What is the standard for NBA disappointment?
Want to read every issue of Good Morning It’s Basketball, your favorite basketball writer’s favorite basketball newsletter? $5 per month or $50 per year and it’s yours. What is the standard for NBA disappointment?Looking at the NBA's 2023-24 tiers through the spectrum of what failure would mean.Good morning. Let’s basketball. Programming NoteThis regular season begins on Tuesday. So all next week — October 23 through October 27 — every issue of GOOD MORNING IT’S BASKETBALL will be unlocked (free) for all viewers. So if you are seeing this via social media, the Substack app or other shares, subscribe now to get all five opening week issues in your inbox or app. If you’re a paid subscriber, THANK YOU. Please share away next week when everything is unlocked. Measuring Future FailureThere are a thousand ways to sort NBA teams when previewing the a season. Folks will do straight-up rankings 1-30, or separate teams into tiers. Sometimes, analysts will focus in only on contenders, and try to determine which ones are real and which are not. Those are all valid, and I’ve done that in prior years. What I’m thinking about as we approach the 2023-24 season is what failure would be for each of the 30 teams. In other words, what’s the best outcome — in terms of playoff participation and the standings — that would still be disappointing when the season wraps up, based on where the teams are now. Let’s take a look. Obviously, the further up the ladder you start, landing in a much lower bucket will be especially painful. No Disappointment PossibleTeams for which there are no expectations to do anything but develop young players and set up for another high draft pick. Portland Trail Blazers I happen to think the Spurs will be more competitive than last season and could even stick around the play-in race. But I also don’t think that failing to meet that level will mark a disappointing season or anything. I think fans and possibly front office leaders in Portland and Washington want their teams to be among the three worst in the league. Being Out of the Play-in MixTeams for which not being in the race for a play-in spot in the second half of the season would be a disappointment. Charlotte Hornets These are teams that I think based on 2022-23 performance, roster structure, 2023 offseason moves and general preseason vibes would have some consternation about ending up with a bottom-5 record. Keep in mind that only four teams — the Pistons, Spurs, Rockets and Hornets — were truly not in the play-in race late in the season last year. You don’t have to be all that good to be, like, 12th in the conference. The Nets are an odd team in this conversation because they owe their first round pick to the Rockets. They are not necessarily built to compete, but they have no incentive to tank. The Jazz remain a question mark. They traded starters to fellow West playoff hopefuls at the trade deadline last season while in the play-in mix. But they also traded for John Collins and extended Jordan Clarkson. But to be a bottom-5 team, I think something will have to have gone wrong. Missing the Play-inNot making the play-in — or finishing top-10 in the conference — would be a disappointment Orlando Magic I feel like it’s impossible to set reasonable expectations for the Rockets given their status in recent years and the investment they made this summer. Is there a playoff mandate here? Or is the play-in enough? I know that less than 33 wins or so — which would slot a team into the “out of the play-in race” category — is probably a failure, so this feels like the right space for them. Orlando has a good amount of hype. They did last year too, and that hype survived a month or two. Sustain it longer, please! 10th in the East is not a particularly crazy demand. The Pacers hung around until injuries (or “injuries”) took them out of the play-in race. Maybe this is slightly too aggressive a standard for Indiana given how young most of the key players are. But I also don’t think a Tyrese Haliburton-led team should be below 33 wins. Missing the PlayoffsGetting ejected in the play-in or earlier is bad. Toronto Raptors Fun fact: only one of these teams (Atlanta) actually made the playoffs last season. So there is going to be some major disappointment, from these teams or those above them. Please also note that I have 20 teams at this level or better, and 16 teams make the playoffs, and there’s always a surprise or two. I toyed with the idea of bumping the Mavericks and Hawks up an additional level — that making the playoffs and getting ejected in the first round would actually be a disappointment. I’m open to that potentiality. But I also think that winning a playoff round in their current states is a really tough ask, and I don’t think that’s a fair baseline. Even though both teams were fairly recently in the conference finals. Bizarre teams! This might be a little aggressive for the Thunder, but the hype is so rampant. Losing in the First RoundWin a round or be sad. Cleveland Cavaliers We have three teams that lost in the first round last year, one team that won its first round series and a team that missed the playoffs entirely. That team — the Bulls — have been quite static and need to justify what they are doing. That means making the playoffs and doing something in them, in my mind. Otherwise, it’s time to pivot. The Knicks won a round last year, so you don’t want to go backwards (which “losing in the first round” would constitute). But I also don’t get the sense that there is a mandate to do more. Is