Yes, Elon Musk created a special system for showing you all his tweets first
Here’s this week’s free Platformer — another deeply reported piece inside Elon Musk’s Twitter, featuring the first in-depth explanation of the system that allowed him to take over the timeline this week. We’re a two-person team competing with some of the biggest publications in the world. If this work is meaningful to you, why not kick in $10 to help us do more of it — or just to express your support? Over the past month, subscribers got detailed, on-the-ground reports from Microsoft and TikTok headquarters. Subscribe now to read them. Plus we’ll send you the link to join us in our chatty Discord server, where we now post all of our breaking news — including this story — first.
Yes, Elon Musk created a special system for showing you all his tweets firstAfter his Super Bowl tweet did worse numbers than President Biden’s, Twitter’s CEO ordered major changes to the algorithmThis story is based on interviews with people familiar with the events involved and supported by documents obtained by Platformer. At 2:36 on Monday morning, James Musk sent an urgent message to Twitter engineers. “We are debugging an issue with engagement across the platform,” wrote Musk, a cousin of the Twitter CEO, tagging “@here” in Slack to ensure that anyone online would see it. “Any people who can make dashboards and write software please can you help solve this problem. This is high urgency. If you are willing to help out please thumbs up this post.” When bleary-eyed engineers began to log on to their laptops, the nature of the emergency became clear: Elon Musk’s tweet about the Super Bowl got less engagement than President Joe Biden’s. Biden’s tweet, in which he said he would be supporting his wife in rooting for the Philadelphia Eagles, generated nearly 29 million impressions. Musk, who also tweeted his support for the Eagles, generated a little more than 9.1 million impressions before deleting the tweet in apparent frustration. In the wake of those losses — the Eagles to the Kansas City Chiefs, and Musk to the president of the United States — Twitter’s CEO flew his private jet back to the Bay Area on Sunday night to demand answers from his team. Within a day, the consequences of that meeting would reverberate around the world, as Twitter users opened the app to find that Musk’s posts overwhelmed their ranked timeline. This was no accident, Platformer can confirm: after Musk threatened to fire his remaining engineers, they built a system designed to ensure that Musk — and Musk alone — benefits from previously unheard-of promotion of his tweets to the entire user base. In recent weeks, Musk has been obsessed with the amount of engagement his posts are receiving. Last week, Platformer broke the news that he fired one of two remaining principal engineers at the company after the engineer told him that views on his tweets are declining in part because interest in Musk has declined in general. His deputies told the rest of the engineering team this weekend that if the engagement issue wasn’t “fixed,” they would all lose their jobs as well. Late Sunday night, Musk addressed his team in-person. Roughly 80 people were pulled in to work on the project, which had quickly become priority number one at the company. Employees worked through the night investigating various hypotheses about why Musk’s tweets weren’t reaching as many people as he thought they should and testing out possible solutions. One possibility, engineers said, was that Musk’s reach might have been reduced because he’d been blocked and muted by so many people in recent months. Even before the events of this weekend, Musk’s long stint as Twitter’s main character, both in the run-up to and aftermath of his $44 billion takeover of the company, had led huge numbers of people to filter him out of their feeds. But there were also legitimate technical reasons the CEO’s tweets weren’t performing. Twitter’s system has historically promoted tweets from users whose posts perform better to both followers and non-followers in the For You Tab; Musk’s tweets should have fit that model but showed up less only about half the time that some engineers thought they should, according to some internal estimates. By Monday afternoon, “the problem” had been “fixed.” Twitter deployed code to automatically “greenlight” all of Musk’s tweets, meaning his tweets will bypass Twitter’s filters designed to show people the best content possible. The algorithm now artificially boosted Musk’s tweets by a factor of 1,000 – a constant score that ensured his tweets rank higher than anyone else’s in the feed. Internally, this is called a “power user multiplier,” although it only applies to Elon Musk, we’re told. The code also allows Musk’s account to bypass Twitter heuristics that would otherwise prevent a single account from flooding the core ranked feed, now known as “For You.” That explains why people opening the app Monday found that Musk dominated the feed, with a dozen or more Musk tweets and replies visible to anyone who followed him and millions more who did not. Over 90 percent of Musk’s followers now see his tweets, according to one internal estimate. Musk acknowledged his bombardment of the timeline on Tuesday afternoon, posting a version of the popular “forced to drink milk” meme in which one woman labeled “Elon’s tweets” forcibly bottle-feeds another woman labeled “Twitter” while pulling her hair back. Some of his tweets Monday were sent while he was on calls with Twitter engineers, to test out whether the solutions they’d designed were working as well as he thought they should. After Musk’s timeline takeover caused an uproar Monday, he seemed to suggest that the changes would be walked back, at least in part. “Please stay tuned while we make adjustments to the uh .