Trapital - One time for the blog era

Hip-hop blogs were an organic moment for music discovery and curation. That's hard to replicate in the streaming era.

Weekly article | May 28 | Read in browser

Hey. Hope you enjoyed the long holiday weekend. It's was great to take a few days and recharge.

The recent murders of black people in the U.S. have been top of mind. My heart goes out to the families of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and Ahmed Aubrey. It's a sad and scary time. May they rest in peace. If you are interested in supporting, check out the Minnesota Freedom Fund.

Here's this week's article:

Why Hip-Hop Fans Miss the Blog Era

Hip-hop blogs were an organic moment for music discovery and curation. That's hard to replicate in the streaming era.

In the late 2000s, hip-hop blogs were the chief curators for rising talent. One post could elevate an unknown artist to a subculture of hungry fans. Blogs attracted a group of millennials who embraced the internet well before the music industry. Drake, J. Cole, and Kendrick Lamar have each paid respect to the websites that put them on when they were coming up.

Blogs were more than a place to find new music. They were an experience. Each site had its community. The desire for those experiences is as strong as ever, especially in the streaming era. Other outlets have since taken their place, but it's not the same.

Blogs were the spot for discovery and curation

In the Napster days, the internet showed its potential in music distribution. Piracy was rampant, but the opportunity was clear. With a quick search and a bit of patience, users could access any song they wanted.

The process was convenient, but it was one-sided. There wasn't much discovery or curation on those peer-to-peer file sharing platforms. The only new thing I "discovered" on Limewire was 1) a virus that ruined my computer, or 2) hearing 'AOL Music, first listen' on a song I just downloaded. Then I would try to get a different version of the song and boom, there it is again! I'm convinced AOL was up to some trickery but that's another story for another Trapital article.

Blogs soon emerged at the nexus of distribution, discovery, curation. Sites like Nah Right and 2DopeBoyz were launched by hip-hop fans who wanted to highlight dope music from up-and-comers.

They gave artists a platform who would have struggled without it. At the time, record labels could easily ignore an unproven artist rhyming about Sonic the Hedgehog. But in the blog era, Charles Hamilton could build his following and use it as leverage for a deal with Interscope. The same goes for The Cool Kids and other alternative rap acts that didn't fit the mainstream.

Here's 2DopeBoyz founder Meka Udoh in a 2011 interview with Black Enterprise:

We’ve never fallen into that ideal that either posting a video of two idiots in the ghetto fighting or being financially backed by a major label, then have the audacity to claim we’re “documenting the culture" would make us successful or influential. Shining a light to the under-the-radar [artist] was more important to us than a Gucci Mane shout out. The site was started when two friends with vastly different musical tastes decided to start a site to spotlight what we liked, and by the grace of whatever deity watches over us, it became a success.

At its peak, 2DopeBoyz attracted 1 million monthly unique visitors. Those visitors became valuable superfans. They were up on the latest and took pride in it. Remember, blogs peaked at the height of the hipster era. There was social capital in being up on trends before others. Blog curators gave superfans confidence that a rising artist was worth investing in.

It turned into two-sided experience. Artists needed superfans to spread the word to other hip-hop fans. Superfans needed artists to deliver good music so they can enjoy and share with friends. Everybody won.

Here's Drake in 2009 reflecting on So Far Gone, a product of the blog era.

Curation is art, not science

The streaming era's first answer to curation was playlists. Spotify's RapCaviar is the flagship playlist that has gotten the most of the attention. I've written favorably about it in the past, but I've missed some key points.

Here's what I wrote last year:

"Spotify has built an economic moat with RapCaviar. The playlist’s size is an advantage that demonstrates power, which begets more features, bigger artists profiled, and richer data. It’s a competitive advantage that’s hard to match.

Going head-to-head with RapCaviar is a tall task. Instead, Apple Music, Tidal, and Amazon need to focus on their strengths."

I still believe RapCaviar has a relative advantage over other digital streaming providers playlists. But "economic moat" was a bit much.

By design, Spotify's curation is taken with a grain of salt for several reasons. First, Spotify is seen as an extension of the music industry. There are ownership stakes and revenue sharing agreements with the major record labels. Spotify is the reason why the labels bounced back from the decline in the 2000s. It's not the independent voice that blogs were.

