels of their back catalogs forever. The business is still designed to promote the next big thing. Ironically, the back catalog growth shifts the music industry to the business model of a big tech company. It has a core business that brings in all the revenue and subsidizes any new moonshot ideas. That model works fine for Google X. Everybody involved understands the long-odds stakes. But what about the newly-signed artist who just blew up on TikTok? Everyone, even the execs at the label, truly believes that she can become the next Billie Eilish. The odds were already slim, but now they’re even slimmer than imagined. How will this shift expectations for both artists and the companies they partner with? music relying on its own IPDespite the wave of music catalog sales by artists from the 70s and 80s, the majority of back catalog listening is from the 21st century. In 2021, 79% of all U.S. streams are still from the past twelve years. There’s been a lot of talk about the impact of older hits making a comeback, like Kate Bush’s “Running Up That Hill.” But the more accurate narrative of catalog success is that “people haven’t stopped listening to Drake’s Views or Taylor Swift’s 1989.” Drake, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, and Adele are the last generation of artists who rose up before the streaming era took off. They have an outsized impact when releasing new music, but even their latest releases can’t compete with their own success circa 2015. It was a different time. This is why Swift’s re-recorded albums and Drake’s Care Package compilation of loose singles work well. It’s music that fans are already familiar with. They operate like sequels to popular movies. It’s also why artists popular artists rely heavily on samples, interpolations, and collaborations. Their name alone can’t guarantee high sales. Oftentimes, all the pieces need to come together just to have a chance to break through the noise. the desire to pattern matchThe streaming era’s shifts to moods over genres have also made it harder for new music to breathe. Here’s an excerpt from Evening Standard on the golden age of back catalog: “Second up is mood and genre based playlisting, which works on roughly the same dynamic [the age of the song is irrelevant]. If you ask Alexa to play Sunday morning music, she’s not going to worry about being cutting edge, or directing streaming revenue to struggling new artists.” Pattern matching was less important last decade. Think about breakout moments like the 2011 viral music videos for Azealia Banks’ “212” or Tyler, The Creator’s “Yonkers.” They weren’t following any formulas. Their creativity blossomed because digital music and media were less saturated back then. Greatness had a better chance to have its moment. I’m sure there are emerging artists who have released equivalent greatness in the 2020s, but they are fighting upstream to compete with TikTok, Twitter, Instagram, my podcasts, and all the video streaming apps available through Roku. It’s a tougher game. leveling expectationsWhen artists get offers to join record labels, they are still pitched on the success of the artists who rose to power in a different time. Sure, it’s great that said label is home to Future, Young Thug, or Cardi B. But TikTok wasn’t a thing when they blew up. Spotify had a fraction of the subscribers it has today. Artists need more recent examples. How many case studies can they share of post-TikTok artists who have a similar path? How has the likelihood of success changed over time? The people working at labels should be thinking similarly. Even if they execute a brilliant, expansive promotional campaign for artists, they shouldn’t compare results to legacy benchmarks. The music industry has always been feast or famine. But that feast is getting a little harder to come by each year.
money moves
enjoy Trapital? share it with a friend Tell them to sign up. I'll send them next Monday's memo. Hit the link below to share:
Or share Trapital quick via text, email, or Twitter. coming soon from Trapital Podcast: The business of buying and selling beats with BeatStars CEO Abe Batshon. Out on Friday! |
Key phrases
Older messages
longevity over everything
Friday, August 12, 2022
Trapital Memo: the strategy behind Post Malone's success
the tiktok takeover
Wednesday, August 10, 2022
Trapital Memo: an analysis on TikTok attempt to eat everyone else's lunch. Will it work?
superstar talent
Friday, August 5, 2022
Trapital Memo: our new Friday newsletter! Interview with music industry vet Benny Pough
renaissance
Tuesday, August 2, 2022
Trapital Memo: I was on NPR to talk about Beyonce, artists building sustainable businesses, and the end of “genres.”
keep that same energy
Tuesday, July 26, 2022
Trapital Memo: a breakdown on Desus and Mero, my interview with Talib Kweli, and Trapital's new partnership with MoonPay
You Might Also Like
Netflix EMEA Boss Criticizes Local Quotas For "Stifling Creativity" and Says Competitors Are "Dialing Back" - Series Mania
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 Netflix EMEA Boss Criticizes Local Quotas For "Stifling Creativity" & Says Competitors Are "Dialing Back" - Series Mania By Max
'Doctor Who' Producer Jane Tranter Says British TV Tax Credits Must Be Updated Amid Over-Reliance On Hollywood Investment
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 'Doctor Who' Producer Jane Tranter Says British TV Tax Credits Must Be Updated Amid Over-Reliance On Hollywood Investment By Jake Kanter This
Alex Wolff and Oystein Karlsen On Capturing The Spirit Of Leonard Cohen In 'So Long, Marianne' — Series Mania
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 Alex Wolff & Oystein Karlsen On Capturing The Spirit Of Leonard Cohen In 'So Long, Marianne' - Series Mania By Jesse Whittock This email was
Idris Elba To Direct Nigeria-Set Film 'Dust To Dreams' For Mo Abudu's EbonyLife and Afreximbank; Seal, Nse Ikpe-Etim and Constance Olatunde Among Cast
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 Idris Elba To Direct Nigeria-Set Film 'Dust To Dreams' For Mo Abudu's EbonyLife & Afreximbank; Seal, Nse Ikpe-Etim & Constance
On-Screen Sex And Violence To Receive Higher Age Ratings From BBFC
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 On-Screen Sex And Violence To Receive Higher Age Ratings From BBFC By Zac Ntim This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by Deadline. Please add
'All and Eva': Creatives Behind Sperm Donor Series Detail How 'Fleabag'-Inspired Dramedy Is Leading A New Wave Of Auteur-Driven Scandi Fare - Series Mania
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 19, 2024 'All & Eva': Creatives Behind Sperm Donor Series Detail How 'Fleabag'-Inspired Dramedy Is Leading A New Wave Of Auteur-Driven Scandi
Flow State Episode 219
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
Listen now (100 mins) | Good morning. Today's mix opens with a synth/field recording piece by Aiko Takahashi. We then play some ambient music by Sonja Tofik & Mar-Ilena, kita kouhei, and Lara
'In Restless Dreams': the Definitive Paul Simon Documentary
Monday, March 18, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 18, 2024 'In Restless Dreams' May Be the Definitive Paul Simon Documentary What started as a making-of chronicle of 2023's 'Seven Psalms'
Election Deniers Are Taking Over Election Boards
Monday, March 18, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 18, 2024 Potential 2024 'Chaos': Election Deniers Refusing to Certify Results Election officials in eight states have delayed or refused to certify
Simon Cowell's Agent YMU Confirms $76M Sale To Permira and Hunts Acquisitions
Monday, March 18, 2024
View on web New reader? Subscribe March 18, 2024 Simon Cowell's Agent YMU Confirms $76M Sale To Permira & Hunts Acquisitions By Jake Kanter This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by