#118 – Inequality is Not a Problem, Poverty is
Inequality has become synonymous with injustice in popular rhetoric. Advocates for equality of outcome forget that attempts to enforce equality necessarily lead to inequality. They lead to the most dangerous inequality of all—inequality of power. Rothbard rightly called egalitarianism a “revolt against nature”. Since people are in no way equal, a central authority (usually the State) must treat people unequally to place them in the same position¹. To understand the rationale behind egalitarianism, imagine a situation where a person with a fractured leg seeks medical help. Rather than treating the injury, the doctor intentionally fractures the legs of ten other people. The doctor justifies this action by stating it will alleviate the original patient’s discomfort by creating a sense of equality among them. Egalitarians view wealth as a fixed pie, believing that rich people have acquired their wealth by stealing from others. But since wealth is created and is not a fixed pie, inequality of wealth or income is morally irrelevant. One helps the poor by lifting them up, not by pushing down those who are rich. The real problem is extreme poverty; that’s what we need to solve, not inequality. Without inequality, there is no opportunity for trade, no opportunity for progress, no opportunity for anything good. True equality will be a catastrophe. We will only have perfectly achieved this ideal when we are all dead. Such is the anti-human vision of the egalitarian. As Tom Hyde has written, in a free market, wealth inequality is good for the poor. People, given a choice, would rather be poor in a world with some degree of inequality than be poor in a world where everyone else is equally poor, resulting in zero inequality. Inequality means opportunities and potential for the poor to engage in trade and excel alongside wealthy partners. The alternative to wealth inequality, though, is inevitably poverty equality. Some might argue that when they speak of equality, they are actually referring to “equality of opportunity”. However, the practical meaning of this concept remains ambiguous. The closest we can get is a world in which individuals are free to pursue what they perceive as paths to happiness, progress, and prosperity without facing arbitrary interference or forced restrictions. Follow me on X: @arjunkhemani Click here to support my work. 1 For a great illustration of this point, see Kurt Vonnegut’s short story “Harrison Bergeron” |
Older messages
The Altruism Trap: How Self-Sacrifice Stymies Progress
Sunday, October 29, 2023
If everyone sacrificed their own happiness for the happiness of others, no one would be happy.
#116 – The Religion of Science
Sunday, October 8, 2023
Addressing a form of zealotry that is cloaked in the guise of science.
#115 – The Myth of the Compromise
Sunday, October 1, 2023
The notion of compromise often receives praise as a virtuous middle ground, a means for rationally resolving conflicts and maintaining harmony. It is the balanced solution where everyone gets a little
#114 – Conversations About Economic Illiteracy and Critical Rationalism
Sunday, September 24, 2023
Interviews with Per Bylund and Tom Hyde.
#113 – The real culprit of consumerism
Sunday, September 17, 2023
Ironically, behavior induced by government intervention gets labeled as “consumerism”, yet the blame often erroneously falls on capitalism and free markets.
You Might Also Like
Around the Newsletter Universe (May Edition)
Friday, May 3, 2024
feed your inbox.
Where do you start?
Friday, May 3, 2024
We have 4 updates for you this week: 1. Where do you start improving your website? Congrats you want to improve your website performance. Everyone has their ideas on where to start. Your competitors
📌 Double Days Sale 📌 Promo Pins for Authors for a Limited Time
Friday, May 3, 2024
Advertise on Pinterest boards that get thousands of views/month Enable Images to See This PINTEREST PROMOS FOR AUTHORS & PUBLISHERS Enable Images to See This $30 for 30 Days of Pins! & ORDER BY
🎤 SWIPES Email (Friday May 3rd, 2024)
Friday, May 3, 2024
The SWIPES Email Edition: Friday, May 3rd, 2024 An educational (and fun) email by Copywriting Course. Enjoy! 🎤 Listen to this email here: Swipe: You know your Uncle Neville, he loves a good
Community Seats for Mai 2024 to Juli 2024
Friday, May 3, 2024
50 % off the Regular Price — Thank you for Being a Subscriber!
Don’t Do These 5 Things
Friday, May 3, 2024
How many of these things will you stop doing?
👷♂️ He scaled a business with 4-ton metal boxes
Thursday, May 2, 2024
We could hardly contain ourselves with this shipping container story… This Bob is building a BIG shipping container business Hey Contrarians, 5 years ago, Robert "Bob" Balderas made a U-turn
3-2-1: Simple ways to be at peace, the source of reputation, and finding unfair advantages
Thursday, May 2, 2024
3 ideas, 2 quotes, and 1 question to consider this week.
Ahrefs’ Digest #181: Why big companies make bad content, and more
Thursday, May 2, 2024
Our meme of the week: 📰 News & updates Google March 2024 core update is done: It actually finished on April 19th but Google didn't tell anyone until one week later. Google Publisher Center to
When It's Better Not to Share Where Things are Made
Thursday, May 2, 2024
When marketing backfires