Second, playlists are influenced by algorithms. Although the weekly playlists are curated by people, streaming data is inevitably factored in. Even if the algorithmic recommendations are accurate, they can't match the word of mouth power that drove blogs. Third, Spotify is heavily criticized for not paying artists enough. It adds to the perception that the company cares more about labels than artists. Blogs never had that problem.

Additionally, there's no community among playlist followers. Listeners and artists can't interact on most digital streaming providers. And even if they could, a "top hits" playlist with 12 million followers isn't a community. RapCaviar has held pop-up events and concerts to bring folks together, but those events are few and far between.

Curation is a challenge in video streaming too. Netflix's Strong Black Lead initiative highlights black cinema. It curates what's available, but there's an incentive to highlight original Netflix programming.

In 2018 Goldman Sachs interview, media mogul Peter Chernin spoke about the challenge of algorithms and curation with regards to Netflix:

“I’d be curious how many people have ever watched something because Netflix recommended it algorithmically. I don’t think it happens that often… It’s mostly word of mouth or your friends have told you, but there’s gotta be a better way to give consumers information and curation to what they want to watch at any given time. And I think it’s a big chokepoint in the entire industry.”

This is a challenge that rap blogs helped solve. The mainstream trends have shifted us away from this, but it's taken a different form today.

Wiz Khalifa's Kush & OJ (2010) was another memorable project from the blog era.

The "new" curators

Ironically, we're back to square one. Napster, BearShare, and Limewire got replaced by Spotify, Apple Music, and SoundCloud. We addressed the piracy, security issues, and the damn 'AOL Music' drops. But there's still a curation opportunity.

Technically, the same blogs still exist. 2DopeBoyz is still active. Complex acquired several of the New Music Cartel blogs and have kept them going. But they are no longer needed for artist exposure in the age of SoundCloud and social media.

Curation has shifted too. Today's rising voices are podcasters and YouTubers. Look at DJ Akademiks. He's a polarizing figure, but he built an audience on YouTube and expanded it to the show Everyday Struggle. Similarly, his former co-host Joe Budden built a community with The Joe Budden Podcast (a Spotify exclusive). When Budden praises new music, it drives listeners to check it out. When Budden hates on "the Lils" for not respecting hip-hop, it drives listeners to check it out too.

Slowly but surely, Spotify wants to corner the market. It's on an aggressive quest to become the home for audio. The company wants to control the distribution of music, the curation of playlists, and exclusivity with the personalities who influence what gets listened to. The strategy is smart. But even if it succeeds, it can't capture the organic experience that existed before it.


It's almost impossible to recreate the fondness that millennials have for the blog era. Everyone loves what was popular when they were coming-of-age. Nostalgia always sells. Blogs were popular enough to ensure that readers weren't alone, but not so popular that they were mainstream. It was a perfect balance.

Today's curators are everywhere. They're on a wide range of media outlets. They have niche audiences and followers who listen. The dynamic has evolved. But the "YouTube era" or "podcast era" doesn't have the same ring to it.

Enjoy this article? Forward it to a friend. Share on Twitter. Post on LinkedIn. Keep that word of mouth going.

SHARE TRAPITAL WITH A FRIEND

Enjoying Trapital? Refer 1 person to the Trapital email list, you'll get 1 free month of Trapital membership.

You can share your personal referral link here via Twitter, LinkedIn, or copy and paste the link below and send to someone who will enjoy this:

https://trapital.co?rh_ref=42ec780e

If you've already referred one person, there are additional referral bonuses here!

SHOUTOUTS

@magdalenakala: Shout-out to the peeps that make me smarter w/ their newsletters: @RuncieDan on hip hop

Pantera Capital: thanks for plugging How Hip-Hop Helped Cash App Grow Faster in your Blockchain Blog.


Was this email forwarded to you? sign up here.
Want more Trapital? Subscribe to the Trapital Podcast.


Text me at +1 (415) 234-3074
Email me at info@trapital.co

Your membership makes Trapital possible. Become a Trapitalist today.

