#110 – On discipling children and towards a better childhood
Imagine a man who demands that his wife sleep at a fixed time every night, forbids her to indulge in certain foods she loves, and confines her to an institution for seven hours a day, where she is subjected to more discipline and has ideas instilled in her that are deemed “good for her”. If this oppression were not enough, the man does not let his wife do anything without his permission, and society expects the wife to be grateful to her husband for all that he does for her. If, after all this, the wife gets angry or starts crying or shouting, refusing to obey another command by her husband, the husband dismisses her, saying that she is throwing “just another tantrum”. While the situation described above would be condemned in today’s society if applied to an adult relationship, a simple substitution of characters reveals a depressing truth. If one replaces the wife in the plot with a child, and the man with parental authority, then it becomes evident that I have just described a typical period in life for most people today, known as childhood. The act of “disciplining a child” is another way to describe the act of coercing a child. Such coercion is generally contrived not for the child’s benefit but for the convenience of the authority engaging in it, as it serves to instill obedience. Although this “disciplining” may sometimes be performed with the intention of benefiting the child, it rarely achieves this aim. The underlying assumption behind carrying out such coercion against children is that the self-discipline exhibited by an Olympic-level athlete, a world-class ballet dancer, a genius mathematician, or even a regular, civil person, stems from an authority figure instilling such discipline from a young age. However, this assumption is misguided. A person is naturally interested in things. As John Holt eloquently expressed, “Children do not need to be made to learn about the world, or shown how. They want to, and they know how.” The discipline demonstrated by the person who is the best in the world at their craft is entirely different from what is implied by “instilling discipline in the child”, an equivocation of the word “discipline”. The latter refers to coercive control, which begets obedience and usually results in the death of the child’s passion, as he is unwillingly forced to do something he does not like rather than pursue what he actually wants. But the Olympic athlete or genius mathematician who spends hours perfecting his craft, testing and stretching to the limits of physical and intellectual capacity, does so because he wants to. A task may be incredibly challenging, but precisely that a challenge exists may make it valuable and exciting to you. What one needs to learn something is curiosity about the subject and the freedom to make mistakes. Those preconditions are in stark contrast, of course, to the ways of our current educational institutions. In school, mistakes are abhorred, and children must learn certain things despite their genuine inclination toward the topic. Knowledge is not poured into minds as water is into a vessel. Instead, one creates it within their own mind by guessing ideas and correcting errors within them. Even if some knowledge has already been “established” by others and instantiated in books or other physical substrates, a person must still recreate that knowledge within their own mind. This learning process occurs by making conjectures—about the explanations found in sources such as books, or those found in a university lecturer’s words, for example—and correcting prior theories that conflict with the newly acquired understanding. Thus, learning is not a passive, top-down process but an active one. Indeed, it is an individual act of knowledge creation. Failure to grasp this fundamental epistemological theory regarding how knowledge is created can have vast practical implications, like how one treats children, and thus affect our future. Childhood does not have to entail coercion. The fact that it does merely represents cultural ignorance, a problem that can be addressed through knowledge, just as it was in the case of African slaves in the 19th century or the granting of equal rights to women. Indeed, I can imagine a world where our descendants will look back at how we treat children today in the same way we now look at the treatment of women in the past—as a different kind of person, subjected to paternalistic control over their decisions—with horror. Much of the content expressed here is inspired by an educational philosophy known as Taking Children Seriously cofounded by Sarah Fitz-Claridge and David Deutsch. Errors are my own! Follow me on Twitter @arjunkhemani. |
Older messages
#109 – The scale of creativity
Monday, August 14, 2023
Through understanding, we liberate ourselves.
#109 – The Constraints of Money
Sunday, August 6, 2023
We typically think of constraints as limiting factors to something we want to achieve. This conception is too narrow. Progress often comes from discovering constraints, and from further refining them.
#108 – The Meaning of It All by Richard Feynman; a summary
Sunday, July 30, 2023
Richard P. Feynman was one of the 20th century's most brilliant theoretical physicists and original thinkers. He all but rebuilt the theory of quantum electrodynamics. It was for this work that he
#107 – Alien Knowledge
Sunday, July 23, 2023
Do not destroy the means of error-correction.
#106 – Embracing the automated future
Sunday, July 16, 2023
Why people will never be made redundant.
You Might Also Like
🎙️ Find That Pod #260
Friday, May 3, 2024
Check out these 5 great podcasts...and bring some awesomeness to your ears. Let's take a look at this week's recommendations. ADVERTISEMENT 5 great podcasts to discover… Welcome to the 260th
Around the Newsletter Universe (May Edition)
Friday, May 3, 2024
feed your inbox.
Where do you start?
Friday, May 3, 2024
We have 4 updates for you this week: 1. Where do you start improving your website? Congrats you want to improve your website performance. Everyone has their ideas on where to start. Your competitors
📌 Double Days Sale 📌 Promo Pins for Authors for a Limited Time
Friday, May 3, 2024
Advertise on Pinterest boards that get thousands of views/month Enable Images to See This PINTEREST PROMOS FOR AUTHORS & PUBLISHERS Enable Images to See This $30 for 30 Days of Pins! & ORDER BY
🎤 SWIPES Email (Friday May 3rd, 2024)
Friday, May 3, 2024
The SWIPES Email Edition: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 An educational (and fun) email by Copywriting Course. Enjoy! 🎤 Listen to this email here: Swipe: You know your Uncle Neville, he loves a good
Community Seats for Mai 2024 to Juli 2024
Friday, May 3, 2024
50 % off the Regular Price — Thank you for Being a Subscriber!
Don’t Do These 5 Things
Friday, May 3, 2024
How many of these things will you stop doing?
👷♂️ He scaled a business with 4-ton metal boxes
Thursday, May 2, 2024
We could hardly contain ourselves with this shipping container story… This Bob is building a BIG shipping container business Hey Contrarians, 5 years ago, Robert "Bob" Balderas made a U-turn
3-2-1: Simple ways to be at peace, the source of reputation, and finding unfair advantages
Thursday, May 2, 2024
3 ideas, 2 quotes, and 1 question to consider this week.
Ahrefs’ Digest #181: Why big companies make bad content, and more
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Our meme of the week: 📰 News & updates Google March 2024 core update is done: It actually finished on April 19th but Google didn't tell anyone until one week later. Google Publisher Center to