… “algorithm,” he tweeted. The artificial boosts applied to his account remain in place, although the factor is now lower than 1,000, we’re told. Musk’s handful of tweets Tuesday reported around 43 million impressions, which are on the high end of his recent average. Absurd as Musk’s antics are, they do highlight a tension familiar to almost anyone who has ever used a social network: why are some posts more popular than others? Why am I seeing this thing, and not that one? Engineers for services like TikTok and Instagram can offer partial, high-level answers to these questions. But ranking algorithms make predictions based on hundreds or thousands of signals, and deliver posts to millions of users, making it almost impossible for anyone to say with any degree of accuracy who sees what. For better and for worse, that answer hasn’t been good enough for Musk. As Twitter’s most prominent user, with nearly 129 million followers, his posts often get 10 million or more impressions, as counted by Twitter. (There are good reasons to doubt the accuracy of these counts, but better data is not readily available.) But Musk’s view counts still fluctuate widely. The bottle-feeding tweet got a reported 118.4 million impressions; his next one, a joke observation previously posted to Reddit and satirically attributed to Abraham Lincoln, got 49.9 million. Some of his tweets from earlier this month had fewer than 8 million. The most obvious reason for this discrepancy is that people think some tweets are better than others. But it doesn’t have to work like that: you could also change the ranking algorithms so that they show your posts no matter what. Terrified of losing their jobs, this is the system that Twitter engineers are now building. “He bought the company, made a point of showcasing what he believed was broken and manipulated under previous management, then turns around and manipulates the platform to force engagement on all users to hear only his voice,” said a current employee. “I think we’re past the point of believing that he actually wants what’s best for everyone here.” Governing
Industry
Those good tweetsFor more good tweets every day, follow Casey’s Instagram stories. saw a couple walking into trader joe’s and the girl said “wow look at all the pretty flowers” and the guy replied “oh yeah it must be flower season” please pray for him Talk to usSend us tips, comments, questions, and your preferred power user multiplier: casey@platformer.news and zoe@platformer.news. By design, the vast majority of Platformer readers never pay anything for the journalism it provides. But you made it all the way to the end of this week’s edition — maybe not for the first time. Want to support more journalism like what you read today? If so, click here: |
Key phrases
Older messages
Elon Musk fires a top Twitter engineer over his declining view count
Thursday, February 9, 2023
Inside Twitter 2.0, turmoil leaves employees stretched to the max
Microsoft kickstarts the AI arms race
Wednesday, February 8, 2023
The relaunched Bing does research, writes emails, and just might hit Google where it hurts
A visit to TikTok's transparency center
Friday, February 3, 2023
Few companies have ever made their code so available for inspection. How much will it matter?
Instagram's co-founders are mounting a comeback
Tuesday, January 31, 2023
EXCLUSIVE: Meet Artifact, a kind of TikTok for text
Google's most serious antitrust challenge to date
Wednesday, January 25, 2023
The US government is coming after the company's ad business — and it might win
You Might Also Like
12 hours to go! 🐣
Friday, April 19, 2024
Catch the super early bird rates before they expire! View this email in your browser. 1200 x 380 (Desktop & Tablet) (8) Hey there, There are just 12 hours to go before Summit Summit ticket prices
Why I Switched My Blog to Ghost (and Why You Might Love It Too)
Friday, April 19, 2024
Tired of slow, clunky blogging platforms? I was too! Find out how Ghost changed my blogging life (and my company!), and why it might be the upgrade you need. Salehin Khan Salehin Khan Why I Switched My
Latvia's startup financing gets creative
Friday, April 19, 2024
We visit Riga to explore Latvia's tech scene, layoffs at Stability AI and why climate tech's latest phase will be built on debt. View in browser Notion flagship logo final Good morning there,
How Meta is paving the way for synthetic social networks
Friday, April 19, 2024
Five ways of thinking about Llama 3, its latest large language model Platformer Platformer How Meta is paving the way for synthetic social networks By Casey Newton • 18 Apr 2024 View in browser View in
SaaSHub Weekly - Apr 18
Thursday, April 18, 2024
SaaSHub Weekly - Apr 18 Featured and useful products Ant Design logo Ant Design An enterprise-class UI design language and React implementation with a set of high-quality React components, one of best
[SaaS Club] Scaling a SaaS Community Platform to $19M ARR
Thursday, April 18, 2024
Hey Reader Let's connect on LinkedIn! Follow me to stay in touch! Here's a quick round up of what's been going on at SaaS Club: 🎧 Podcast Circle: Scaling a Community Platform to $19 Million
The Most Profitable Software Company in Q1 2024
Thursday, April 18, 2024
Tomasz Tunguz Venture Capitalist If you were forwarded this newsletter, and you'd like to receive it in the future, subscribe here. The Most Profitable Software Company in Q1 2024 image Ethereum
Clippa and PrivacyBox
Thursday, April 18, 2024
A browser extension for PrivacySandbox control with passive income BetaList BetaList Daily Clippa Create short clip videos for social media in a few clicks PrivacyBox A browser extension for
I think I figured it out
Thursday, April 18, 2024
Read this in 1 min, 2 sec I was scrolling through our YouTube channel last night... And something finally clicked. Why are all these founders we interviewed successful? What do they know that others
stealth startups in industrials
Thursday, April 18, 2024
intel on hidden gems within the market inside Hi there, Never miss an outlier. Check out this list of target companies in industrials. These startups are hidden gems within the space. See them here The