Older messages

The infamous split

Wednesday, May 20, 2020

Revisiting the Jay Z-Dame Dash Roc-a-Fella split and the ownership vs partnership tradeoff. Trapital Weekly Article. Weekly article | May 20 | Read in browser Want more Trapital? Become a member. Learn

Remembering Andre Harrell

Thursday, May 14, 2020

The late music executive turned Uptown Records into a lifestyle. Trapital Weekly Article. Weekly article | May 14 | Read in browser Hey, hope your week is going well. Last Friday, music executive Andre

Hip-hop philanthropy ain't easy

Thursday, May 7, 2020

Many artists are eager to use their platform to give back, but effective philanthropy takes focus and alignment. Weekly article | May 7 | Read in browser Hey! I hope you're week's been great. I

Why bad deals get signed

Wednesday, May 6, 2020

 An interview with entertainment attorney Tiffany Ballard. Trapital Podcast. Hey there, This week I spoke to entertainment attorney Tiffany Ballard. If you follow Genius, you've likely seen her on

Hip-hop's gaming opportunity

Wednesday, April 29, 2020

Travis Scott's Fortnite event showed what's possible, but there are more opportunities out there. Weekly article | April 29 | Read in browser Hey! Thanks for the great feedback on last

You Might Also Like

Animated ‘Flow’s Surprising Spring At The Specialty Box Office

Sunday, November 24, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 24, 2024 Animated 'Flow's Surprising Spring At The Specialty Box Office By Jill Goldsmith This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by Deadline.

RFK Jr.'s 10 Wildest Medical Theories

Sunday, November 24, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 24, 2024 RFK Jr.'s 10 Wildest Medical Theories From fluoride to Covid-19, Trump's pick to head the Department of Health and Human Services has

‘Wicked’ Casts $164M+ Spell In Global Opening; ‘Gladiator II’ Thunders To $221M WW After 2nd Offshore Frame - International Box Office

Sunday, November 24, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 24, 2024 'Wicked' Casts $164M+ Spell In Global Opening; 'Gladiator II' Thunders To $221M WW After 2nd Offshore Frame - International Box

Sammy Hagar Wants Peace With Alex Van Halen

Saturday, November 23, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 23, 2024 Sammy Hagar Wants Peace With Alex Van Halen: 'I Will Not Take This to My Grave' Red Rocker also reveals that he's written a new song with

Camerimage: ‘The Girl With The Needle’ Takes Golden Frog — Full Winners List

Saturday, November 23, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 23, 2024 Camerimage: 'The Girl With The Needle' Takes Golden Frog - Full Winners List By Zac Ntim This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by

‘Wicked’ On Way To $165M Global Opening - International Box Office

Saturday, November 23, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 23, 2024 'Wicked' On Way To $165M Global Opening - International Box Office By Nancy Tartaglione This email was sent to newsletterest1@gmail.com by

Kendrick Lamar Addresses Super Bowl Drama on 'GNX'

Friday, November 22, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 22, 2024 Kendrick Lamar Addresses Super Bowl Drama and Five Other Takeaways From 'GNX' The surprise album is Kendrick's first official release

Documentaries Flow With ‘Porcelain War’, ‘Ernest Cole’, ‘Sabbath Queen’, ‘Bread and Roses’ – Specialty Preview

Friday, November 22, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 22, 2024 Documentaries Flow With 'Porcelain War', 'Ernest Cole', 'Sabbath Queen', 'Bread & Roses' - Specialty Preview By

Wayfarer Studios Sets Nationwide Release For Michael Chiklis Sports Drama 'The Senior'

Friday, November 22, 2024

View on web New reader? Subscribe November 22, 2024 Wayfarer Studios Sets Nationwide Release For Michael Chiklis Sports Drama 'The Senior' By Matt Grobar This email was sent to newsletterest1@

New Music This Week from Kim Deal, Opeth, Father John Misty, The Beatles and More.

Friday, November 22, 2024

The AllMusic New Release Newsletter New Releases for November 22, 2024 Here are the AllMusic editors' picks for the most noteworthy releases this week. Looking for more? Visit our New Releases page