this a conference finals team in the eyes of anyone but the most irrational fan? I’m not there. The other teams are relatively young and need to see progress. I think the pressure is highest for Cleveland given Donovan Mitchell’s future, but I also know there would be a good amount of gruff if Sacramento falls early again or Minnesota doesn’t take a step forward. Keep in mind too that missing the playoffs is possible for both teams and would be a massive disappointment. Missing the Conference FinalsYou have to escape the second round at minimum L.A. Clippers We know that the Clippers have been to the conference finals once in all of eternity. I think given the failures and troubles since then, getting back would mark a successful season, even if that’s not what anyone had in mind back in 2019. You know the story on the Sixers. Second round fail after second round fail. Just get past that and most is forgiven. Memphis is quietly in a weird zone: three straight playoffs, two straight 50-win seasons with a young core … one playoff series victory in that time. But I don’t think advancing to the second round will be quite enough here. I think they need to assert themselves as a legitimate West contender in the playoffs to feel like the right path is laid out. Losing in the Conference FinalsNot making the NBA Finals is falling short [no teams] This is a pretty weird gap in most years, I feel. It’s rare that “making the Finals” is a baseline expectation for a team. If you can make it, you should think you can win it! I guess this category becomes more relevant in eras when there is a clear superpower or two in the other conference, like during the Warriors dynasty. In that case, a franchise like the Raptors would have been satisfied to just get past the Cavaliers and lose in the Finals. Funny enough that after LeBron left, Toronto did make that leap … and then went ahead and won the Finals anyway. Not Winning the ChampionshipAnything less than a title is a seen as a failure Boston Celtics I don’t think this qualifies as the definitive list of NBA championship contenders this season — some of these teams in particular (Golden State and Miami, and perhaps L.A.) are not quite to the level of the others, but have the level of success over the past decade that requires a title to have had a successful season. Getting to the Finals isn’t enough. The standard is higher. This is obviously a huge bucket of teams going for it all … which I think is good for the NBA. There isn’t a hegemon (sorry Denver) so various franchises feel like they have a path. It makes for a lot of compelling regular season watching, in my view: every time these teams face each other is important. And when added with the number of teams that need to advance at least round in the playoffs to feel like the season is a success, it should make for quite a rowdy postseason. What do you think? Are any of these preseason expectations too harsh? Too light? The Preseason Fades OutAnthony Edwards, hello. This Ant pass is arguably a more important sign for where the Timberwolves are headed. Dudes keep trying Chet Holmgren and folks, that’s not a great idea. What a fun player... Keep reading with a 7-day free trialSubscribe to Good Morning It's Basketball to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.A subscription gets you:
|
Older messages
Work beef in the NBA dark ages
Thursday, October 19, 2023
A new history of Shaq and Kobe's feud leads to reflection on how the internet changes sports debate. PLUS: Steph Curry breaks my heart, again.
Victor and Chet, take the wheel
Tuesday, October 10, 2023
A deeply fulfilling preseason debut for our new 7-foot kings.
On the asymmetry of player movement in the NBA
Thursday, October 5, 2023
Sorry, no emo subject line here.
3 questions about the Damian Lillard trade
Thursday, September 28, 2023
One for each team involved.
It doesn't matter if Chris Paul is named a starter
Wednesday, September 27, 2023
Based on the Warriors' stars' typical availability, he'll be starting a lot of games regardless.
You Might Also Like
Holiday Giving Update ❄️
Friday, December 20, 2024
The Sportsletter Team Needs Your Help to Stay on the Field in 2025...
The Holiday Sports Primer 🎅
Friday, December 20, 2024
The Holiday Sports Wish-List: A Sneak Peek at the Next 3 Weeks in Sports...
The Matchday Preview
Friday, December 20, 2024
The final Bundesliga matchday before the winter break is here. A crucial relegation 6-pointer in Bochum, Bayern & Leipzig battle it out at the top of the table, & so much more! ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
The Sportsletter: Urgent Update 🚨
Thursday, December 19, 2024
The Team Needs Your Help to Stay on the Field in 2025...
Pop-Tarts & Power Rankings
Thursday, December 19, 2024
CFB Bowl Season Naming Rights Comedy. NBA & NHL Standings Check. Highlights & More...
Podcast app setup
Thursday, December 19, 2024
Open this on your phone and click the button below: Add to podcast app
Chapel Hill Bill & Red-Hot NBA Drama
Thursday, December 19, 2024
Bill Belichick Joins UNC. NBA Cup Drama Goes Viral. MLB Winter Meetings, UCL, NHL & More...
The NBA Cup is filled with JUICE
Thursday, December 19, 2024
Two more compelling games with recently bad teams moving on to the semifinals. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Don’t Wait ‘Til The Clock Runs Out
Thursday, December 19, 2024
The Sportsletter's Holiday Gift Guide DEC
💰 Team Values & Friday Highlights
Thursday, December 19, 2024
Forbes Top-50 Sports List. TNF Kick Game. Hero Hidalgo. CFB Awards. LeBron/Bronny & More...