The Amazing Things & Ideas - The Price of “Free”
The default condition of humanity is poverty, not wealth. What many people now consider as “basic human needs” were, at best, luxuries as recently as 200 years ago. Decent housing, vaccines that protect against disease, medicines that cure sickness, books for a good education—generations of humans died without having ever conceived of the possibility of these things. Take the Black Death, for example. This devastating pandemic, which swept through Europe in the 14th century, killed millions of people at a time when the concepts of vaccines and effective medicines were nonexistent. People of that era could hardly imagine the possibility of medical interventions that could prevent or cure diseases, much less consider them basic needs. As much as anyone might wish otherwise, one cannot escape economic scarcity. There are always trade-offs. To call something a “need” suggests it is infinitely valuable. However, there always comes a point at which the further expenditure of time and resources spent consuming any good or service exceeds the value of the improvement or benefit it provides. Where that point occurs depends on the subjective valuation of the person choosing to or refraining from buying the good or service at a specific price. Consider Bob at the supermarket, facing the meat aisle with a tight budget. He loves beef for its taste and nutritional value, making it a regular part of his shopping list. However, due to inflation, the price of beef has surged significantly, prompting him to reconsider his options. Because of the additional cost, Bob reevaluates the trade-off: Is the pleasure and nutrition from beef worth the higher price, or could those resources be better spent? Spotting the soy products, a cheaper and versatile protein alternative, Bob decides that the rising cost of beef no longer justifies its value over soy. This choice reflects a personal valuation of goods based on scarcity and the necessity of trade-offs. Individuals or groups often use the word “needs” as a rhetorical tactic to portray their subjective desires as objective necessities. Anyone with an understanding of basic economics knows that this is merely sophistry. People choose the means by which to attain their “needs” (and to what extent) based on value judgments and the costs of alternative desires (opportunity cost). Take healthcare, for example. There’s no doubt that medicine contributes to physical survival. So, should it be free for everyone who “needs” it? Some argue that it should. But nothing, even in our modern world of comparative luxury, is truly “free”. When someone says something should be free, they mean it should be paid for by someone else (if only in practice, if not in intent). In 2022, the National Health Expenditure (NHE) in the United States reached approximately $4.5 trillion, or about $13,493 per person, and accounted for 17.3% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). These figures underscore the economic realities behind the healthcare debate. When discussing “free” healthcare, it’s essential to recognize that these costs are absorbed by taxpayers, whether through increased taxes, government borrowing, or reallocating funds from other public services. Since we don’t live in the Garden of Eden, medicine, like anything else that is scarce, has a cost—a price that has to be paid even if the government labels it “free”. If we think of healthcare as a “need”, we will entertain consuming it at any price, however large, for any improvement in health, however small. Of course, even the government has to deal with economic reality, so they can’t shift all of the economy’s resources to healthcare. Notice how vague the term “need” here really is. If we accept the concept of needs (based on the moral premise that “needs must be met”), we also implicitly accept the morality of having decisions concerning those needs made for us by someone else—in our age, that typically means the state. Whenever someone talks about giving someone something they need without earning profits, it is almost always a way of changing things for others without their consent.
Follow me on X: @arjunkhemani Click here to support my work. |
Older messages
#27 – Farbood Nivi: Follistatin Gene Therapy, E/Acc, and Following Your Heart
Saturday, March 23, 2024
Watch now (70 mins) | Farbood Nivi is the founder of Grockit (acquired by Kaplan in 2013). He has been biohacking for 25 years. Recently, he became one of the first 200 people in the world to receive
It’s Impossible to Justify Predictions from Evidence. Here’s Why.
Thursday, March 21, 2024
Imagine a chicken on a farm who sees the farmer bring it food every morning. Every day, the chicken watches the farmer come with food, making it think that the farmer always brings food. But one day,
#26 – Jeremy Shearmur: Epistemology, Austrian economics, and The Life of Karl Popper
Monday, February 19, 2024
Listen now (84 mins) | Jeremy Shearmur is a fellow emeritus in philosophy at the Australian National University. He is the author of Hayek and After and The Political Thought of Karl Popper. He also
The Not So Good Old Days
Sunday, February 4, 2024
“[T]he sage gave him the history of man in a single line; it was this: he was born, he suffered, and he died. […] Life was insignificant and death without consequence.” — W. Somerset Maugham, Of Human
#25 – David Deutsch: Free-Will, Taking Children Seriously, and Anarcho-Capitalism
Monday, January 1, 2024
Watch now (41 mins) | David Deutsch is the author of The Fabric of Reality and The Beginning of Infinity. He works on fundamental issues in physics, particularly the quantum theory of computation and
You Might Also Like
🎙️ Find That Pod #260
Friday, May 3, 2024
Check out these 5 great podcasts...and bring some awesomeness to your ears. Let's take a look at this week's recommendations. ADVERTISEMENT 5 great podcasts to discover… Welcome to the 260th
Around the Newsletter Universe (May Edition)
Friday, May 3, 2024
feed your inbox.
Where do you start?
Friday, May 3, 2024
We have 4 updates for you this week: 1. Where do you start improving your website? Congrats you want to improve your website performance. Everyone has their ideas on where to start. Your competitors
📌 Double Days Sale 📌 Promo Pins for Authors for a Limited Time
Friday, May 3, 2024
Advertise on Pinterest boards that get thousands of views/month Enable Images to See This PINTEREST PROMOS FOR AUTHORS & PUBLISHERS Enable Images to See This $30 for 30 Days of Pins! & ORDER BY
🎤 SWIPES Email (Friday May 3rd, 2024)
Friday, May 3, 2024
The SWIPES Email Edition: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 An educational (and fun) email by Copywriting Course. Enjoy! 🎤 Listen to this email here: Swipe: You know your Uncle Neville, he loves a good
Community Seats for Mai 2024 to Juli 2024
Friday, May 3, 2024
50 % off the Regular Price — Thank you for Being a Subscriber!
Don’t Do These 5 Things
Friday, May 3, 2024
How many of these things will you stop doing?
👷♂️ He scaled a business with 4-ton metal boxes
Thursday, May 2, 2024
We could hardly contain ourselves with this shipping container story… This Bob is building a BIG shipping container business Hey Contrarians, 5 years ago, Robert "Bob" Balderas made a U-turn
3-2-1: Simple ways to be at peace, the source of reputation, and finding unfair advantages
Thursday, May 2, 2024
3 ideas, 2 quotes, and 1 question to consider this week.
Ahrefs’ Digest #181: Why big companies make bad content, and more
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Our meme of the week: 📰 News & updates Google March 2024 core update is done: It actually finished on April 19th but Google didn't tell anyone until one week later. Google Publisher Center to