Men Will Literally Have Completely Different Mental Processes Instead Of Going To Therapy
People are debating “therapy: good or bad?” again: It honestly boggles my mind that non rich people are willing to drop ~$100 on a single therapy session
Just seems like such a bad ROI
I feel bad for people culturally coerced into spending their money on this @bastard_brian i can trace 90% of my current income and a fair amount of my current lifestyle competence to a couple of sessions with @SparksRemarks, and, as we know, performance coaches are actually just therapists therapy is simply talking to a person, which is how it can be either insanely OP or completely ineffective or anything in between There are dozens of kinds of therapy: reliving your traumas, practicing mindfulness, analyzing dreams, uncovering your latent desire to have sex with your mother. But most people on both sides of this debate are talking about what psychiatrists call “supportive therapy” - unstructured talking about your feelings and what’s going on in your life. I know the responsible thing to say is something like “this is helpful for some people but not others”. I will say that, in the end. But I have a lot of sympathy for the people debating it. I have such a strong intuition of “why would this possibly work?” that it’s always shocked me when other people say it does. And I know other people with such a strong intuition of “obviously this would work!” that it shocks them to hear other people even question it. Yet my patients seem to line up about half and half: some of them find therapy really great, others not helpful at all. Whenever I try to understand this, I find myself coming back to this tweet: Qiaochu is a smart person with various impressive academic accomplishments, all of which are . . . apparently compatible with being the person who would write this. And I hear weird stuff like this all the time. An equally accomplished friend told me at one point that “I was fifteen when it occurred to me for the first time that I had a personality”. I’ve previously written about a friend who was in their late teens/early twenties before they realized they could have food preferences. I don’t want to exaggerate this. Regardless of what he says, I’m sure Qiaochu thought about and solved problems as a college student - if nothing else, responding to problems like “it’s cold outside” with solutions like “maybe I should get a jacket”. But I trust him when he says he was lacking some kind of essential reflectivity or systematicity about it or something along those lines. If you have no ability to systematically think about and solve your problems, you should probably tell all your problems immediately to someone who does, and maybe this person could be a therapist. But also: people vary really widely in their ability to do something sort of like hold a conversation with themselves - for example, some people totally lack an inner monologue. Nobody has ever checked if those people benefit from therapy more, and I don’t want to actively predict that they would. But I know that I talk things over with myself a lot. Does this help me stay emotionally stable? Not sure; seems plausible. If I didn’t have an inner monologue, maybe the only way I could get that same effect would be by talking them over with another person. Other people obsessively seek external reassurance. I talked here about the phenomenon of hypochondriacs who go to their doctor to be told that their latest concern (maybe the 25th time they had a certain symptom) isn’t worth worrying about, same as the last 24 times. They’re not even asking for an x-ray or something! They’re just happy to hear the doctor say the words “given that your last 24 symptoms were nothing, I’m assuming this one isn’t anything either”. Then they are delighted and go home! I sometimes think about this by analogy to “you can’t tickle yourself” - some people can’t reassure themselves either, and are very happy to hear thoughts they could have easily generated themselves coming from other people’s mouths. Are these some of the people who benefit from therapy? Seems plausible. I worry this will come across as “everyone who benefits from therapy is defective in some sort of basic human functioning.” That’s not quite the message I want to send - partly because there are lots of other reasons therapy can benefit people, but partly because I suspect everyone is defective in some sort of basic human functioning, regardless of whether they like therapy or not. Instead, think of it as: there’s wide variation in the details of people’s minds and thought processes - even smart competent people who you would really expect to have all the basic human skills. Probably some kinds of thought process make you more likely to benefit from supportive therapy, and others make you less likely. Nobody’s studied this and it’s all just speculation, but I think it’s reasonable speculation. You’re a free subscriber to Astral Codex Ten. For the full experience, become a paid subscriber. |
Older messages
Contra Hoel On Aristocratic Tutoring
Tuesday, March 22, 2022
...
Mantic Monday 3/21/22
Monday, March 21, 2022
...
Open Thread 216
Monday, March 21, 2022
...
Highlights From The Comments On Zulresso
Wednesday, March 16, 2022
...
Justice Creep
Wednesday, March 16, 2022
...
You Might Also Like
The Moisturizers Our Writers Actually Buy
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Including options for oily, combination, and “so dry it cracks post-shower” skin. Every product is independently selected by editors. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an
The Airlines’ Secret Billion-Dollar Refund Racket Is Set To End
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Airlines won't say how much they make from unused flight credits, but potential automatic refunds could hurt their massive windfall. Read below to learn how airlines could be on the verge of losing
Stormy Daniels, Whale Blabber, and Robot Snails
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Facts, without motives.
☕ Level the playing field
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
5G football helmet aids in breaking comms barriers. May 08, 2024 Tech Brew SPONSORED BY Upway It's Wednesday. AT&T developed a prototype football helmet to help deaf and hard-of-hearing players
Unlearning Covid’s lessons
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Plus: Eurovision, third places, and more May 8, 2024 View in browser Good morning! Are you worried about bird flu (or something else) becoming the next pandemic? Today, senior correspondent Dylan Scott
UPDATE: Congressman Collins feels the heat
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Last Friday, Congressman Mike Collins (R-GA) endorsed the conduct of student counterprotesters at the University of Mississippi. Collins posted a video on X showing a counterprotester heckling a Black
Numlock News: May 8, 2024 • Sunscreen, Warhammer, Red vs. Blue
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
By Walt Hickey I'm going on my honeymoon at the end of the month and we'll be having guest writers during the actual anniversary of the newsletter, so we're starting the annual promo early
☕ TikTok vs. Uncle Sam
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Plans for Saudi Arabia's futuristic city go awry… May 08, 2024 View Online | Sign Up | Shop Morning Brew PRESENTED BY GolfSuites Good morning. We'd wish you a Happy Hump Day, but for most of
Trump Trial Put Off, Diving Into a Black Hole, and Boy Scouts Change Name
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Former President Trump's classified documents case was delayed indefinitely Tuesday by the judge, in part over issues related to possible mishandling of the documents by prosecutors. ͏ ͏ ͏ ͏
Cops finally unmask 'LockBit kingpin' after two-month tease [Wed May 8 2024]
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
Hi The Register Subscriber | Log in The Register {* Daily Headlines *} 8 May 2024 Handout of Dmitry Yuryevich Khoroshev from NCA Cops finally unmask 'LockBit kingpin' after two-month tease